John Coltrane
Kulu Se Mama


4.5
superb

Review

by SgtPepper EMERITUS
May 17th, 2012 | 18 replies


Release Date: 1966 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A spellbinding performance.

John Coltrane was a pioneer of Jazz music. Jazz wasn't just another form of music to him, but a method of communication. Another form of expression in which the music describes the kind of sensations that no arrangement of words could ever describe. He viewed his albums as meditative journeys, altering the conventions of Jazz, while discovering new techniques and orchestral approaches. Kulu Sé Mama induces a certainly interesting listening experience because it has such an abstract agenda. It is an album that reflects the traditional Bebop style of his earlier efforts, but we also see John Coltrane dwelling into the more experimental approach of his latter efforts. The album opens with "Kulu Sé Mama", a musical piece decorated with tribal aesthetics, expressing an evident influence from African spirituality. The instrumental elements have their moments of scandalous eruptions, but for the most part, "Kulu Sé Mama" is a rather gentle piece- an ascension into a spiritual state of mind.

"Welcome" is another delicate composition that is blossoming with musical elegance. Its driven by an alluring, yet gentle melody, that delivers an exquisitely beautiful sound. The music is warm and embracive, like the sensation of being in the arms of a lover. But as we transcend further into Kulu Sé Mama, we find that it reveals a more jubilant side. "Vigil", for example, is flourishing with energetic deliveries. Elvin Jones starts us off with an eruptive drum solo, before John Coltrane complete takes over with an intense release of free-form solos. And then of course, there is our highlight, "Selflessness", which features a duet by John Coltrane and Pharaoh Sanders as they coalesce their tenor saxophone deliveries into one spellbinding performance. "Selflessness" is a voyage through different moods, exposing sides of both sensitivity and aggression within its musical landscape. Kulu Sé Mama may not have many songs to offer, but it is a truly remarkable album, and a listening experience well worth the time of any Jazz enthusiast.



Recent reviews by this author
Deerhunter Fading FrontierJulia Holter Have You In My Wilderness
Knxwledge Hud DreemsTrioscapes Digital Dream Sequence
Broken Bells After The DiscoSound and Fury (FI) Pulsacion
user ratings (79)
3.9
excellent


Comments:Add a Comment 
StrangerofSorts
Emeritus
May 17th 2012


2904 Comments


Hey dude, just commenting to draw attention to one thing I noticed when reading this review (feel free to disregard it, I've decided that tonight is as good a night as any to lie up late listening to The Smiths).

The way you structure your thoughts is very kind of stop-start. Thoughts are cut off waaayy before they're given enough room to sink in. For example:

Driven by an alluring, yet gentle melody, it exhibits such beauty. Its music is warm and embracive, like being in the arms of a lover.


This is too segmented. It would flow a hell of a lot better like: "Driven by an alluring, yet gentle melody, it delivers a beauty that is both warm and embracive: like being in the arms of a lover."

Generally one short-ish coherent thought = one sentence. Also the review kind of just ends, maybe try to weave some kind of over-arching "argument" (I say argument, I really mean a point. Like exploring the albums themes etc.) into the review to both pad it out and smoothen the structure.

Idk, tired thoughts. Will check this out though.

rockandmetaljunkie
May 17th 2012


9621 Comments


Sweet review, pos
Do you consider writing a negative review ?

SgtPepper
Emeritus
May 18th 2012


4510 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

@StrangerofSorts

You actually have a point. The sentence is actually much better the way worded it. I'll see if I can get the mods to edit some stuff out.



@Captain

Thanks, mate. Yeah that sentence reads weird to me to. I'll be honest, the review was kind of written on the spot- I was listening tot he album and just felt compelled to write a review for it.

ControlDarts
May 18th 2012


290 Comments


love this guy, great review dude

SgtPepper
Emeritus
May 18th 2012


4510 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Alright its been edited. Thanks guys for all your advice.

SgtPepper
Emeritus
May 18th 2012


4510 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

@Control

Thank you.



@Rockandmetal

I have yet to write a review with negative score. Im just the kind of person that if I dont like the music of a certain album, then I dont see the point in putting time and effort in writing review for it. I know a lot of users enjoying tearing apart bad albums, but its not me. Though I know that if i want to be taken seriously I should write a negative review.

Anthracks
May 18th 2012


8028 Comments


coltrane was pretty talented

TheFonz123
May 18th 2012


2793 Comments


My favorite artist ever.

liledman
May 18th 2012


3828 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Altering the conventions of Jazz, while discovering new techniques and orchestral approaches.




as mentioned above, some of this reads awkwardly, and this sentence is kind of just stuck in there.



we also see John Coltrane dwelling into the more experimental approach




delving?



tribalistic aesthetics




tribal would probably work better here



descension into a spiritual state of mind




i think he would rather ascension ;)



also the end of this just feels tacked on and abrupt, but thats just me.

SgtPepper
Emeritus
May 18th 2012


4510 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

@liledman

Hey, man. Yeah I already asked the mods to take care of some of the edits (including the ones you pointed out), so now I'm just waiting for them to actually do it. But about the ending, I honestly didnt know any other way to end it.

I hope the edit bug gets fixed soon.... and I have to proofread a lot better before uploading.

liledman
May 18th 2012


3828 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

yeah, weird you always have trouble getting edit to work. should be easy.



good to see you are enjoying trane's later stuff.

ZedO
May 18th 2012


1096 Comments


this jazzman was a legend, i found so many artists here covered his songs in jazz festivals...

pos, mate! i got your point, just be cool about editing, you can do it later.

Shadowmire
June 1st 2020


6660 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

nice thread

Zig
June 18th 2020


2747 Comments


good stuff

porcupinetheater
February 9th 2021


11030 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

ffffuck that title track is something else. The two on side B are nice but god damn that first is fucking cosmic

sonictheplumber
February 9th 2021


17533 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

powerful

porcupinetheater
February 9th 2021


11030 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Coltrane and Pharoah together could set fire to the bottom of the ocean

Ryus
December 18th 2023


36794 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

a-side is unreal



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy