Artuma
07.09.14 | sry guys no odal :[
discuss here instead of the serpent thread ffs |
Hawks
07.09.14 | Needs more Dead Winter Days and As Embers Dress the Sky, but still great list. m/ |
Artuma
07.09.14 | i'm not as much into pf as a lot of users seem to be but those songs rule too. thanks m/ |
TalonsOfFire
07.09.14 | For me 9 is 1, 1 is 2, and 7 is 3 but still sweet list |
Hawks
07.09.14 | Pale Folklore is my fav Agalloch so that might explain it. :p |
Artuma
07.09.14 | 9 was my first fave agalloch song but in a long run these 8 epics top it |
Hawks
07.09.14 | 9 has been my fav Agalloch song since I first got into them tbh. |
ti0n
07.09.14 | approved |
Mongi123
07.09.14 | ODAL!
Anyway, yes 1 is 1. What a goddamn masterpiece. |
Artuma
07.09.14 | @hawks it's a superb and pretty catchy song yeah |
TalonsOfFire
07.09.14 | Yeah I just got into this band a few months ago so my opinion'll probably change, I just love the last third of Falling Snow, it tops everything else for me currently |
Artuma
07.09.14 | @talons how much do you like 2? |
Mongi123
07.09.14 | I reeeeeeally love The Lodge. It's all about the deer skull :D |
Artuma
07.09.14 | the lodge is awesome but probably the weakest song on the mantle |
TalonsOfFire
07.09.14 | I love 2, my fav on ashes after the first two and probably top 10 of theirs |
Artuma
07.09.14 | sweet, i think you still have some hope with your taste :]] |
Keyblade
07.09.14 | Uh dude, Fire Above, Ice Below? |
Artuma
07.09.14 | it's def top 15 |
Atari
07.09.14 | sweet. glad to see she painted fire across the skyline in top 5
|
Keyblade
07.09.14 | Bloodbirds? Those are my 2 favorite tracks on Ashes lol :'[ |
Atari
07.09.14 | needs more the white tho :3 |
KingdomOfTyrant
07.09.14 | no bloodbirds lol |
climactic
07.09.14 | top 2 is yes |
KingdomOfTyrant
07.09.14 | bloodbirds is 1 |
Artuma
07.09.14 | yeah the white rules. these 10 songs tho |
climactic
07.09.14 | SOLSTAFIR!!!!!! |
Artuma
07.09.14 | @key and kingdom bloodbirds is only one part of a song, and overall that song is the one that keeps me not 5'ing ashes |
Artuma
07.09.14 | SOLSTAFIR!!!!!! [2]
best agalloch vox moment ever |
climactic
07.09.14 | that song is such a jam, i thought i was the only one who liked it the best on ashes. that heavy riff at the beginning gets me every time |
Artuma
07.09.14 | yeah and the moment when the vox come in is completely unreal... or so you'd think until solstafir makes everything else sound flat out gay |
Muisc4Life26
07.09.14 | fantastic list! |
Artuma
07.09.14 | thanks :] |
YoYoMancuso
07.09.14 | 1 is 1
7 is 2
The Hawthorne Passage is 3 |
Artuma
07.09.14 | hawthorne passage was another early fave song for me. the first half of it is ridiculously fun, but the second half drags a bit |
KriegdemKriege
07.09.14 | Correct list is the tracklisting of the Mantle plus Falling Snow. |
YoYoMancuso
07.09.14 | second half is the best part man, The Seventh Seal sample sends chills down my spine and that happens again when the winds come in |
Artuma
07.09.14 | @krieg fucking hell no even tho mantle is easily my fave album |
Artuma
07.09.14 | "second half is the best part man, The Seventh Seal sample sends chills down my spine and that happens again when the winds come in"
it's fantastic agreed but it's just a tad too long |
Gameofmetal
07.09.14 | I'm getting ready to check out Agalloch for the first time. Starting with Marrow of the Spirit. |
TalonsOfFire
07.09.14 | While I love 5 I actually prefer every other track on PF for some reason |
Artuma
07.09.14 | @gameofmetal marrow is an odd one to start with but i think you'll love it |
Gameofmetal
07.09.14 | I always did have the luck of picking the odd albums when finding bands but it usually works out. |
Artuma
07.09.14 | just let me know your thoughts on marrow when you've finished |
Gameofmetal
07.09.14 | Will do. |
RadioSuicide
07.09.14 | Hawthorne is easily top 5 but good list. |
Gameofmetal
07.09.14 | Artuma I'm only a little ways in, on Into The Painted Gray but it sounds very cool so far. |
Artuma
07.09.14 | "no fire above ice below? is this some sort of fucking joke?"
less of a joke than you |
InFlamesWeThrash666
07.09.14 | 1 is definetely 1 ...5 is in my top three though |
Artuma
07.09.14 | @gameofmetal cool, just wait for black lake, it's so goddamn epic |
JohnnyoftheWell
07.09.14 | The Melancholy Spirit, You Were But a Ghost in my Arms, The Watcher's Monolith!
Otherwise, approved |
Artuma
07.09.14 | dude i have you were but a ghost on here
the melancholy spirit is prob my 2nd favorite song on pf and the watcher's monolith is 3rd for marrow so they missed this list with a minimal margin |
JohnnyoftheWell
07.09.14 | I'm an idiot :P
I see, fair enough...you can't really go wrong with Agalloch (even The Serpent was solid enough) |
Artuma
07.09.14 | serpent was kinda lackluster on agalloch standards but then again it's agalloch so how could it possibly not be great |
pedro70512
07.09.14 | I Am the Wooden Doors is my #1. I absolutely love that song. |
Gameofmetal
07.10.14 | Artuma very much enjoying Marrow of the Spirit. Black Lake was indeed epic. Now an Agalloch fan for sure. |
Artuma
07.10.14 | good boy :] |
Amphoteric
07.10.14 | 1 will always be 1 |
Artuma
07.10.14 | once 1 always 1 |
Amphoteric
07.10.14 | Well actually it's tied with Embers imo, idk which I would truly rank 1 out of those. |
Artuma
07.10.14 | dunno man, embers never hit me like that |
Amphoteric
07.10.14 | That acoustic break with the clean guitar solo is only the greatest thing ever written in the history of music. |
pedro70512
07.10.14 | Bro do u even music? There's so much better shit out there. Why r all metalheads so narrow-minded and think they're angry shit is tha best? Beethoven, Wagner, Mozart, come on. |
Artuma
07.10.14 | edgy one, pos'd |
Amphoteric
07.10.14 | Troll on, brotha |
climactic
07.10.14 | 1 is 1 eternally |
Artuma
07.10.14 | @fut i know it's your 1st sputversary aka the princess day but no |
Amphoteric
07.10.14 | That comment was in reference to Pedro |
BigPleb
07.10.14 | agreed futures, they really aren't. |
climactic
07.10.14 | agalloch is angry as fuq |
climactic
07.10.14 | also i dont agree with pleb but i do think this band is overrated HARD, ashes and *maybe* the mantle are their only albums worth a 4+ |
Artuma
07.10.14 | one does not simply dislike this band, can you see it pleb? :] |
pedro70512
07.10.14 | Seriously though, I actually don't like typical "angry" stuff. Five Finger Death Punch is my go-to comparison because they're excellent musicians but the music has a 16-year-old mentality focused on giving The Man the finger and stuff.
The Mantle is a sentimental 5 for me. Probably more a 4.5 because the second half isn't as good as the first. |
BigPleb
07.10.14 | Ashes is good but the rest SUCK, hear me Finland boy?! SUCK!!!!!!! |
pedro70512
07.10.14 | It's like they tried to be Saor and failed, man. |
Artuma
07.10.14 | saor released their debut last year didn't they? |
Amphoteric
07.10.14 | "Seriously though, I actually don't like typical "angry" stuff. Five Finger Death Punch is my go-to comparison because they're excellent musicians but the music has a 16-year-old mentality focused on giving The Man the finger and stuff."
Same reason I hate Phil Anselmo and similar vocalists/bands like Pantera. |
Artuma
07.10.14 | hi pleb how you doing? :] do you know the band agalloch? they're great |
pedro70512
07.10.14 | "saor released their debut last year didn't they?"
yep and it was pretty sweet. |
TalonsOfFire
07.10.14 | Agalloch is barely black metal they have some mild characteristics but they almost never do blast beats, screamed vocals, tremolo guitarwork, or screaming vocals. The music is never even that aggressive, it's more atmospheric. Can't really compare them to bands like saor or the great old ones |
Artuma
07.10.14 | dunno if you talked about mantle or ashes but they were released waaay before saor so "they tried to be Saor" makes quite little sense |
Artuma
07.10.14 | ok talons it's nice that you figured that out |
Crysis
07.10.14 | disagree with several choices and don't agree with the ranking of them at all
into the painted grey is terrible |
Crysis
07.10.14 | also where is "as embers dress the sky" |
Amphoteric
07.10.14 | also where is "as embers dress the sky" [∞] |
Artuma
07.10.14 | not on the list |
BigPleb
07.10.14 | god you're moody |
Crysis
07.10.14 | then apparently this isn't the top 10 agalloch songs |
TalonsOfFire
07.10.14 | I was just clarifying for these gonks who keep saying that new saor is better and nonsense like that |
Artuma
07.10.14 | then apparently my opinion differs from yours cool
seriously tho i think marrow > pf i know it makes you cringe crysis |
TalonsOfFire
07.11.14 | I haven't heard more extreme reactions to an album than marrow maybe I should hear it |
pedro70512
07.11.14 | Marrow was pretty good. The climaxes could have had more oomph and Dekker's drumming is a little shaky but overall it's worth having in your collection. |
R6Rider
07.11.14 | I know it's a hard list to make, but no Fire Above, Ice Below?
damn |
Artuma
07.11.14 | jesus guys are you still asking for that song? |
Artuma
07.11.14 | list defines justice now stop |
Nud
07.11.14 | Needs more folklore |
TalonsOfFire
07.11.14 | Finally listening to Marrow for the first time, 8 rules |
DrGonzo1937
07.12.14 | I approve |
Artuma
07.12.14 | gd |
Arnaud
08.23.14 | 1 is 1 eternally [2] |