neekafat
04.21.22 | bet |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
04.21.22 | Rank her haircuts |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.21.22 | jfc is this the saltiest you've ever been on here |
Lasssie
04.21.22 | i wasnt in love with haley williams when i was a kid dont believe it it isnt true |
neekafat
04.21.22 | "jfc is this the saltiest you've ever been on here"
hahahaha you bring out the worst in me |
Colton
04.21.22 | i made 22.7 thou then I neek'd it |
Divaman
04.21.22 | Credible at least. |
onionbubs
04.21.22 | damn the two songs in c tier for bne were my two favs back when id jam that album a lot lol |
neekafat
04.21.22 | @diva i'll take it
@onion well you're a lil pop punk boi aren't you? (; |
onionbubs
04.21.22 | lol u know me (back in those days at least) |
SteakByrnes
04.21.22 | Hallelujah is def one of the weaker ones thank you, never got the praise it received |
neekafat
04.21.22 | it's a v nice track but not a highlight for me yah |
onionbubs
04.21.22 | ay nice that means theres more room for me on the "hallelujah deserves all the praise it received" train. kinda crammed but at least onions only take up like 6 ounces of space |
mynameischan
04.21.22 | I gave 3 another chance a few years ago and it was still quite bad |
onionbubs
04.21.22 | yea i dont like 3 at all outside of maybe 2-3 songs |
YoYoMancuso
04.21.22 | The Only Exception is one of the worst songs I've ever heard |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.21.22 | sounds like a paramore record |
Cormano
04.21.22 | 5 is 1 also rym is a joke site |
Cormano
04.21.22 | My Heart, We are Broken and Misguided Ghosts are my fave deep cuts |
neekafat
04.21.22 | lots of bad takes here hmmmmmm who woulda thought
@cormano those are some nice picks tho, good shit |
alamo
04.21.22 | nooooooooo a C for rose-colored boy and fake happy???????? |
neekafat
04.21.22 | rose-colored is a v high C, i was being a lil mean
Fake Happy is def a C for me :/ |
onionbubs
04.21.22 | damn i didnt even see rose colored boy in c thats a worse take than anything in the thread
pool is best on that album tho ya. largely indifferent outside of those two |
bgillesp
04.21.22 | Considering After Laughter is the only one I’ve listened to in full (just never tried to get into Paramore but love some singles that I know), I really should get around to 1 and 2 |
Dwap
04.21.22 | 5 is 1 |
notagenius
04.21.22 | I never really embraced Paramore's transformation. So even s/t is a happy and fun piece, it evokes sadness to me somehow. |
Mort.
04.21.22 | paramore?
more like paraless |
Divaman
04.21.22 | Agreed. Paramore lost something when Josh Farro left the band. Hayley is good. Hayley and Josh creating together was magic. |
notagenius
04.21.22 | Escape Route (Bonus Track) is one of the best on s/t imo |
Koris
04.21.22 | Nice list! Obviously I have some disagreements - After Laughter is my second favorite album by them, for instance - but as long as BNE is number one, I can't complain :] |
neekafat
04.21.22 | thanks boo!
@Diva, eh. I miss the riffs, but Hayley is an incredibly talented songwriter
|
neekafat
04.21.22 | "if this doesnt get featured but johnnys does its discrimination" [2] |
Kompys2000
04.21.22 | Neek u neekin hard with this one lol
Some questionable takes here but Ain't it Fun in S tier excuses the vast majority of 'em, what a tune |
Divaman
04.21.22 | Here's what I hear, neeka. When Hayley and Josh were co-creators, the band went right at the music. Without Josh, Hayley and the members who are left seem to me to circle around the music. She's not a terrible songwriter, but in this case, I think the whole was definitely superior to the sum of its parts. |
neekafat
04.22.22 | @Kompys thank youuuuuu I distrust anyone who doesn't like that song
@Diva to each their own! I'll admit there was something special there. Their rock stuff never hit those heights again |
Storm In A Teacup
04.22.22 | Aint It Fun is definitely S tier |
Divaman
04.22.22 | And there was an energy to it. I saw them live three times before the Farro brothers left the band, and it was always an exciting show. I still buy the LPs, and I'll pick up the one they're supposed to release later this year. But so far, I just feel like they've reached the same heights. |
Dedes
04.22.22 | Riot! Is a masterpiece
Only track that I find to slump somewhat imo is Fences but even that is impossibly fun |
Dedes
04.22.22 | Also you're right s/t is far from their best but is actually kinda ambitious and genuinely pretty darn good |
bgillesp
04.22.22 | Okay, jamming 1 now. I'll let you know how it goes
[edit] Well that was some good 'ol fun right there. Gonna keep going with these |
bgillesp
04.22.22 | Why is Misery Business not an S tier!? |
bgillesp
04.22.22 | So Riot is my favorite but BNE isn't far behind. I liked the S/t, but there were several songs on it I thought were boring. Basically nothing boring on 1 and 2 though |
neekafat
04.22.22 | Good stuff bgill!! Yeah Riot is the fan-favorite but BNE has an edge to it I can't get over (and you gotta check "Decode")
Misery Business is probably unfairly an A-tier sheerly bc of the hundreds of times I listened to it in 5th grade |
neekafat
04.22.22 | @diva you're right about their live shows. Seeing Hayley/Josh-era "Decode" was a life-changer, didn't like the song much until then and now it might be my fave |
bgillesp
04.22.22 | Is Decode a bonus track? |
Divaman
04.22.22 | Yeah, "Decode" was added later to the international edition of the album. It was originally on the Twilight soundtrack. |