bungy
10.08.12 | Holy shit best list |
XingKing
10.08.12 | Because they fucking suck. |
bungy
10.08.12 | lol |
Trebor.
10.08.12 | lol sex pistols
Amazing list |
Trebor.
10.08.12 | I like them, put I would have to make like a 500 album punk list for me to put them |
ShadowRemains
10.08.12 | awesome list
haha sex pistols |
Masochist
10.08.12 | Huge list. But no Bad Religion = no passing marks. |
XingKing
10.08.12 | Don't worry Flutter, I'm sure everyone who doesn't know anything about punk likes them too. |
XingKing
10.08.12 | Lol |
StarlessAnd
10.08.12 | some good
some unforgivably bad |
ShadowRemains
10.08.12 | exile in oblivion |
Trebor.
10.08.12 | I've heard 58 of these what do I win |
Atari
10.08.12 | I've heard like 7 of them lol. damn guess i need to get into some real punk. |
StarlessAnd
10.08.12 | sputnik is the right place agrd |
Dev518
10.08.12 | @ Fluttertrank Don't listen to them. Sex Pistols are good. They're just not as good as The Clash or the Ramones, but they could definitely make it into a respectable top 100 list IMO. |
Trebor.
10.08.12 | Not in a top 100 that includes punk, hardcore, grind, scramz, etc
|
Dev518
10.08.12 | I've heard 49 of these, and Punk is the majority of my Pie Chart. |
Dev518
10.08.12 | That's true but there are certainly worse choices on this list than the Sex Pistols, not that its bad by any means. |
Curse.
10.08.12 | did you run this list through Satty before posting |
tom79
10.08.12 | the wild and koalacaust yesss. so much good stuff here. |
boogs
10.08.12 | 37 rules bruh bruh |
Curse.
10.08.12 | Sex Pistols are atrocious, don't let their influence cloud the fact that they suck |
Blackbelt54
10.08.12 | Thanks everyone
I do need to delve into Bad Religion more, they seem great but I haven't listened to them enough |
clercqie
10.08.12 | yesyesyesyesyesyes!
Never Mind The Bollocks is still a fucking amazing record, legacy aside. |
cumverg
10.08.12 | stopped reading when is saw clash at 1 lol |
warrar1
10.08.12 | edit: yall didnt see that |
clercqie
10.08.12 | "stopped reading when is saw clash at 1 lol"
Yeah, because it's unranked moron. |
warrar1
10.08.12 | maybe he doesnt believe the clash should even be classified as punk rock! stop getting into his head man |
warrar1
10.08.12 | sorry |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Massive props on 1, 3, 4, 26, 38, 97
Are 6, 18 and 55 really punk though? |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Oh, yeah - and why no Pistols? Suck or not, they HAVE to be on a punk list, methinks (most punk bands sucked back then anyway - musically that is).
Also, why no Buzzcocks, Undertones, Bad Religion, old Green Day? |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Oh, yeah, including Converge and not the Pistols on a PUNK list brings the lulz. |
Blackbelt54
10.08.12 | It's punk and subgenres. I'm not a huge pistols fan. And yeah I buzzcocks and BR rule but I haven't listened to enough. And dang it I forgot the Livingbrooks |
tom79
10.08.12 | blackbelt ever listen to any dillinger four? Should definitely delve into their discography if you haven't yet. |
Blackbelt54
10.08.12 | An I forgot like bats goshdangit |
Blackbelt54
10.08.12 | I have a little... I've been meaning to check them out for so long now, thanks I'll definitely listen to them ASAP |
JackSparrow
10.08.12 | Ramshackle Glory and Defiance Ohio but no Mischief Brew? :( great list though I know over half of these. Needs D.O.A. too |
Trebor.
10.08.12 | returntorock has been reading too much rolling stone |
JackSparrow
10.08.12 | Lol the even notion of Green Day being on this list is ridiculous. I can live happily without the Pistols being on here. |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Never even touched that rag, Treb.
And what is it with people that makes their brains block at the notion of Green Day being a PUNK ROCK band?! Sure they're not a PURE PUNK band, but pretend the last 10 years didn't exist, and stuff like Dookie and Insomniac can be construed as punk. If the Ramones and The Clash are punk, OLD - EMPHASIS ON OLD - Green Day is punk too. |
Trebor.
10.08.12 | Yeah they're punk they're just not very good compared to a lot of other 90's punk
Dookie is their best album and it's like a 3.5 |
alachlahol
10.08.12 | too much gay satellite punk |
JackSparrow
10.08.12 | The fact remains they've never been anything but average pop-punk at their best, meaning they don't belong in a definitive list such as this. At their best they are little more than imitations of Descendants and Screeching Weasel with a little less effort and creativity. As for Sex Pistols, I would put them in a punk list because they were at the forefront of the movement by the time 1979 rolled around but their influence isn't enough to make this list judging by the wide variety of sub genres of punk here |
clercqie
10.08.12 | lol @ "their influence isn't enough" |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Dookie is a 5/5, fucking perfect album.
By that logic Jack, are the Ramones punk-pop? I think they are, to be honest. So are the Undertones. I keep hearing critics compare GD to the Ramones, but I don't really agree with that. GD are more along the lines of Generation X or Youth Brigade (apart from the vocals). |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Yeah, LOL @ that. Try asking a layman what a punk band is and see what the first name is that they tell you. This has been proven through practical application btw. |
Trebor.
10.08.12 | Because when I want accurate statements about music I ask laymans (laymen?)
|
JackSparrow
10.08.12 | I'm not going to speak for Blackbelt because Never Mind certainly would have made my 100 punk list due to influence and sound. Ramones are definitely pop-punk but they were basically pioneers of that and were doing it 20 years before Green Day copied everything they did. Critics shouldn't be listed to, someone recently compared that atrocious "Kill the DJ" to The Clash's "The Magnificent Seven" which should be punishable by castration |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | That's not the point. The point is, if a band is known to the mainstream as a representative of a certain style, IT IS RELEVANT TO THAT STYLE.
I'm a dubstep layman. If anyone asks I say Skrillex or Deadmau5. They may suck, but the fact that I know who they are EVEN THOUGH I DON'T LISTEN TO DUBSTEP means they have RELEVANCE WITHIN THE GENRE. No? |
JackSparrow
10.08.12 | Don't put so much faith in the mainstream to be an honest representative of a genre, especially when it comes to punk. By that logic Sum 41 could be perceived as relevant to punk because of their image and use of the word "skumfuk". Crass was never mainstream, doesn't mean they aren't punk. |
porch
10.08.12 | yeah what alach said |
Blackbelt54
10.08.12 | This is just my personal 100, why would I put an album on it if it's not in my top 100? |
alachlahol
10.08.12 | thats a question you should be asking yourself |
bungy
10.08.12 | I like too much gay Satellite punk to narrow it down to 100.
Listened to that Pogues album last night so good |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Jack, you're also missing the point. The point is, ask Average Joe "hey, you familiar with punk?" and he's bound to say "oh yeah Johnny Rotten, God Save The Queen!" It's happened to me a number of times. Therefore the Pistols were relevant to punk, as they constitute the genre reference to many laymen. Which is a bit different from your Sum 41 example, even though I get what you're coming from.
@belt: fair enough. |
bungy
10.09.12 | lol laymans |
Trebor.
10.09.12 | sounds like an orgcore band name |
Blackbelt54
10.09.12 | Yeah bungy that pogues album is probably my favorite Celtic punk album |
wabbit
10.09.12 | does it have body of an american or is that just a bonus track. That's probably there best song.
list is so fucking awesome gg |
bungy
10.09.12 | That must be a bonus track I need to check that out |
WeepingBanana
10.09.12 | this is basically my 100 punk albums list with the order rearranged
nice |
Blackbelt54
10.09.12 | Thanks rabbit
Lol nice banana |
cumverg
10.10.12 | and where is The Damned?? |
Blackbelt54
10.11.12 | yeah they're another band I need to listen to more |
ibringyoufire
10.11.12 | Neato list. How do you feel about Social Distortion? |
Blackbelt54
10.11.12 | they're good based on what I've listened to, but they're one of the many bands I haven't listened to enough to put on here. so I guess I need to check out more |
Blackbelt54
10.11.12 | Cool thanks hep |
huguitoescorza
10.24.12 | Good List, but sex pistols???? |
huguitoescorza
10.24.12 | Bad religion???? |
Blackbelt54
10.25.12 | I addressed both of those in the comments- not a big pistols fan, and I honestly haven't listened to BR enough to put them on here but that will change |
menawati
10.25.12 | damn no Stranglers, Xray spex or vice squad |
aexulans
10.29.12 | very nice |
Blackbelt54
10.30.12 | Thanks |
Rastapunk
10.30.12 | What's that hate on Sex Pistols? They had some fine tunes! |
Cygnatti
10.30.12 | good list, sex pistols ain't bad
just that, public image is so much better |
Blackbelt54
10.31.12 | no hate, just not a huge fan. they're ok |
Rastapunk
10.31.12 | Of course they aren't the best :)
That list is missing some UK82 bands (Exploited, GBH etc) |
Blackbelt54
11.01.12 | Yeah I'm definitely no expert on the UK scene. Holy crap I don't have Cock Sparrer or the Adicts this list is missing so much |
