Tundra
01.27.22 | The comments section will be a shitshow for sure, I don't care if you disagree |
Kompys2000
01.27.22 | remission fans BTFO |
bgillesp
01.27.22 | I’ll come at you with an equally(?) hot take
7>5>3>the rest |
FR33L0RD
01.27.22 | I agree, to disagree. to each is own man. I respect your opinion.
4-6-2 are my Top3 |
BlazinBlitzer
01.27.22 | Hmm
2 > 4 > 8 > 7 > 6 > 1 > 3 > 5 |
Djang0
01.27.22 | Recently got into this band's discography, and I remember thinking how bad Emperor of Sand was so this list befuddled me to say the least but props for a unique ranking. |
TheAntichrist
01.27.22 | lmao 8 is not mastodon's worst |
Tundra
01.27.22 | I know the first 4 mastodon albums are placed in such high regard by many, but just dont see it with remission or blood mountain. I like how the 4 are themed around fire, earth, water, air, but I just dont get so much a earth vibe on blood mountain, or a fire vibe on remission. All I hear is 'riff fast', 'drum fast', 'screamy scream', and i cant tolerate that very much for a long period of time. I prefer when they included more melody into their later albums. Besides Hushed as shown, that album is such a draaaag to me, even if it does have a fair bit of melody in it. |
Flugmorph
01.27.22 | this is the funniest ranking ive ever seen
thank you for the laugh |
combustion07
01.27.22 | 4,6,8,2,5,3
Still need to really jam the others |
Dwap
01.27.22 | Woah
This is some crazy shit |
bigguytoo9
01.27.22 | Leviathan is the only worthy album. Crack The Skye is bullshit watered down tripe. |
Kompys2000
01.27.22 | Leviathan is gr8 but hunter is better ;) |
rockarollacola
01.27.22 | Took some balls to post this list, so big props. 2 favorites are The Hunter and Once More Round the Sun because I'm retarded. |
Icebloom
01.27.22 | 1, 2 and 3 are my favourite Mastodon albums as well! Although I'd probably put Once More 'Round the Sun at 1.
"All I hear is 'riff fast', 'drum fast', 'screamy scream', and i cant tolerate that very much for a long period of time. I prefer when they included more melody into their later albums." Yeah that sums up my thoughts about the early albums, agreed hard. I'm just not into that kind of music. (Blasphemy!) |
JDubb
01.27.22 | Sweet ranking. More in my line of thinking. 2 is my 1. Love 3. And 6 and 7 would be higher. 8 is 8. |
TheAntichrist
01.27.22 | no it's not are u smokin crock |
Sunnyvale
01.27.22 | Almost certainly the first time this particular ranking has been posted here... Interesting stuff. I'd say mine would be 2, 4, 7, 3, 6, 8, 5, 1, but some of those are flexible. |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.27.22 | your comic timing has gone downhill since the metallica ranking, idk where the punchline is on this one |
TabulaRasa6
01.27.22 | A very controversial list but respect for putting it out there. Blood Mountain or Crack the Skye would probably take top spot for me. Idk how I'd rank the rest. |
Tundra
01.27.22 | don't comment on my threads then JohnnyoftheShitheads |
Sinternet
01.27.22 | oh man who hurt you boy |
Flugmorph
01.27.22 | tundra is a good lad |
Tundra
01.27.22 | bro he was clearly being elitist, he asked for it and I'm defending myself??? |
Tundra
01.27.22 | Got it, passive aggressive remarks only, thank you sheriff, good day |
CygnusX1
01.27.22 | 4>6>8>2>>>3,5,7,1. First half of their discog is great. Second half is okay, a few good tracks here or there. Cold dark place was cool |
AlexKzillion
01.27.22 | rank their guitar solos next please |
Kompys2000
01.27.22 | Cold dark place pimp slaps their last two |
Pangea
01.27.22 | personally i am more of a mammoth fan |
Ryus
01.27.22 | 8 is 1 thats all that matters |
JDubb
01.27.22 | I can see an argument for 4 or 6 as #1. But honestly, 8 is 8. |
evilford
01.27.22 | Haha johnnyoftheshitheads |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.28.22 | wow what did i miss oh wow
plz amend this status to johnnyoftheshitthread - thought this ranking of the band mastodon had taught me what's good for me, but alas |
Koris
01.28.22 | Putting 8 at 8 is punishable by death, dontcha know? |