[quote=Iai]Haha.....I just came in here to recommend X-Japan's Art of Life, and I see I've already done it.



I must give my judgement on this album.



A Change Of Seasons = one of the best songs of all time.

The rest of the album = useless wank.



I give it a 3/5 overall. A version without the bonus tracks, though, would get a 5/5 without any hesitation whatsoever.[/quote]

With the exception of "Perfect Strangers" i must say i agree with you.

Another nice 1/5 from our technical wankists.

Just a note the reason why Perfect Strangers sounds odd is because, Myung is playing the Keyboard, Sherinian is playing the Guitar, Portnoy the Bass, and Petrucci the Drums.

ACOS = the best dt epic.

Album Rating: 3.5

I prefer Octavarium (the song) tbh, that's without a question my favorite song ever. This may be more impressive on a technical aspect but Octavarium's title track just has that sheer, epic, goosebump inducing atmosphere that makes it so perfect. While tis song definitely has it, it doesn't amount to Octavarium imo. This is still a damn near perfect song however, and one of my favorites ever.

Album Rating: 4.0

Pfffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffft, Octavarium is a bunch of mini songs stuck together. A Change of Seasons doesn't have that disjointed feel - it's the one theme, it's a real song.



Anyway, I declare this EP a 4/5, mainly for the title track of course. The covers aren't too bad, but I'm they're prone to being skipped over.This Message Edited On 11.15.08

This will probably sound blasphemous to most Dream Theater fans but I don't even really even like the title track. I got through 13 minutes of it and was bored to tears. I plan on giving it a relisten in the future but as of now I don't remember a single part of what I listened to. As far as Dream Theaters 15 min+ epics go I'd much rather listen to Octavarium.

*puts up flame shield*

Album Rating: 4.0

A Change of Seasons is my favorite Dream Theater song.



If only the lyrics weren't so cheesy...

Album Rating: 3.5

I actually quite like the lyrics on ACoS. They're a lot better than what they write now at least.



And yeah, it's a race between ACoS and Octavarium as my favorite Dream Theater song, and possibly my favorite song off all time.

Album Rating: 3.5

The title track is awesomeness. I love it.

The title track is the best thing DT has recorded.

Album Rating: 5.0

Review is quite nice as a whole, but just to inform you, the lyrics of the title track examine a mans life, from his youth in the former movements, through to his aging into an older person and becoming more cynical and realizing that his life has been drained. This is kinda obvious, in that in the final movement, he "Sits down with his son".

A change of seasons is one of the best songs ive ever heard and the covers are excellent too.

Album Rating: 4.0

One of DT's best. I view the EP as an EP, so the 4 goes out to the title track only. Great song, not Odyssey but great songwriting and the gay vocals of LaBree don't interfere that much.

Album Rating: 4.0

Is this song post labrie fucking his voice up? cause he sounds great here, but he's not exactly going for those super high's you hear on Awake and Images and Words. anyone know?

Album Rating: 4.0

Oh, and for whomever wrote the review, the song A Change of Seasons is about Mike Portnoy's mother dying and how it changed

his life, him dealing with it and his reactions to the automated responses of people who try and console him about his loss.

Album Rating: 4.0

Title track is one of my favorite songs.

ew gross

sorry i had to

Album Rating: 4.0

You given it a chance, bro?

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

A Change of Seasons is one of the best songs this band ever released.

Album Rating: 4.5

rules yea