Necrotica
06.11.13 | Honorable mention: Possessed - Seven Churches at #11 |
demigod!
06.11.13 | altars
human
severed survival
|
evilford
06.11.13 | worst death album is only death album on list sweet |
Artuma
06.11.13 | Human has to be my #1 but Close to a World Below comes pretty damn close, great list |
demigod!
06.11.13 | evilfords comment [2] |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | I still never understand the TSOP hate and the insane amount of Altars praise, but whatever |
evilford
06.11.13 | I don't hate tsop at all I just think every other album death made is better
I would think altars would speak for itself but idk |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | I still give Altars a 4, but I wouldn't bump it up to a 4.5 or 5 |
MO
06.11.13 | nice list |
thumbcrusher
06.11.13 | 2's guitar tone is like omg |
demigod!
06.11.13 | listen to altars baked |
evilford
06.11.13 | never heard a few of these. I agree that CTAWB def belongs in top 5
NSV has never really been in my top 10-15 or anything like that but I guess I'm the odd duck out on that one |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | Human and Altars would make this list just as generic as any other list of this nature anyway. I wanted to include some of my underrated favorites on here to give something a bit more fresh |
recycledcopier
06.11.13 | good job picking ten albums that aren't even the best albums by the bands listed. |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | But yeah, different strokes for different folks |
demigod!
06.11.13 | the lack of atheist and cynic is baffling |
evilford
06.11.13 | "good job picking ten albums that aren't even the best albums by the bands listed."
lol |
evilford
06.11.13 | if you're compromising your actual opinion on which albums are best in order to avoid appearing "generic" to the less-educated, it kind of defeats the purpose of making the list in the first place right? |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | No, I was explaining how I'm not going to conform to what everybody wants me to put on here. This is my honest
opinion of what I think are the best dm albums. I'm not going to change it to appease other people who want me to
alter it |
RunOfTheMill
06.11.13 | Yeah Orchid rules, good stuff. |
evilford
06.11.13 | fair enough
don't assume that people who put human or altars on their list are, either |
Atari
06.11.13 | sweet list bro |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | @evilford: I'm definitely not. I just like switching things up a bit. 'Tis all opinion anyway :] |
evilford
06.11.13 | [size=+53290837061890398501]:][/size] |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | I'm not, that's why I kept the list the way it was :P |
evilford
06.11.13 | I never said he's "wrong". it is all opinion obviously. I'm just trying to understand if/why people think that anyone who does put the "popular" picks (i.e. human, altars, symbolic, etc) on their lists are necessarily doing it to conform to what their list is "supposed to have" or whatever. like maybe lots of people just think those albums are that good and belong there for a reason, regardless of their amount of prestige. |
evilford
06.11.13 | /complaining
good list tho |
Necrotica
06.11.13 | Yeah, and besides, I still included plenty of standards too like None So Vile, Close to a World Below, TSOP, etc. If I had
none of the popular classics that'd be pretty fucking ridiculous |
Gyromania
06.11.13 | good list |
70sPriestIsBetter
06.11.13 | immortal rites -> suffocation
>
rapture -> pain divine
by a landslide |
mandan
06.11.13 | 3 rules, and 9 is pretty cool.
I'm surprised that KILL, TheNotrap and Hawks haven't commented on here. |
DikkoZinner
06.11.13 | Not a fan of Incantation?
|
mandan
06.11.13 | ^Nah, you can't be a KILL alt. He's got quite a few, but no. |
mandan
06.11.13 | @lately: does KILL prefer Megadeth or Metallica? |
evilford
06.11.13 | that doesn't prove anything, everyone knows that |
mandan
06.11.13 | Good, good. Is there a Rush album KILL dislikes? |
mandan
06.11.13 | Sorry lately, but I can't believe you. In my eyes, you are not KILL. |
70sPriestIsBetter
06.11.13 | lately you misinterpreted my comment
immortal rites followed by suffocation > rapture followed by pain divine |
DikkoZinner
06.11.13 | Rapture best on that album, "In Rapture I'm Reborn".... |
VinesOvThorn
06.11.13 | Only 1,2, and 6 belong.
Neg'd. |
70sPriestIsBetter
06.11.13 | wheres gnome sink already |
70sPriestIsBetter
06.11.13 | yes you are |
Trebor.
06.11.13 | 1 is boring |
70sPriestIsBetter
06.11.13 | damn bro all this hype for nothing, consider the faith lost |
Cygnatti
06.11.13 | unquestionable presence. :D |
evilford
06.11.13 | "1 is boring"
dude |
Necrotica
06.12.13 | :/ but it's awesome |
mandan
06.12.13 | KILL has 1 4.5'd, which means you're not him lately.
Who will you pose as next time? |
recycledcopier
06.12.13 | But Unholy Cult is better... |
Cygnatti
06.12.13 | "1 is boring"
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=344056455720795&set=vb.148748665308628&type=2&theater |
Necrotica
06.12.13 | ^ that |
DirtyDan
06.12.13 | Props for number 4 man |
alachlahol
06.12.13 | not what id put in my top 10! props for being an individual! |
Keyblade
06.12.13 | major props for 4 man, but by that point I wouldn't really call them dm anymore (if you could call them that in the first place)...still an excellent band. |
Dodecahedron
06.12.13 | Eppur Si Muove.. niice. One of my favorites. |
Necrotica
06.12.13 | @Keyblade: Yeah, I was cautious on that one. I still consider them DM, but just barely when considering their other genres. Fantastic stuff though |
DrHouseSchuldiner
06.12.13 | 4 rules |
Necrotica
06.12.13 | Hellyeah, doomy as fuck |
Trebor.
06.12.13 | I like metal that riffs, and 1 doesn't riff |
evilford
06.12.13 | wow |
DikkoZinner
06.12.13 | 1 wins this list |
DikkoZinner
06.12.13 | or 5 |
NapalmCrusader
06.12.13 | Where is slaughter of the soul and the of opeth listed here should be still life |
Necrotica
06.13.13 | ^ Eh, I like melodeath but Carcass is the only artist I'd consider above the rest in that regard at the moment |
Artuma
06.13.13 | should be still life [2] |
ProfessorVeerappan
06.13.13 | Hell yeah a crazy list including massive death metal artists
but a few here and there
1.At the Gates
2.Benighted
3.Ulcerate
4.Gorguts
5.In mourning |
BallsToTheWall
06.14.13 | Not a standard sputnik list so i'll give you credit for that, |
BlackLlama
06.14.13 | Opeth does not belong on a "best death metal" list : Deicide > |
PortraitsOfDecay
06.14.13 | 3 was the first death metal album I've ever heard, so that one's easily my favorite album they released. 6 is #1 for me though. Looks like I'll have to check out 4 and 10. |
Matthaios
06.21.13 | Love seing Sound Of Perseverance on there, one of my all time favourite albums. Interesting pick for Opeth though, I personally think Still Life is their best observation. |
BigPleb
06.21.13 | Altars of Madness? |
Keyblade
06.21.13 | list rules cuz 4 |
Necrotica
06.28.13 | ^ Agreed so much. What's with this Immolation hate? :/ |
OhCarrots
09.07.13 | agreed |
evilford
09.07.13 | '"I like metal that riffs, and 1 doesn't riff"
.....what in all fuck??'
Yeah. If ever there were an objectively wrong statement in regards to music, that's it.
|
UnderTheNorthernScar
09.17.13 | where is symbolic?? |
OhCarrots
09.21.13 | ^ I like the album, but just not enough for it to make this list :[ |
evilford
09.21.13 | You're necrotica reincarnate? |
OhCarrots
09.21.13 | Yup. I'll be back next week judging by the date. Once I write 2 more reviews after that, then I'll be a contrib once more |
Necrotica
10.03.13 | m/ |
BigPleb
10.03.13 | Along with being an avg contrib writer, Treb doesn't know how to riff.
Such a shame. |
Necrotica
10.03.13 | Yeah, I really don't understand what he means about how 1 doesn't riff :/ |
BigPleb
10.03.13 | Its what happens when you have Alkaline Trio 5'd |
evilford
10.03.13 | I'm still confused as to how CTAWB in any sense of the word doesn't riff. |
Necrotica
10.03.13 | Exactly! |
evilford
10.03.13 | we musta got trolled |
Necrotica
10.03.13 | I'm still trying to figure out the mystery of Treb's 2011 account |
Necrotica
11.22.13 | Forgot to add Obscura by Gorguts on here. Oh well, I'll put it there next time |
demigod!
11.22.13 | i think i dig 3 more than symbolic at this point |
Necrotica
12.04.13 | I noticed that you bumped Symbolic up to a 4.5, btw |
evilford
12.04.13 | HE'S SEEING THE LIGHT! PRAISE JEEZUS! |
KILL
12.04.13 | weieieieierd list |
DrHouseSchuldiner
12.04.13 | Ya kinda |
Necrotica
12.05.13 | I'm thinking of giving Symbolic a 4/5 instead of a 3.5; I guess we'll see what happens, but I find myself enjoying it more now |
Inveigh
12.05.13 | whoa Symbolic is a hard 5 m/ |
conesmoke
12.05.13 | those titties... druel. |
MO
12.05.13 | good list. with a description like 9 how can people not think it's one of their best |
Necrotica
12.05.13 | Thanks, man. I'm realizing how much weird/obscure shit I put on this list, haha |
Judio!
12.05.13 | I like the list. Glad to see there's someone else on this site besides me who thinks SoP is the best Death. |
evilford
12.05.13 | Trebor.
06.12.13
[Report this Post] I like metal that riffs, and 1 doesn't riff
QFT
Just in case treb EVER sees the light |
Necrotica
01.12.14 | m/ |
Necrotica
06.07.14 | 10 still rules |
CK
06.07.14 | Dude, where's Winds of Creation =[ |
someguest
06.07.14 | http://beyondrandom.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/yB2i56a.jpg |
Necrotica
06.07.14 | m/ |
combustion07
06.24.21 | Some dope, interesting choices here. I need to check 4. Gorerotted and Sadist tho m// |
TheAntichrist
06.24.21 | nice to see sadist - tribe here. this ablum is criminally overlooked |
Koris
09.04.22 | ^ indeed, great ablum men |