dunksman23
05.20.12 | inb4 needs more meshuggah |
ValeriusTheAlbino
05.20.12 | Slayer |
rockandmetaljunkie
05.20.12 | Judas Priest |
rockandmetaljunkie
05.20.12 | Also, where is Motorhead ? |
dunksman23
05.20.12 | ^ would u really class motorhead a possible 2nd greatest metal band? |
rockandmetaljunkie
05.20.12 | Would you really class Metallica as the second greatest Metal band ? |
Ovrot
05.20.12 | Iron Maiden or Judas Priest
depends on the album |
fulgrim
05.20.12 | I think Maiden have been more consistent than Priest so probably them, but there isn't much in it. |
TheNotrap
05.20.12 | Maiden - Not second, first.
Priest
Metallica
|
dunksman23
05.20.12 | no. i would not consider metallica to be the 2nd greatest. but a lot of peop[le do. thats the only reason its on the list |
dunksman23
05.20.12 | ^ and converge |
TheNotrap
05.20.12 | and Kenny Rogers |
Tyrael
05.20.12 | Iron Maiden has the best overall discography but Judas Priest made Painkiller |
rockandmetaljunkie
05.20.12 | "no. i would not consider metallica to be the 2nd greatest. but a lot of peop[le do. thats the only
reason its on the list"
Then they should reconsider. Metallica's rightful place would be 4rth or 3rd. |
dunksman23
05.20.12 | this list only confers the general consencus. not my own personal opinion |
TheNotrap
05.20.12 | "but Death improved Painkiller."
No |
rockandmetaljunkie
05.20.12 | I wouldn't classify Motorhead as the second best Metal act of all time, but there are a lot of people
who believe Motorhead deserve the spot, so you should include them as an option.
Personally, i would rank them above Alcoholica for historic reasons. |
MoosechriS
05.20.12 | Iron fucking maiden!!!!! |
jopower
05.20.12 | Iron Maiden didn't decline as much as the other two, so Iron Maiden wins. |
jayfatha
05.20.12 | Uh definitely Maiden |
SpiritCrusher2
05.20.12 | I love Metallica the most, but yea, it's Maiden |
KILL
05.20.12 | "but Death improved Painkiller".
neck
priest is prob my fav here but nah none of these |
ZilbelPing
05.20.12 | I'd say maiden but I love Preist so it all depends on the album cause both have amazing tracks.
I'd actually dare and say maiden and Preist over sabbath but I don't know |
Oathbreaker
05.20.12 | people still talk about these bands? |
Hammersharf
05.20.12 | 100 fucking percent Maiden!!! |
lucazade22
05.20.12 | Maiden >>>>>>> Metallica > Judas Priest |
FictionalFlames
05.20.12 | Maiden > Judas Priest > Metallica
Iron Maiden's album are more consistent than Priest's or Metallica's. Then again anyone's discography is more consistent then Metallica's. |
Trebor.
05.20.12 | Iron Maiden are best
Priest are gay
|
ReturnOfTheDnor
05.20.12 | "Iron Maiden's album are more consistent than Priest's or Metallica's. Then again anyone's discography is more consistent then Metallica's."
idk, Metallica's actually pretty consistent...
Pre-1990 Metallica was consistently good, and post-1990 Metallica was consistently terrible. |
Colliiiin
05.20.12 | MAIDEN. |
Surtur
05.20.12 | Maiden > Sabbath > Metallica > Priest |
pedro70512
05.20.12 | "Priest are gay"
is that supposed to be like, a pun or something? because it sure ain't logic. |
Rastapunk
05.20.12 | All three of them! |
JokineAugustus
05.23.12 | Definitly Death is number 1 or 2 than maiden than metallica than priest. |
Dashy
05.23.12 | Death > Maiden > Sabbath > Priest
Why isn't Death on this list. |
Bloodhail
05.23.12 | who let my dad on the internet |
mindleviticus
06.10.12 | Meshitica sucks cock.
Maiden and Priest fo life muhfucka |
KjSwantko
06.10.12 | "inb4 needs more meshuggah"
....wtf?
anyway, basically it's a tie between the 3 but if i was forced to choose I'd say Metallica > Priest > Maiden |
thumbcrusher
06.10.12 | idk if metallica stopped in 1992 many people would probably consider them the best ever. virtually all bands have a least a few crappy albums if they've been going for 30 odd years so it depends on if you judge on the consistency or how good their best ones were. i'd say metallica should be held in high regard up for their run of lightning, puppets and justice, not many bands could manage three albums like that on the trot. |
Shuyin
06.10.12 | cannibal corpse |
KjSwantko
06.10.12 | Shuy you have 5,000 comments; 4,000 of which are "cannibal corpse." |
IMZA1793
06.10.12 | Maiden > Metallica > Priest |
FearThyEvil
06.10.12 | Maiden hands down. |
facupm
06.10.12 | "Death improved Painkiller"
NOOO |
Shuyin
06.10.12 | 'Shuy you have 5,000 comments; 4,000 of which are "cannibal corpse."'
who needs words.. when you can have cannibal corpse m/ |
cagedescending
09.16.12 | Priest because Sad Wings |
