Typhoon24
10.21.16 | i 4.5'd demon days but a collective 3.9 feels right idk
air moon safari should be a 4.4 |
SandwichBubble
10.21.16 | Demon Days is still a 1.5 for me. Tell me what I'm missing, former president Doub-ya. |
SandwichBubble
10.21.16 | Also, add Throbbing Gristle - The First Annual Report. "3.5 average" is atrocious. |
Artuma
10.21.16 | "omfg why does this band only have a 3.9 avg when it really should be a 4.0 at least this is outrageous!!" |
hal1ax
10.21.16 | You genuinely like bar sachiko ? May I ask why? |
pizzamachine
10.21.16 | 1 is overrated |
porcupinetheater
10.21.16 | Hell yeah proper use of underrated
Also, My Dying Bride - For Lies I Sire.
That record goes dusk to dawn |
ryu
10.21.16 | Grace Jones - Nightclubbing. It doesnt even have a review. |
Snide
10.21.16 | Nickelback - All The Right Reasons. Average rating is 2.2, album is a 4 |
GhostOfSarcasticBtrd
10.21.16 | Alexisonfire (most egregious 3.8 on this site)
They're Only Chasing Safety
Periphery |
Storm In A Teacup
10.21.16 | the sput-hate is real w/ Periphery
They're Only Chasing Safety is a genre 5/5 classic and objectively a 4, but I'd say 4.5 so probably is overrated.
Alexisonfire's debut is a 3.8, but even with over a thousand votes I don't understand why it couldn't ever break out into at least a 4 and it's a straight up sin for Old Crows/Young Cardinals to be rated a measly 3.3...I feel objective saying the average should at least be a 3.6 or 3.7 |
Trebor.
10.21.16 | a weekend in the city. they;re only chasing safety yeah |
GhostOfSarcasticBtrd
10.21.16 | "the sput-hate is real w/ Periphery"
Debut is a genre classic. I don't care how big a target that puts on my back it's a true statement. Misha cherry-picked all the best material he had made over his entire life and then Casey had input on the vocal arrangements and Travis wrote a lot of the drums, so it's totally different than all their other shit.
"They're Only Chasing Safety is a genre 5/5 classic and objectively a 4, but I'd say 4.5 so probably is overrated."
Not sure I get this cause it has a 3.6, so overrated how?
|
Jeffrulesyou
10.21.16 | I think a lot of it has to do with people rating things within a genre they don't like. I feel as if people rated things within the genre they like; it would be more of an appropriate aggregated rating. I don't know much about pop-punk, but don't most people consider American Idiot a classic of the genre? I don't think I would want to rate/review something from a genre of music I don't like. I feel my opinion would be too biased and people who enjoy that genre might actually like that album/band. |
Storm In A Teacup
10.21.16 | idk you are the one who said it was underrated first |
GhostOfSarcasticBtrd
10.21.16 | Underrated cause a 3.6 is like half a point below where it should stand, yeah. You said the same kinda stuff but then said "overrated" so I'm confused. |
Storm In A Teacup
10.21.16 | oh shit I meant underrated lol |
TheSpaceMan
10.21.16 | itt ppl complaining about 3.9 avgs |
Storm In A Teacup
10.21.16 | one person |
Sinternet
10.21.16 | bar sachiko should be a 2.5 because it's retarded to think it is either a 1 or a 5 |
anat
10.21.16 | there are some albums I love that are literally underrated like they have 1-4 votes but generally those are niche British albums that I wouldn't expect to be rated and it's difficult to get the word out |
