JohnnyoftheWell: skramz comebacks RANKED

JohnnyoftheWell 05.12.23	definitive list etc fuck off
Ryus 05.12.23	move up 7 and 8 nuke 5 and 6 into oblivion
JohnnyoftheWell 05.12.23	hatred for 6 will be tolerated but the cutoff between 5 and the rest of the list is pronounced and unmendable
Wildcardbitchesss 05.12.23	I’m just patiently waiting for Pg 99 to do something
Ryus 05.12.23	that would be amazing fr
MillionDead 05.12.23	CTtS is one of those bands I still have immense respect for, but their style of songwriting has aged weirdly enough for me to not care to check out the stuff that's newer. Mostly cause the cleans are mad cringe at times.
Supercoolguy64 05.12.23	8 was such a let down and all the bullshit surrounding its announcement and eventual release did not help
hesperus 05.12.23	hot take: people who were taken aback by LP probably didn't know much about Jeromes Dream and definitely either forgot about Presents or didn't listen to it in the first place. the vocal performance is perfectly serviceable and arguably works better with the style they went for on that album than screams would have
hesperus 05.12.23	anyway, these are all great releases by great bands, but i think 5 takes my blue ribbon
Ryus 05.12.23	jahgreed
Supercoolguy64 05.12.23	LP getting compared to presents is always painful to see. LP didn’t have riffs or meaty production.
Pikazilla 05.12.23	very good list, although 8 sucks big time 1, 6, and 7 are prolly my favourites here :3
DungeonBoy 05.12.23	Decompositions Volume I is better than Rites of Initiation and many days I prefer it to As the Roots Undo ducks behind cover
Pikazilla 05.12.23	Understandable, I'd put the two on the same level tbh
botb 05.12.23	Pretty solid takes here. I do love that gospel record but couldve done without 9 completely. And jeromes dream is maybe the most overrated skramz band of all time
ConcubinaryCode 05.12.23	It'd be cool if CTTS actually made a follow up to the comeback. I still think LP got a lot of flak, it's not a staple release but still fun although I'll admit my love for it has waned a lot since release. A bit surprised to see Gospel so low but I get it. 3 does indeed hit hard and am waiting for the next album
botb 05.12.23	You could technically include the No Man releases on this too since it’s all 3 majority rule dudes and maha on vocals (who also did guest vocals on multiple majority rule records)
gnarwhalsam 05.12.23	Yeah pretty accurate, most of these aren't good except COC. I was disappointed by the Gospel records. Largely the recording and production. The drummer is insane and The Moon Is A Dead World does such a great job highlighting that.
Sniff 05.12.23	New take. JD were never that good to begin with
Ryus 05.12.23	wtf
Prancer 05.12.23	is 2 supposed to be the comeback to the comeback? either way I think I agree with this list. CoC is the best and gospel's newest grew off me a bit
cylinder 05.14.23	breh you got 7 and 1 mixed up
JohnnyoftheWell 05.14.23	7 contains probably the single worst song on this whole list so that's gonna be a no
Winsomniac 05.14.23	Curious to see how Loma Prieta gonna fit into this
botb 05.14.23	If you think 1 isn’t 1 you haven’t listened to it probably
Kompys2000 05.14.23	"has not aged particularly well" for the second newest album on the list now THAT'S what I call johnnyposting
JohnnyoftheWell 05.14.23	the three yardsticks for whether an album has aged well or not are 1 yr, 10 yrs and 30 yrs gospel have loser'd at the first hurdle
Kompys2000 05.14.23	You posted this list one (1) day before album in question turned one year old, mission failed on a technicality alas
Sniff 05.14.23	#facts
Demon of the Fall 05.14.23	1 and 2 is accurate 7 is probably underrated but then I don’t care about CTTS
Mort. 05.15.23	what about that cypress dust witch ep portraits of past put out like 14 years ago?
unclereich 05.15.23	Lp is underrated[2] 😝
Sniff 05.15.23	One thing we all can agree on is that 8 is 8
Ryus 05.15.23	8 is like 3 or 4
BAT 05.15.23	Still haven't peeped the new gospel. And jd-lp was solid but that one senza album overshadowed it for me. Watchu think of new sawtooth grin.
XingKing 05.15.23	Gospel is my favorite out of all of these so this list hurts my soul deeply
Wildcardbitchesss 05.15.23	Same : ( City of Caterpillar is def number 2 for me tho