ArsMoriendi
06.13.20 | 1.Animals
2.Dark Side
3.Piper
4.Meddle
5.Wish You Were Here |
Ryus
06.13.20 | no piper means list is bad |
Titan
06.13.20 | No way Piper is top 5
Not a chance |
Pikazilla
06.13.20 | It's better than the wall for sure |
Titan
06.13.20 | Dont get me wrong, I love the record, but no chance
NO CHANCE |
neekafat
06.13.20 | its pretty much on par imo, both are acceptable #5 picks |
Titan
06.13.20 | Piper is the dude that doesn't get the girl in the end |
MementoMori
06.13.20 | Nah, I wouldn't say Piper makes the cut. Great record though. Meddle is probably the more underrated PF record, while Dark Side takes the cake for being the most overrated. |
Ryus
06.13.20 | meddle is underrated yea
top 4 for me is piper, animals, dark side, then meddle |
Pikazilla
06.13.20 | The Wall is the lame fat uncle who's also a closet sociopath |
Pikazilla
06.13.20 | top 4 for me is piper, animals, dark side, then meddle
Absolutely |
Titan
06.13.20 | The Wall is banging porn stars dude |
Pikazilla
06.13.20 | Retired pornstars with stds, yeah |
Titan
06.13.20 | Meddle over Piper all day long |
Pikazilla
06.13.20 | Wish you were here, animals, piper, dark side, meddle - best floyd, easily
And the only floyd you probably need |
Inoculaeted
06.13.20 | No saucer love. |
Titan
06.13.20 | Momentary Lapse and Division Bell, whether you like them or not, are essential to their discography. Most Floyd albums are indicative of the times in which they were recorded.
Compare them to what their peers were doing. I dare anyone. |
Sinternet
06.13.20 | trash band psych era was good i guess |
Titan
06.13.20 | they're no miley cyrus agreed |
budgie
06.13.20 | still enver heard 5
hiya titan
|
Titan
06.13.20 | sup bro
get on the song Echoes at least budgie.....if you don't like it, you don't ever have to speak to me ever again |
samwise2000
06.13.20 | The 5 in this list are definitely the most popular picks, and for good reason (although its nice to see animals at 1 for a change) |
FR33L0RD
06.13.20 | Any position of the Top-4 here is fine with me, quatro rules. |
evilford
06.14.20 | 1. Dark side
2. Animals
3. Wywh
4. The final cut
5. Piper |
Thor
06.14.20 | 1. The Wall
2. Animals
3. WYWH
4. Dark Side
5. Meddle |
Inoculaeted
06.14.20 | 1. Dark side
2. Animals
3. WYWH
4. Meddle
5. Saucerful |
protokute
06.14.20 | 1. piper + early singles
2. dark side of the moon
3. meddle
4. animals
5. wish you were here |
MementoMori
06.14.20 | No no, only my ranking is correct my dudes. Seriously though, interesting to see the divergence here. |
Inoculaeted
06.14.20 | All good ranks. I’m finding it interesting how many of these don’t have The Wall top 5 (myself included). I don’t even know why. It’s a good album. It’s just not as exciting as a lot of their others for some reason. |
MementoMori
06.14.20 | I quite like the politics and conceptual side of it (though Pink Floyd tends to have that generally). |
JokineAugustus
06.14.20 | Animals
Wish You Were Here
Piper
Dark Side
Meddle |
Faraudo
06.14.20 | Animals will always be 1. |
wojodta
06.14.20 | Wall is def top 3 Floyd. It's one of their most emotional records and that's why I love it. |
evilford
06.14.20 | The final cut felt to me like what roger really wanted to make with the wall. Not much from the wall sticks with me. The final cut, on the other hand, is just chock full of emotionally powerful moments and great lyricism, even if the emphasis isnt on musicianship. Super underrated album imo. I'll never not love that album |
wojodta
06.14.20 | Final cut's in my top 5 as well. So I agree with all that. It's probably their darkest album. |
evilford
06.14.20 | Oh definitely. Doesnt get much darker than two suns in the sunset or the title track |
Inoculaeted
06.14.20 | Fuck I gotta listen to that |
protokute
06.15.20 | The experience of listening to The Wall all the way is pretty tiring, and tbh that aren't a lot of exciting songs, and the political stuff doesn't do really much to me there apart from some songs. |
protokute
06.15.20 | And yes, I really need to get around on listening to the later Pink Floyd albums |
Morningrise767
06.15.20 | 5
3
2
4
1 |
Inoculaeted
06.15.20 | The Wall is a great musical, but it sounds as though they compromised their tendency to push the experimental boundaries in favor of creating a cohesive narrative. There are undeniable bangers, but the album feels more pop than anything else they’ve done. |
wojodta
06.15.20 | It's definitely better to listen to it beginning to end. With the exception of Comfortably Numb, there's nothing on there that I'd be compelled to listen to by itself. |
evilford
06.16.20 | I used to jam one of my turns daily. Great song. But yeah that's the conundrum with the wall; it is better as a whole piece rather than the sum of its parts, but it is so bloated and goofy in spots that you eventually lose interest. That's been my experience at least. It's still a great album but not anywhere close to their best like dark side, wywh or animals |