Can't wait for this to hit metacritic

"The fact that she will ultimately only have ever made one great album is very sad"

I am starting to fear this

Album Rating: 3.0

yeah ngl every time someone calls album X the best Carly since Emotion the nadir of my shrug gets a centimetre lower. don't think she's entirely lost though - all her stuff since (even Dedicated) was worth a Best Tracks scalping

Album Rating: 4.0

"The fact that she will ultimately only have ever made one great album is very sad"



Literally not true lol

Album Rating: 4.0

The fact that people think Emotion is amazing, but don't like any of her other albums is hilarious to me



I promise you they are not THAT different

Album Rating: 4.0

I think Dedicated Side B especially, is as good as Emotion for the most part. I personally prefer The Loneliest Time over both of these, but I think it just hit at the right time for me, despite it's flaws. This is probably the worst one since Emotion overall, not to say it's exactly bad though it's still pretty good!

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Kinda depends on what you qualify as "great." Yeah I think Emotion was S-Tier and she hasn't made anything since to reach that height, but she's put out multiple A-tier releases since. I'd consider everything since Emotion (except for MAYBE this) to be great.

The fact that people think Emotion is amazing, but don't like any of her other albums is hilarious to me [2]

i agree with flag on this (what the hell is going on)

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

"The fact that people think Emotion is amazing, but don't like any of her other albums is hilarious to me"



I agree with this by virtue of the fact that Kiss is also an incredible album, not because I think anything she did after Emotion is any good.

Album Rating: 4.0

The fact that people think Emotion is amazing, but don't like any of her other albums is hilarious to me [3]



Ash has just been on my wavelength

The Loneliest Time kicks ass this does too

sputnik L rateyourmusic W

on God even Kiss kinda rules and Dedicated Side B is her best what do you people WANT

Album Rating: 4.0

"Truly one of the best dance pop albums released this year, don't understand the middling reception on this site" [2]



enjoyed this way more than the loneliest time. maybe no BANGERS but almost all the tracks have been growers for me

Album Rating: 4.0

They want Emotion Pt.2

(Which we kinda got with the EP)

Album Rating: 4.0

Emotion is easily my fave and always will be but she's been consistent 4's ever since

Album Rating: 4.0

Everyone giving less than a 4 is homophobic

WHAT
How bout no rating

Album Rating: 4.0

"Emotion is easily my fave and always will be but she's been consistent 4's ever since"



Agreed agreed quality pop music

Album Rating: 4.0

Everyone giving less than a 4 is homophobic [2]