onionbubs
01.21.18 | will probably add descriptions later, for at least the top 10-20 ish |
Drifter
01.21.18 | Nice |
onionbubs
01.23.18 | thought this band had more fans on this site rip |
Danred97
01.24.18 | Good list. Aside from Black Mass being too low, I’m kinda in agreement here. Burn After Writing is probably my #1. |
JayEnder
01.24.18 | Sites been down onion. Ps Obituaries needs to be much higher. |
Minushuman24
01.24.18 | Ooph all my favorites are so low
gates and obits def top 5 |
Deathconscious
01.24.18 | im still jerking it to this band all day err day. |
tom79
01.24.18 | sweet list dude. even got the deep cuts on here. love it. Probably a top 5 band of mine tbh. |
onionbubs
01.24.18 | obituaries rules but I’m not sure its ever been in my top 5. literally like the first 30-35 ish songs are all 4.5+s tho so it being lower is a testament to how amazing the other songs from them are |
Astral Abortis
01.24.18 | Mexican Guitars and Casey are both #1 |
onionbubs
01.24.18 | Hard to argue with that. Both absolute classic tunes |
mortifierftw
01.25.18 | 6 is 1 |
Dedes
01.25.18 | The Obituaries at 28 is a sin |
onionbubs
01.26.18 | 27-1 exist tho
Again do you realize how hard this was |
Snake.
01.26.18 | 67 is way too fucking low smdh |
onionbubs
01.26.18 | ehhh |
Satellite
01.26.18 | irish goodbyes at 31? fuck off
good list otherwise |
Satellite
01.26.18 | actually no ticket at dead last is pretty egregious
i hate you |
onionbubs
01.26.18 | if it means anything if i provided ratings for each song irish goodbyes would have a 9/10 |
onionbubs
01.26.18 | don’t like no ticket at all sorry. one of the few menzingers song that does nothing for me |
Satellite
01.26.18 | more like 420/10
*eats entire pack of tide pods* |
kris.
01.26.18 | 1 at 1 nice |
Minushuman24
01.31.18 | No ticket does rule |
QuinnObropta
09.11.22 | I wish this had descriptions! I'd love to hear your thoughts |
onionbubs
09.11.22 | i remember trying to do descriptions for this but its kinda hard finding a lot of things to say about each and every one of these songs given theyre all stylistically pretty similar, and i dont usually have as much to say about lyrics as i do music
its all good tho bc id change a lot around w this list anyway (example: how tf are gates and your wild years not top 10ers). hello exile shakes things up a lot too since id rank a good handful of songs off that album pretty high |
QuinnObropta
09.29.22 | That's very interesting to hear. I just got into the Menzingers this year and I absolutely adore them. Time Tables' first verse / everything before the first chorus is probably my favorite moment of any song ever at the moment. Chorus is still very good, but that first minute is absolutely ridiculous. THEN I HEARD HER SINGING SOMETHING FAIRLY FAMILIAR, A TALE OF TWO LOVERS IN THE THICK OF THE SUMMER |
Slex
09.29.22 | 11 is my 1 but great list for sure |
onionbubs
09.29.22 | 11 is like top 5 for me now lol absolute jam. 1 is still probably my 1 tho |
Slex
09.29.22 | 1 is probably top 3 for them yeah
I thought the last album had some of their best songs too even tho the album itself was inconsistent |
onionbubs
09.30.22 | farewell youth and strain your memory are arguably 10ers for me. hello exile rules |
Slex
09.30.22 | Yep those are the big ones for me too, Farewell Youth especially I fucking LOVE |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | I have a top 50 playlist have to post it soon, but you can check it here. https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3ZES5kxV9c3WO3ueLvWfGy?si=7Rpyrl6gTZuRcqX_tTF6pQ&utm_source=copy-link |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Here is my top 10
1. Casey
2. Burn after Writing
3. The Obituarirs
4. Your Wild Years
5. After The Party
6. Charlie's Army
7. Gates
8. Midwestern States
9. Sun Hotel
10. Time Tables |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Slex knows what's up! |
Slex
09.30.22 | Nice to see love for Your Wild Years and Charlie's Army, underrated songs |