Album Rating: 4.0

Hesitation Marks has some good stuff too. But yeah The Fragile is probably my favorite of all time; and one of the darkest albums ever made.

Album Rating: 4.5

to me it is Year Zero that’s a bit overrated, not With Teeth

also, agree on The Slip being underrated, definitely better than Hesitation Marks

Album Rating: 5.0

I didn’t really get an accurate description of this album from the review. Maybe it is because I have listened to it 500 times at least if not more? The review has no substance or interest. Should have been a sound-off. I am also withdrawing off of Cymbalta and need my weed so…



In all seriousness though the actual rankings for NIN go:



The Downward Spiral



The Fragile (Blow me)



Pretty Hate Machine



Broken





and I honestly don’t really care for any of his other albums.

stone on

Album Rating: 4.5

Year Zero is overrated, With Teeth is underrated. But we're splitting hairs here really

Album Rating: 4.5

honestly did not fuck with year zero when it first came out buuuut it's aged pretty well everytime i go back to it, at least on par with withteeth maybe even better. broken&phm&downward are my goto nin, fragile has some of his best songs but i feel like the 2nd disc doesn't go anywhere near as hard as the first. never heard the slip but hesitation marks was solid

yeah they pretty on par

Album Rating: 3.0

Year Zero is the best thing he’s done since The Fragile imo, unless we’re counting film scores I guess. All of his OST’s that I’ve heard are good but his Watchmen and Gone Girl scores really stood out to me.



The man stays busy

Album Rating: 3.0

mine goes



The Fragile

The Downward Spiral

Broken

Year Zero

Bad Witch

Hesitation Marks

Not The Actual Events

Add Violence

The Slip

Pretty Hate Machine

With Teeth



Still would sit comfortably at number 4 if we’re counting that. Didn’t put in the Ghost records because I absolutely have not listened to them enough for that.

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, the ghosts albums are really in a separate category, they are more like ASMR stuff

Album Rating: 4.5

Year Zero is great but tracks 9-13 are basically auto-skips for me and pretty much unlistenable. Like some of his worst songs ever. Thankfully the last 3 tracks are stellar.

Album Rating: 3.0

I actually really dig The Great Destroyer lol



I don’t remember the other four offhand