Breathe Carolina Hello Fascination
  full reviewuser ratings (30) 
Tracklist:
1. "Hello Fascination"
2. "I'm the Type of Person to Take Things
Personal"
3. "Take Me to Infinity"
4. "Dressed Up to Undress"
5. "I.D.G.A.F."
6. "Welcome to Savannah"
7. "I Have to Go Return Some Video Tapes"
8. "The Dressing Room"
9. "Tripped and Fell in Portland"
10. "Can I Take You Home?"
11. "My Obsession"
12. "Velvet"
13. "Rescue"


Release Date: 08/18/2009

user rating
2.6
average
Chart.
other reviews
WhiteTieBlackJacket (3)
"Here's To You - Criticize My Darlings. Are You Satisfied?"...
Levie Galapon (2)
Having made an album better than their last. Breathe Carolina surprises everyone with an album that ...

related

 It's Classy Not Classic
recommended by reviewer
Breathe Carolina It's Classy Not Classic
BrokenCYDE I'm Not A Fan But The Kids Like It

members also liked
Brokencyde I'm Not A Fan, But The Kids Like It!
Mr. Bungle Disco Volante
Tim and Eric Awesome Record, Great Songs
Johann Sebastian Bach The Musical Offering, BWV 1079
Deadmau5 For Lack Of A Better Name
Metro Station Metro Station
And Then There Were None Who Speaks For Planet Earth?
Daft Punk Human After All

  On 2 Lists

1.5
very poor
James USER (2 Reviews)

2009-08-15 | 42 comments | 1,077 views

Summary: Breathe Carolina creates a cd filled with musical cliches, lyrics that could have been written by a 15 year old girl, and instrumentation that hardly qualifies as music.

4 of 6 thought this review was well written

Lets face it, with the lyric writing maturity of pre-pubescent boys and the musical talent of whatever the extent of the new Garage Band program can give them, Breathe Carolina have come onto the “16-year-old-scene-girl” scene with the subtlety of an elephant. A necessary question: “Is ‘Hello Fascination’ as bad as the other bands (BrokenCYDE) in this hopeless genre of screaming and auto tune?” The answer: a resounding NO, but the end result is still pretty terrible.

The first song, also the title track, is a foreboding example of things to come. The song starts with some kind of guitar with so many effects that it is nearly unrecognizable. The song moves into a very standard synth and extremely poppy beat that sounds straight out of a Brittany Spears cd. To make matters worse, the song features a breakdown filled with the same unrecognizable guitar and some strange attempt at drums that uses the same crash cymbal the whole 15 seconds It is featured.

The second song, “I’m the Type of Person to Take Things Personal” features more of a trance synth feel with echo-ey clean vocals from David and the same, one note, generic scream from Kyle which features the ever-mature line “ You better use your head before we take it off your mother fu**ing shoulders.” The song ends with a trance beat into the next song, “Take Me to Infinity.”

“Take Me to Infinity” features that very line at least 4 times per verse, which can certainly grate on a reviewer’s eardrums after hearing the full song several times. Once again the guitar-that-probably-isn’t-guitar is featured in the background, and one of the most bothersome things about this song is that in one part, it actually has Kyle and David talking about what they are going to do after they record for the day, which actually just feels insulting.

Moving on to “Dressed Up to Undress,” this is quite possibly one of the worst written choruses I have ever heard with the same uninspired music. The chorus is as follows: “Why you dressing up tonight, we don’t need money to kill the lights, and why you talkin’ over it, I don’t words to feel those lips, and why you talkin’ over it, everything we want is in our grips, it seems to me, that we should be, dressed up to undress.”

Track 5 is “I.D.G.A.F.” Again, this song sounds as if it was penned by a certain hotel heiress rather then two grown men. The chorus features incomprehensibly fast robotic vocals and David saying he doesn’t give a fu*k, and nothing else. Once again amongst the drivel of synth and computerized noises, the guitar, if you can call it that, is present.

“Welcome to Savannah” is the next track and is actually one of the better songs, especially when compared with “I.D.G.A.F.” The song features all electronic instrumentation with almost all clean vocals. There is screaming, but it is so edited and broken up that it can hardly be called screaming at all.
After the fairly normal “Welcome to Savannah,” we get treated to the incredibly immature, borderline stalker lyrics of “I Have to Go Return Some Video Tapes.” The song features heavy screaming, and whiny clean vocals, along with literally one synth sound, and little variation. The lyrics contain gems such as, “I want you to know, I’ve been in your apartment.”

“The Dressing Room” is track 8 and as you can guess, it’s about women, dressing rooms, and not remembering their names. It sounds identical to every other song on here; it actually becomes comical how similar and undifferentiated this song is compared to every other one.

“Tripped and Fell in Portland” is the next song and has the most actual instrumentation. It sounds like every other generic pop/rock band ever, which is actually a step up in technicality of music. But wait! There’s more! This particular song has an acoustic, slow moving ending as the last minute.
Track 10 is “Can I Take You Home?” As if correlation between song and title were mandatory, this song is about taking a girl home, sorry to ruin the surprise for anyone. And guess what else? The melodic side is once again the same sugary, synth heavy music that runs this cd.

If the song title reflects on the lyrics of this song, which they do in this cd, then you should be very frightened by “My Obsession.” This is easily the most boring song on the cd and features almost recycled lyrical ideas from “I Have to Go Return Some Video Tapes.”

The second to last song “Velvet,” is the same thing as every other song on the cd, and sounds as if it belongs on a pop diva’s cd rather than a record written by two males. Lastly, “Rescue,” actually sounds very different, for the worse. It features guitar that isn’t even playing chords, but single notes. This song actually sounds like it was thrown together at the last second as a filler track. It has very little melody and just isn’t good by any stretch of the mind.

So is this cd the redemption of Breathe Carolina? No, but will it meet the expectations of every scenester on the planet? Of course! It’s Breathe Carolina.

The Album Stream is now on the Breathe Carolina Myspace
http://www.myspace.com/breathecarolina

Share: Facebook Stumble Digg!Digg Twitter Del.icio.us

Comments:Add a Comment 
jamesiscake


Comments: 14
08.15.09

Album Rating: 1.5

Second Review! Constructive Criticism? album stream at: http://www.myspace.com/breathecarolina

Digging: War From A Harlots Mouth - Transmetropolitan

Zip


Comments: 3731
08.15.09

Album Rating: 4

Yeah how about, this album isn't out yet and this review will be deleted by the mods in a matter of hours

Digging: Disparaged - The Wrath of God

jamesiscake


Comments: 14
08.15.09

Album Rating: 1.5

No the stream is up on myspace, so that works right?

Zip


Comments: 3731
08.15.09

Album Rating: 4

Then you need to post a link to the stream.

Waior
Contributing Reviewer


Comments: 6300
08.15.09


Edit your first post to look something like:

Second Review! Constructive Criticism? Stream: http://www.myspace.com/breathecarolina


or whatever their myspace is. Decent review, could use a little more unity though. Good job covering a new release. Put a track list, artwork and release date on this baby.

Digging: The Red Chord - Fed Through the Teeth Machine

Zip


Comments: 3731
08.15.09

Album Rating: 4

Album is not that bad...

jamesiscake


Comments: 14
08.15.09

Album Rating: 1.5

Ok thanks for your help! Done...and done, and I hate to break it to you zipper, but this cd IS that bad

Waior
Contributing Reviewer


Comments: 6300
08.15.09


You can take the stream out of the summary now. Save you some work later.

Album is bad, yeah.

Zip


Comments: 3731
08.15.09

Album Rating: 4

WELL I AM ENJOYING IT DESPITE YOUR CRITICISM!

CompanionCube


Comments: 870
08.15.09


zippermouths obv a 16-year-old-scene-girl

Zip


Comments: 3731
08.15.09

Album Rating: 4

nope 15

fattytoeben


Comments: 571
08.15.09


No need for 12 paragraphs padre.

Digging: The Decemberists - The Hazards Of Love

This Life is Genocide


Comments: 1984
08.15.09


Review does not deserve two negs

Digging: After The Sirens - What I Have To Give, Let It Be Enough

WhiteTieBlackJacket


Comments: 257
08.15.09

Album Rating: 3

I disagree with this review. Overall, the music produced by Breathe Carolina is feel-good pop - dance/car music. It's not like
they're attempting to be Fall Out Boy. I hate Brokencyde and Family Forve 5, but, for some reason, Breathe Carolina seem alright
to me.

I'm thinking this will be a 3 for me.

Digging: AFI - The Art of Drowning

UhhKris


Comments: 3791
08.15.09


band sucks
review is okay

Digging: Converge - Axe To Fall

Zip


Comments: 3731
08.15.09

Album Rating: 4

I'm thinking 3.5 just cuz I'm cool with this stuff. It's so not BrokenCYDE so we are ok.

jamesiscake


Comments: 14
08.15.09

Album Rating: 1.5

Well White Tie, everyone is entitled to their own opinion. MY opinion is that this cd was very immature lyrically and very uncreative musically.

WhiteTieBlackJacket


Comments: 257
08.15.09

Album Rating: 3

I have to say though, if Daft Punk announced they would be releasing an album in 10 years, I'd forget about Hello Fascination. Right now though, there's nothing else to fill my synth void.

jamesiscake


Comments: 14
08.15.09

Album Rating: 1.5

Zipper, I agree, and in the review, it says that this IS NOT AS BAD AS BROKENCYDE, but still not a good cd by any means, i would say 2.0 max

Zip


Comments: 3731
08.15.09

Album Rating: 4

Well it wasn't really intended to be lyrically mature, given the target audience. You're just supposed to plug it in and dance/headbang and stuff.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Site Copyright 2005-2009 Sputnikmusic.com
All Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy