KTV
07.20.09 | 10 is too low |
FreePizzaDay
07.20.09 | 9 has always been my favorite album. I'm a sci-fi nerrrrrrd. I haven't listened to much Maiden made after 1989. |
XulOnerom
07.20.09 | SSOASS is my fav Maiden album |
sba4life
07.20.09 | 8,9,10,and 11 should be at the top of the list man. |
Fxxkit13
07.20.09 | agreed ^^^
Brave New World is pretty good though |
Zizzer
07.20.09 | I still like 8-11, I just like the above ones better. I like Maiden's new stuff a lot |
Fxxkit13
07.20.09 | Interesting....Are you generally more of hard rock fan or metal? |
Ire
07.20.09 | Somewhere in Time should be at number one
FAEL |
Lunarfall
07.20.09 | powerslave definitely should be #1 |
ninjuice
07.20.09 | "11 should be higher"?
Isn't Fear of the Dark supposed to suck? |
KILL
07.20.09 | 10 is way too low |
Piglet
07.20.09 | gee i dunno |
Fxxkit13
07.20.09 | Fear of the Dark is an okay album. Definitely better then their newest releases (except for maybe BNW) |
Piglet
07.20.09 | list is a bit wonky... unless it's entitled to the guy's favourite albums. Not the best albums in his opinion if you get what I'm saying. |
shindip
07.20.09 | aside from 10s lowness, list is good |
Zizzer
07.20.09 | Don't get me wrong... I still like 10 but just not as much as the others above it.
And Fear of the Dark and Afraid to Shoot Strangers are great songs I think but the rest of the album is kind of iffy so I ranked it low. |
Piglet
07.20.09 | all the albums are good anyway so what the hell |
FadeToBlack
07.20.09 | 5 too high, 10 too low |
Douchebag
07.20.09 | 9 and 10 are better than killers. apart from that looks about right at a glance. |
Piglet
07.20.09 | i love A Matter Between Life and Death. |
FadeToBlack
07.20.09 | Yah it's good but it's a bit drawn out imo. I prefer BNW and DOD |
Piglet
07.20.09 | hmmm... AMBLAD was my first album I heard from Iron Maiden which probably explains why i love it so much. |
Douchebag
07.20.09 | New Maiden is just as good as classic maiden in my opinion. In fact if you just stay away from the 90's maiden can do no wrong. |
Piglet
07.20.09 | yeh well, lots of people think the newer stuff ain't as 'gallopy' which is probably true since not a lot of newer bands retain that old style. |
Douchebag
07.20.09 | agreed, but it's still fun. I mean if they were still getting the gallop going people would tire. they still get a fair old gallop going, it's just used in doses. |
Nagrarok
07.20.09 | 10 so low is a crime, as it slays basically everything above it except 1 and 3. 2 is highly overrated. Good thing about putting NPFTD lowest instead of the Bayley albums though. |
Zizzer
07.20.09 | Meh, the only good thing on NPFTD is Mother Russia. |
MetalMassacreAttack
08.02.09 | #1 is fine
#2 is overrated and too poppy (maybe that fits your taste better, who knows) should be ~5 imo
#3 Is fine
#4, #5, #6 are similar, though #6 should be the highest one imo.
#7 , #10 are underrated, should be ~2-5 imo
The lowest positions are fine. |
FadeToBlack
08.02.09 | fail at 2 being 'poppy'. Just cause you don't like it, doesn't mean you can make false statements. |
shindip
08.02.09 | 10 should be higher |
Yazz_Flute
08.02.09 | how is 2 poppy
9 and 10 are way too low imo. |
MetalMassacreAttack
08.02.09 | Who said I don´t like it? I gave this a 4.0 (excellent) rating on this site. And often listen to it, just check my last.fm account.
What I mean is this album, except for the incredible title track, relies quite a bit on sing along choruses, repetitive lines and structures, most songs being verse/chorus/verse/chorus/solo/chorus. I have nothing against keyboards and songs being accessble, but SSoaSS lacks the creativity other albums like PoM and Somewhere In Time have.
Still a great album, nevertheless. |
FadeToBlack
08.02.09 | The same can be said for many tracks off all of their albums (Run To The Hills, Die With Your Boots On, 2 Minutes To Midnight etc etc).
Anyway I will stop arguing with you now :P |
JacobsLadder
08.02.09 | No Maiden ranked list can be correct they have just too many amazing albums. |
FadeToBlack
08.02.09 | That's true |
MetalMassacreAttack
08.03.09 | Aight Fade, let´s be friends =)
@ Jacobs
There´s no such thing as a correct opinion list. But yup, Maiden have way too many great albums, and that makes lists about ´em very polemic |
