Drbebop
02.26.20 | Sgt Pepper ruined music as a whole. Some good songs on it tho |
Lucman
02.26.20 | Top 4 is pretty much spot on, though 2 may be 1 for me. |
ArsMoriendi
02.26.20 | "Sgt Pepper ruined music as a whole."
????????????????
Also Blue Jay Way is awesome |
MindsOfMen
02.26.20 | "Sgt Pepper ruined music as a whole."
Wow man someone is capping. There's no way 5 is better than 7 and 9. |
Drbebop
02.26.20 | Nope. The endless praise it got and how it keeps topping best albums of all time polls and how it’s considered by critics as the best album of all time means that everything else has to compare to it. Everything will always be compared to Pepper now. It takes the credit for everything like being the first concept album when it clearly isn’t. It gave way to prog which gave us shit like ELP and Rick Wakeman’s solo career. It made everyone overly pretentious and had them shunning simpler music for arty farty bullshit instead. It brought the industry as low as it could possibly go and sent music back to the Stone ages. Plus a couple of the songs are fairy shite. |
samwise2000
02.26.20 | Magical Mystery Tour is low-key probably the most consistently great Beatles record |
Drbebop
02.26.20 | Eh debatably. Side 2 is great but it gets a little too fillery in spots. Flying doesn’t need to be there for example. Blue Jay Way I have a love hate relationship with |
Egarran
02.26.20 | Correct list.
|
parksungjoon
02.26.20 | you know what, i regret ever defending your opinions |
Gyromania
02.26.20 | I'm only sleeping? Really? I mean it's good but for no one, taxman, tomorrow never knows, eleanor rigby. |
Gyromania
02.26.20 | And yeah peppers honestly isn't that good. Abbey road annihilates it |
Drbebop
02.26.20 | Idk i’m Only sleeping always struck me as John’s best song. It’s catchy, weird, lively and dreamy all at the same time. It was either that or Here there and everywhere for the top spot but IOS edged it out |
samwise2000
02.26.20 | @Gyro Abbey Road is best, agreed |
samwise2000
02.26.20 | Although I still think MMT is criminally underrated |
Kompys2000
02.26.20 | Wow man someone is capping [2] |
neekafat
02.26.20 | No |
ArsMoriendi
02.26.20 | Flying is good
Also MMT is my favorite Beatles
Bottom 5 are their first 5 |
Drbebop
02.26.20 | I do like Flying but it’s pretty obvious filler. I wish they kept the Mellotron ending tho |
wojodta
02.26.20 | 1 and 3 are best. 2 is super overrated. |
Minushuman24
02.26.20 | Magical mystery tour is forever number one. Abbey Road is probably 2 for me, then maybe rubber soul. |
SandwichBubble
02.26.20 | "It brought the industry as low as it could possibly go and sent music back to the Stone ages."
You ever think about a job as a politician, cause this is the kind of "statement that makes no statement" writing that could get you far. |
parksungjoon
02.26.20 | [Report this Post] |
SandwichBubble
02.26.20 | You can't report me!
I'll report YOU! |
parksungjoon
02.26.20 | not you, the post you quoted |
TabulaRasa6
02.26.20 | This is better than the Radiohead list. |
parksungjoon
02.26.20 | definitely not lol |
TabulaRasa6
02.26.20 | Nah, this might be the only list where I agree with most of the rankings. |
SandwichBubble
02.26.20 | I keep re-reading the paragraph like I'm gonna understand it this time.
I never do.
It haunts me with it's incorrectness. |
parksungjoon
02.26.20 | "Nah, this might be the only list where I agree with most of the rankings."
if you think pepper isnt a top 5 beatles album you are beyond redemption my friend |
TabulaRasa6
02.26.20 | I did say "most" and not "all". Lol
For example, I think it's madness that Magical Mystery Tour is above Pepper. |
virpi
02.27.20 | Good list, near the top it gets impossible for me to rank the albums. Sgt. Pepper is overrated by many, but it's also historically very important. Top 3 for me: Abbey road, Revolver, MMT |
rockarollacola
02.27.20 | The fact that Boys isn't the worst song on Please Please Me is utterly outrageous. Fuck that song. I fucking hate Boys. |
Lucman
02.27.20 | All the love for MMT is strange. It's a great record but Rubber Soul, A Hard Day's Night, White, Abby, Revolver, and even Help far ahead of it. I'd say the top 6 here is almost perfect. Switch 8 with 9 and move it (Let It Be) just above Yellow Submarine. Not a fan of that record. |
MindsOfMen
02.27.20 | "Nope. The endless praise it got and how it keeps topping best albums of all time polls and how it’s considered by critics as the best album of all time means that everything else has to compare to it. Everything will always be compared to Pepper now. It takes the credit for everything like being the first concept album when it clearly isn’t. It gave way to prog which gave us shit like ELP and Rick Wakeman’s solo career. It made everyone overly pretentious and had them shunning simpler music for arty farty bullshit instead. It brought the industry as low as it could possibly go and sent music back to the Stone ages. Plus a couple of the songs are fairy shite."
You're right, Sgt. Pepper's is compared to everything. Just the other day I was listening to Slaughter of the Soul by At the Gates and Sgt. Pepper's was the first album on my mind. Lmao.
And I don't see how it's pretentious? It's a really fun, laid back album which is part of the reason it works so well. Yeah quite a few of its songs have deeper meanings, but they're all pretty fun on a surface level. Idk man. It's a weird album to get upset about.
|
Hendoi
02.27.20 | incorrect list |
Sinternet
02.27.20 | I'd probs say White Album > Rubber Soul > Revolver is my top 3 but that peppers comment is the stupidest thing i've ever read |
Kompys2000
02.27.20 | People get so heated over Sgt. Pepper's lmao |
Egarran
02.27.20 | Imagine being upset about a Beatles album in 2020 lmfao |
virpi
02.27.20 | The White Album is great, but there clearly are too many weak songs. If you omit those, it's almost perfect. |
DDDeftoneDDD
02.27.20 | My dad bought Yellow Submarine movie when I was a kid...It was quite an early drugless trip |
Pangea
02.27.20 | switching 2 and 7 would make it pretty close to my ranking. 1 is definitely the best i agree |
qwenta
02.27.20 | Sgt Peppers has A day in the life, the greatest song ever (or close to), it bumps the album to perfection. |
wham49
02.27.20 | im a fan of for sale, would put it higher,but pretty god list
also shes leaving home is a great song |
BigHans
02.27.20 | Abbey Road
Rubber Soul
Sgt Pepper
White
Ok I give up but yeah theres no way 1 is 1 and that 5 is better than 7,8, and 9 |
TVC15
02.28.20 | In what universe is She’s Leaving Home the worst song on Sgt. Pepper |
CaliggyJack
02.28.20 | Sgt. Peppers at 9?
You must be high |
DePlazz
02.28.20 | Sgt. Pepper should be top 4 |