SharkTooth
06.05.15 | AND IT BEGINS
voting ends in 2 days |
rockandmetaljunkie
06.05.15 | time to dig |
TheSpirit
06.05.15 | oh damn... better get listening |
Balerion
06.05.15 | here we go |
Friday13th
06.05.15 | DOOMERS GATHERED IN THEIR MASSES |
Gameofmetal
06.05.15 | Much excite, very doom |
TheSpirit
06.06.15 | My votes for 2. 1 was okay, but the blackened inclinations of 2 is what sealed the deal or me. |
rockandmetaljunkie
06.06.15 | Just finished listening, both are good records and my vote will prob go to no 1. Need to re-listen in order to validate. |
SharkTooth
06.06.15 | obviously I love 1, but 2's black-metal production adds a creepy feel that really helps the general quality of the album. At the same time I fucking love the crispness of the riffs on 1, it just has a more "violent" feel to it |
Friday13th
06.06.15 | 1 riffs hard yeah. I'm not quite sure about the distorted, inexpressive singing though. It's not too distracting at least. |
SharkTooth
06.06.15 | Yeah I wasn't a fan of that at first either, while it grew over time for me, I can see how it might not do so well for others |
Friday13th
06.06.15 | Right, it's not much of an issue. Meaty riffs are meaty riffs! I'd definitely take it over 2. I don't think the blackened lo-fi feel fits doom very well. Granted, black metal isn't my thing, being why I opted out of SCREAM's contest. Anyways, my vote goes with #1 |
SharkTooth
06.06.15 | I was impressed with the instrumentation on 2, gonna relisten to my own before coming to a final conclusion but I wouldn't be surprised if either one wins
EDIT: I'm somewhat leaning towards 1 just because the fuzz is so powerful in it, there's nothing wrong with the BM production in 2, but damn 1's sound is just so powerful |
Hawks
06.06.15 | I've been feeling a little doom binge coming on so I'm definitely gonna pay attention to these lists for recs. |
SharkTooth
06.06.15 | feel free to join the fun man |
Cosmoblue
06.06.15 | Definitely going for the first one |
NLD
06.06.15 | These both rule but I'm going to vote 2. I can just see myself going back to it more often for the production and black elements, they really make it a memorable record for me. |
SharkTooth
06.06.15 | the score is now tied at 2-2 |
MoosechriS
06.06.15 | Voting for 2 (as its my entry), but 1 is damn cool |
MoosechriS
06.06.15 | Also dude, how long are you keeping each round open for votes? |
manosg
06.06.15 | Checked 1 a while ago and found it just ok. Gonna recheck though in order to choose. |
Egarran
06.06.15 | 2 days? Good thing I have nothing better to do. |
puntugruhm
06.06.15 | nobody cared about monolord last year, nice to see they're getting some recognition now. that said, my vote is with 2. |
JasonCarne
06.06.15 | I really like 1, but haven't heard 2 yet. Listening now. |
SharkTooth
06.06.15 | @MoosechriS
first comment answers your question |
MoosechriS
06.06.15 | Yeah, sorry dude. Should have actually read the thread first haha |
JasonCarne
06.06.15 | Yeah, I'm going with 1. I got through 3 tracks of the second choice and I just wasn't feeling it. |
Gameofmetal
06.06.15 | 1 is real gud so far |
emester
06.06.15 | eh i would say 1 is only fairly decent so fair. the riffs are heavy yeah but the airy vocals really do not complement the heaviness that well. While it does have some absolutely crushing moments they in themselves arent really mind blowing looking at a decent 3 for 1 |
Egarran
06.06.15 | 2 has the most personality. It's just more metal, dude.
1 seems a bit generic, but it has better riffs and songwriting.
Monolord narrowly wins it for me.
|
SharkTooth
06.06.15 | "2 has the most personality. It's just more metal, dude.
1 seems a bit generic, but it has better riffs and songwriting."
this is pretty much how I feel, they're really close in terms of quality |
NLD
06.06.15 | Yeah I agree with Egarran's descriptions but 2 just wins out for me |
rockandmetaljunkie
06.06.15 | my vote goes to Monolord |
SCREAM!
06.06.15 | Listened to 1 and it had some solid riffs but felt kind of derivative. Looking forward to 2 that description sounds promising |
manosg
06.06.15 | 1 is exactly as I remembered it. Not bad but finishing it is a chore for me. |
rockandmetaljunkie
06.06.15 | My vote would go to BDR but they are too inconsistent imo. |
Gameofmetal
06.07.15 | 2 is decent but I liked 1 better |
DominionMM1
06.07.15 | if forced to choose I'd go with 2 |
manosg
06.07.15 | It's a huge surprise to me but my vote goes to 1. 2 feels like it lacks direction and cohesion. But then again sludge always bored me so what do I know? |
SharkTooth
06.07.15 | votes are at 6-5, we are now waiting for Flugmorph, emester, SCREAM!, OvDeath, Gameofmetal, Keyblade, Hyperion1001, Balerion, and qiblas to give their votes |
emester
06.07.15 | 2 is a lot more interesting than 1 if I gotta be honest. It sounds like borderline blackened sludge. Its not fantastic but it sounds like its own thing while Monolord feels like another EW worship band. The lo-fi production doesnt bother me in the slightest hell I think it works to the overall benefit of the album. plus the drumming on 2 is almost hypnotic and really kept me engaged. not sure who my vote goes to yet but its looking like its going to be Black Demon Rites |
Gameofmetal
06.07.15 | Final vote goes to Monolord |
SharkTooth
06.07.15 | the scores 7-6 with Monolord just slightly in the lead |
Balerion
06.07.15 | My vote goes to Monolord |
SCREAM!
06.07.15 | Yeah BDR definitely gets my vote |
SharkTooth
06.08.15 | a little more than 2 hours left before next match starts, will probably keep this running for those who haven't voted yet |
SharkTooth
06.08.15 | I voted for one,and thus unless anyone else has a vote to put we are currently at 8-6
(also the next match is up) |
Flugmorph
06.08.15 | currently listening to 2. still need to listen to monolord after that. dug their last lp tho |
Flugmorph
06.08.15 | i guess monolord gets my vote after all. Motmänniskan sounds interesting but monolord is just so much more dynamic |
qiblas
06.08.15 | Monolord wins. Although 2 is very solid. |
SharkTooth
06.08.15 | well Monolord wins with a total of 10 votes, very close match here though |
alienobserver
06.08.15 | i listened to 1 before this list how much doom cred do i get |
SharkTooth
06.11.15 | +3.14 |