Bl4ckheart
07.14.19 | 1 and 2 are great albums. |
calmrose
07.14.19 | what's with all these shitty metalcore lists popping up lately? |
Deathconscious
07.14.19 | Yikes |
TakeToYourGuns
07.14.19 | Damn man, you need to listen to some good metalcore |
Arditi
07.14.19 | Like I said guys this is stuff I jammed 3-4 years ago. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @calmrose yeah man I fully acknowledge that this is a shitty list which is why I don't fuck with metalcore anymore. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @TakeToYourGuns. "Good Metalcore" is an oxymoron lmao. |
Deez
07.14.19 | Mort will have a heart attack when he sees this shit |
Trebor.
07.14.19 | metalcore phase was only a year so like why make a list, shit is only six albums |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @Trebor. Maybe Because I can? If you read the description you'd know its only the records I really liked.
|
Viriathus
07.14.19 | Yeah this is indeed a metalcore list |
gschwen
07.14.19 | >if there were to be a discussion for best metalcore album of all time, this would have to be considered.
Please listen to something that came out before 2005. You’re dismissing 15 years of a genre and all it’s pioneers to make this statement about a band that hasn’t accomplished a damn thing for music, let alone metalcore. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @gschwen. Another one, I said countless times I don't listen to metalcore anymore so I'll have to decline. I'd rather listen to good music. |
Viriathus
07.14.19 | Theres no need to be dismissive of an entire genre just based upon whats surface level for it. Youre missing out on good earlier stuff.
Converge, Poison the Well, Cave In, Every Time I Die, early Eighteen Visions, Disembodied, Bloodlet, Skycamefalling, Norma Jean, Fear Before the March of Flames just to name a few. |
Deathconscious
07.14.19 | "'Good Metalcore' is an oxymoron lmao."
Oh dear, youre completely oblivious to the non-mallcore side of metalcore, arent you. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @SlicePaperMoog. Yeah listen man I've no doubt that there is good, great metalcore out there but it just doesn't click with me which is why I won't pursue it anymore. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @AdolfChrist. A joke more or less mate. |
Viriathus
07.14.19 | How do you know it doesnt click with you if you havent heard it? |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @Trebor. Yeah six albums but I usually take time for my lists as you can see with my others so sometimes I just want to make a brief list. |
gschwen
07.14.19 | I dunno what to tell you when you make a list of well-done London Broils and tell everyone that’s why you don’t eat steak anymore. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @SlicePaperMoog. I have heard some of that stuff and evidently it's not on the list so make of that what you will. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @gschwen. Yes good metaphor London Broils and steak is exactly what I had in mind while writing the list. |
splinter
07.14.19 | best genre |
botb
07.14.19 | AAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaa |
Confessed2005
07.14.19 | Good metalcore does exist. And it sounds nothing like any of these albums. |
MarsKid
07.14.19 | " "Good Metalcore" is an oxymoron lmao. "
hol the fuck up |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @MarsKid. J O K E |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @dARiUs tHE gREaT. Who the fuck are you? |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @Confessed2005. Yes, I know that. |
Viriathus
07.14.19 | "@SlicePaperMoog. I have heard some of that stuff and evidently it's not on the list so make of that what you will."
So Cave In, Converge, Norma Jean, and Poison the Well bad but Motionless In White is a staple of the genre? Aight bby you do you. |
Arditi
07.14.19 | @SlicePaperMoog. C'mon mate tastes change. Now I'd take converge over these bands any day. With all due respect, you seem to have a hard time understanding that this was done from the perspective of my junior high self. |
Viriathus
07.14.19 | You still called it a genre staple though. I get that its done from that perspective but lol. |
Arditi
07.15.19 | @SlicePaperMoog. I suppose it is from a popularity standpoint but I digress. As stated I'm quite obviously not a connoisseur of metalcore self-admitted. However I would recommend you to check out the sixth entry, you might like it. |
JokineAugustus
07.15.19 | Check Dillinger and save yourself |
Viriathus
07.15.19 | I have listened to that Blind Witness album and its honestly pretty bad imo. |
Arditi
07.15.19 | @SlicePaperMoog. Fair enough :) |
JokineAugustus
07.15.19 | You should also check out Spectrum of Death. Much better than Reign in Blood. |
Arditi
07.15.19 | @JokineAugustus. If it's any consolation I have been trying to get into Converge again, as well as Code Orange to reintroduce myself to metalcore that is a little closer to my taste now. |
Snake.
07.15.19 | honestly if you dug sempiternal in your formative years your metalcore "phase" was basically doomed from the start sorry |
JokineAugustus
07.15.19 | Ya Converge, Dillinger, and Botch are the big 3 |
Viriathus
07.15.19 | Code Orange are not that good. They just are a watered down Disembodied/early 18V. |
Viriathus
07.15.19 | Id take Cave In over both Dillinger and Botch for Mathcore tbh
No shade towards Dillinger or Botch. They still both gud. |
Uzumaki
07.15.19 | I’m surprised at MightyScoop’s level of control regarding this list. I applaud him. |
Arditi
07.15.19 | I'll check out Cave In because I've heard good things from several people. Thanks for the rec. & yeah haven't liked Code Orange so far, seems they cant settle on a genre lol. |
Arditi
07.15.19 | @Uzumaki. Purposely bad list from the perspective of my younger self. As stated I wouldn't be able to listen to these albums nowadays without saying "wtf were you thinking". Lol. |
Arditi
07.15.19 | If yall are interested in how different my taste is, check out my fav albums list. |
mrdogthrow
07.15.19 | 3 is GOAT |
Uzumaki
07.15.19 | @arditi, s’all good, I was just joking because of past experience with my similar metalcore list. FWIW, I still like listening to 2 & 4 from time to time. I can and will vouch for Cave In though. Fantastic works there. |
Viriathus
07.15.19 | ngl 2 has a few decent tracks on it. Still the only BMTH album I can say that I like is There Is A Hell. Even then id still pick Norma Jean, Underoath, Poison the Well etc. over it lol. |
Arditi
07.15.19 | @Uzumaki. I got you bro thanks & cheers :) |
Arditi
07.15.19 | @SlicePaperMoog. Yeah man, I honestly can't stand the band overall. Even back then it was the only record I could tolerate. |
Uzumaki
07.15.19 | Hospital For Souls is a fucking barn burner of an ending.
I feel for arditi because (correct me if I’m wrong arditi) he and I are similar in the fact of how late we got into the genre, so therefore we gravitated towards bands/albums that others who were more firmly entrenched in the genre didn’t care for at all. Arditi grew out of metalcore and it seems like he’s trying to get back into it, and as y’all know I’m reverse-engineering my way through the genre, so as much as I wanna poke fun with all you other guys, I still feel like standing with arditi as well. |
mrdogthrow
07.15.19 | yeah uzu hospital is such an intense closer. Sempiternal is almost the perfect album |
Arditi
07.15.19 | @Uzumaki. Yeah, that sounds about right my friend! haha. Thanks for getting me :) |
MELONADE13
07.15.19 | kids these days |
Uzumaki
07.15.19 | Anytime, friend |