Artuma
08.09.13 | i know people will disagree a lot with some of the choices |
Keyblade
08.09.13 | 1 is 1 forever and always
cool list dude |
Artuma
08.09.13 | thanks bro, that song is somewhere beyond this world |
Keyblade
08.09.13 | lack of Lips of Ashes makes me :'( tho |
Artuma
08.09.13 | never really thought lips of ashes was anything special tbh, sry |
NeroCorleone80
08.09.13 | 1 and 2 are def the best. I'd have A Smart Kid on here, and also put 8 and 24 much higher |
Artuma
08.09.13 | i'm thinking too that 24 should probably be higher here |
NeroCorleone80
08.09.13 | Its easily the second best on Deadwing imo |
Artuma
08.09.13 | nah man, the middle section of the start of something m/ |
mursu
08.09.13 | You've got some good choices here, but the list is missing Open Car |
Artuma
08.09.13 | open car used to be one of my favorites off deadwing but it kinda grew off me |
SmersH
08.09.13 | Nice list. I might trade out Even Less for Stop Swimming, personally - but the top three are definitely correct. |
KILL
08.09.13 | all those shitty incident songs over stop swimming? i'm pissed
buying new soul??? |
Artuma
08.09.13 | i drive the hearse being shitty huh? |
KILL
08.09.13 | thats one of the better ones i suppose :D |
SmersH
08.09.13 | Jupiter Island?
lol |
Artuma
08.09.13 | agreed, jupiter island is pretty lol |
Trampumpoolee
08.09.13 | Buying new Soul , Lips of Ashes , The Sound of Muzak , Strip The Soul , My Ashes , Way out of here , Normal , Footprints.
I missed 8 songs that i would put in a top 20 at least |
Emyay
08.09.13 | all of the incident songs that he put are good ones. normal is definitely missing here. i'd have fear of a blank planet, sound of muzak, open car, the rest will flow, and shallow but thats just me |
Artuma
08.09.13 | considered putting normal here but decided to not. sound of muzak has a kickass drum performance but
the lyrics kinda kill it for me. fear of a blank planet and strip the soul are both songs i don't
really mind about. the rest will flow is a nice uplifting jam but still not top 40 stuff for me.
shallow is easily the weakest track on deadwing imo |
KILL
08.09.13 | buying new soul> |
Artuma
08.09.13 | sorry kill but no |
KILL
08.09.13 | i am the porc authority dude ive been to wilsons manor |
Emyay
08.09.13 | stars die is on the sky moves sideways? i have that album but i don't have that song |
KILL
08.09.13 | theres like 3 diff versions of it thats prob y
i got the original uk release |
Artuma
08.09.13 | dude you shouldve taught him to write better lyrics |
Artuma
08.09.13 | stars die is on the us release of tsms |
Emyay
08.09.13 | the only stars die i have is the one on we lost the skyline, guess i'll have to get the original. also, on sky moves sideways i have a phase 1 and phase 2. when you put that on your list did you mean phase 1 or phase 2 or are you lumping them together? i don't know if i would agree with that considering that they don't follow each other on the album (or at least my version) |
Artuma
08.09.13 | it's the same thing as with shine on you crazy diamond |
Mongi123
08.09.13 | Sweet list man 1 is correct. I really need to listen to their whole discography even though that's quite a project. What one you suggest next? |
Artuma
08.09.13 | thanks mate. well which ones have you heard? |
Mongi123
08.09.13 | I've heard Lightbulb Sun, IA, Deadwing, Fear Of A Blank Planet, And The Incident. |
Emyay
08.09.13 | he's heard all the newer ones is my guess. thats how most people get their start. i still need to really delve into their older albums. gonna listen to all the songs on this list that i'm not too familiar with |
Emyay
08.09.13 | ^i swear i posted this before seeing mongi's response |
Mongi123
08.09.13 | Haha dude same |
Artuma
08.09.13 | @emyay: seriously do that. they have such a wide and consistent discog
@mongi: i'd suggest to check signify and stupid dream next. stupid dream seems to be a sputnik favorite but i think signify is an underrated gem |
Emyay
08.09.13 | definitely listen to stupid dream next, its the most like their newer albums and you should like it straight away. and yeah artuma i made a little playlist of the songs i don't know that well and i'm gonna check 'em out in a bit |
Artuma
08.09.13 | nice one : ) |
NeroCorleone80
08.09.13 | I'm surprised you dont like Stupid Dream more Art, because its very similar to Lightbulb. |
Artuma
08.09.13 | i know, i never really fall in love with stupid dream like i did with lightbulb even though they are two "sibling" albums |
YoYoMancuso
08.09.13 | 3 is 1 |
KILL
08.09.13 | it could be a joke it could be a statement :D |
JamieTwort
08.09.13 | "I've heard Lightbulb Sun, IA, Deadwing, Fear Of A Blank Planet, And The Incident."
All the weaker ones, sweet. |
Artuma
08.09.13 | ah, hi jamie :D |
NeroCorleone80
08.09.13 | Lightbulb is just as good as Stupid Dream, and theres no way any of those are weaker than on the sunday |
KILL
08.09.13 | lightbulb sun rapes yea |
Artuma
08.09.13 | agreed |
Emyay
08.09.13 | no use arguing with jamie about PT. he loves his old shit and he will not hesitate to shit on you for liking FoaBP or any of the others. that being said, i love the new shit so much |
jtswope
08.09.13 | 1 is my favorite too |
JamieTwort
08.09.13 | "he will not hesitate to shit on you for liking FoaBP or any of the others."
You realise that when I stay stuff like what I said above I'm not being 100% serious, right? It's all tongue in cheek. I obviously prefer their old stuff but I'm well aware most people here like their newer stuff best and I don't have a problem with that. |
Artuma
08.09.13 | 1 and 2 were easy picks for me |
jtswope
08.09.13 | Both great songs |
KILL
08.09.13 | still pissed at no STOP SWIMMING |
NeroCorleone80
08.09.13 | I know the lift can be painfully slow |
jtswope
08.09.13 | Basically anything from Stupid Dream could be on this list |
Artuma
08.09.13 | tinto brass is pretty bad imo |
Emyay
08.09.13 | i know jamie. thats basically what i was trying to point out, albiet in my own tongue in cheek kind of way |
Emyay
08.09.13 | tinto brass is pretty bad imo [2]
its awful |
TheInmortalVermicide
08.09.13 | Not bad but there are missing key tracks like the self titled in lightbulb sun and buying a new soul on recordings |
KILL
08.09.13 | lol hardly emyay |
peaks40
08.09.13 | needs moar the sound of muzak |
dsroka005
08.09.13 | where's moonloop (coda)?!! |
Artuma
08.10.13 | i mean tinto brass isnt awful but its one of their weakest tracks ever for sure |
OmairSh
11.13.13 | This band......
"i mean tinto brass isnt awful but its one of their weakest tracks ever for sure"
Leave now, just...leave |
Rowan5215
11.13.13 | just realising now how fucking good an album the Sky Moves Sideways is
damn |
Mongi123
11.13.13 | Tinto Brass rules. I think I wanna do something more like this after I listen to UTD and SMS more. I think .3 is still number one for me. |
GnarlyShillelagh
11.13.13 | sound of muzak is where to be found nowhere |
Rowan5215
11.13.13 | Sound of Muzak is annoying |
Rowan5215
11.13.13 | man his lyrics have sucked since Lightbulb Sun |
Mongi123
11.13.13 | Dude don't talk shit about Heart Attack In a Layby haha |
Rowan5215
11.13.13 | don't really remember that one to be fair but FOR THE MOST PART they've sucked |
Keyblade
11.13.13 | Solo in Muzak deserves top 15 at least |
Mongi123
11.13.13 | Tbh he's never been a "fantastic" lyricist but he pulls off some good stuff most of the time aka Heartattack, .3, Blind House, Baby Dream in Cellophane. Just some good one's off the top of my head. |
Rowan5215
11.13.13 | I think he's pretty good lyrics-wise on TSMS, Signify, Stupid Dream, Lightbulb Sun mongi |
GnarlyShillelagh
11.13.13 | muzak is annoying agreed |
GnarlyShillelagh
11.13.13 | sound of muzak is somethin else tho |
Emyay
11.13.13 | sound of muzak rules just thought i'd weigh in |
Mongi123
11.13.13 | [2] |
Emyay
11.13.13 | also 6 is probably 1 for me. 1 is 2 |
Artuma
11.13.13 | sound of muzak has horrible lyrics, otherwise it prob would've made the list |
Emyay
11.13.13 | i like the lyrics but i'm no lyric authority. i always respond more to the sounds |
Mongi123
11.13.13 | I wouldn't call them horrible, but Wilson saying music is going downhill I don't agree with one bit. |
Emyay
11.13.13 | yeah true, he is kind of a dick in that regard |
Mongi123
11.13.13 | He's for the most part a very humble and respectful dude, but I don't understand why he hates ipods so much. Either way, I'm listening to your music so how we listen to it you shouldn't really give a shit. |
SirDrumsalot
11.13.13 | I need to listen to more of these guys. I haven't taken the time to really listen, but I really like a few of their songs I've heard. Their drummer seems to kicks some balls on a few songs. Like Bonnie the Cat. |
Artuma
11.13.13 | i don't really get the hate for bonnie the cat. the drumming is phenomenal on that song agreed |
Emyay
11.13.13 | song gets hate? i like it a lot |
Rowan5215
11.13.13 | I'm interested at your choices from Stupid Dream Art, I love Don't Hate Me and Even Less (especially the former which I think is incredibly underrated) but I always thought that Pure Narcotic and Piano Lessons were the worst songs on there. |
Artuma
11.13.13 | but those two are the catchiest, dammit. and yeah, don't hate
me is pretty underrated even tho it gets love |
Rowan5215
11.13.13 | If we're talking catchy then Stranger by the Minute >>>> both of those. I dunno they both just piss me off massively, I definitely think Stop Swimming or a Smart Kid could take their place. |
Mongi123
11.14.13 | Piano Lessons is catchy as fuck |
GlenTennis
11.14.13 | 1 is their best. |
Mongi123
11.14.13 | .3, Waiting, Arriving, Russia On Ice, Anesthetize, Burning Sky, and Idiot Prayer would def be in my
top 10 |
