I'm starting to think that they'll never beat Waiter: You Vultures!

Don't get me wrong though, I've thoroughly enjoyed everything they've released.

Album Rating: 4.5

Yep. This album is absolutely wonderful.



P.S - I just want to sleep forever, alright guys?

Album Rating: 3.0

naw

Album Rating: 4.0

It's good and whatnot but nothing special... meh, will still make it into my top 50 of the year, though.

Meh, I wouldn't give it any more than a 2.5

Album Rating: 4.0

Just realized that Share With Me The Sun - from an instrumental standpoint - kinda sounds like You Are a Tourist by Death Cab for Cutie.

Album Rating: 4.0

easily their best since censored colors.

feel like the same sound has been stretched too far now, this and american ghetto not that great

american ghetto was so awesome


this is okay

Album Rating: 4.0

American Ghetto was awesome until i realized how underproduced it was... and how about a third of the album was completely forgettable.



Honestly, the only song on here that i'm not all that crazy about is Floating. Everything else ranges from good to amazing.

Album Rating: 3.5

@KritikalMotion: There's no room for 2 Don Draper's on Sputnik. you know what you have to do.



@Klap: Great review, sir. As a fanboy, I concur with nearly everything you said. I think most of

P.tM's fans, and fans of the live show, are anxious and still holding out for that one record that

we all know that they still have in them. The one that incorporates their earlier experimentation

with the raw feel of their live show. Not that they do rush music as has been alleged, but perhaps

they could take a year off touring (they deserve it, especially after this year) and focus on a more

expansive record.



Can't agree enough with the sentiment about the vocals above. My friends and I were talking about

this. John is way too quick to go in falsetto overdrive these days. It was a lot more rewarding when

he would use it sparingly, say like in CC or Church Mouth. Can't say that I particularly enjoy the

post-production on his vocals on ItMItC. Would love to see Zach and Ryan with more group vocals

x100.



Speaking of production, I don't really care for the allure of the shiny new toys they got along with

this label deal. I rather much prefer the lo-fi production of their early work, like It's

Complicated Being A Wizard. And IMO, some of my favorite work of theirs, is actually their pre-

Waiter material: The unreleased Demos EP and the Under Waves of the Brown Coat EP. Every P.tM fan

deserves to hear this, which is why I will provide a link for them here:



Demos: hXXp://www.mediafire.com/?zxdgijbtcfo



Under Waves of the Brown Coat: hXXp://www.mediafire.com/?mnj9mrgxh1x



/done.

seriously tried to get into this, but nup. not gonna happen.

not really sure what to think of this yet

I just cant like this band at all...

Album Rating: 3.0

good review.



Good album but not up to par with american ghetto, or the satanin satanist.

ss was boring

SS owned man, whatchu smokin'?

taxidermist idk it was my first and only cd by them and id really get into it for the first 2 or 3 tracks and then zzzzzzzz

I wish this was good

Album Rating: 4.0

patience young one