Inveigh
02.21.11 | great list, but there are a good amount of discs on here that I'd put about 1. if you haven't already... check out
Judge - New York Crew
Verse - Aggression
7 Seconds - The Crew
Champion - Promises Kept
Youth of Today - Disengage |
Inveigh
02.21.11 | *above, not about lol |
Aids
02.21.11 | (listen to emo):
Off Minor - The Heat Death of The Universe
Saetia - A Retrospective
City of Caterpillar - City of Caterpillar
Gospel - The Moon Is A Cold Dead World
The Saddest Landscape - You Will Not Survive
Sed Non Satiata - Sed Not Satiata
Daitro - Laissez Vivre Les Squellettes
etc..... |
WeepingBanana
02.21.11 | Bane - Give Blood
Touche Amore - To the Beat of a Dead Horse |
thediamondcanopy
02.21.11 | lack of Converge makes me weep |
Blackbelt54
02.21.11 | yeah the descendents is a pretty big stretch, i'll admit... |
kris.
02.21.11 | goddamn people need to learn what hardcore is
1
is not hardcore
neither is 10
and lol at converge being hardcore
goddamn |
Blackbelt54
02.21.11 | what is 1 considered? ik that 10 really isn't idk why i had it in there, and ik that converge isnt hardcore. im not good with genres and stuff |
AmericnZero02
02.21.11 | I'd call 1 post hardcore. |
Inveigh
02.21.11 | I think you can get away with calling 1 hardcore, but I've always thought of it as post-hardcore. the rest of Refused's discog is decidedly hardcore in nature though. |
Scoot
02.21.11 | dangers - anger is my #1 |
AliW1993
02.21.11 | Very nice list, I really need to check out Husker Du. |
eternium
02.21.11 | Both 3 and 1 are debatable but acceptable.
Amazing list, quite similar to mine. |
LegendofPittman
02.21.11 | Geez this list is extremely good. |
Adabelle
02.21.11 | I only have 5-and-a-half of these, I need to sort my life out. |
couldwinarabbit
02.21.11 | 1 kinda sucks but you have awesome other albums so cool list bro.
|
WeepingBanana
02.22.11 | also, wrong discharge album |
ShadowRemains
02.22.11 | "...and cursed suck"
waitwut |
cvlts
02.22.11 | what the fuck, hep!
so it ain't the swarm, who gives a fuck |
demigod!
02.22.11 | how the hell isn't converge hardcore? they're just a different style
fucking elitists
|
patroneyes
02.22.11 | glad to see nausea on here, i love that album
pushing the envelope of hardcore with a bunch of these albums, though |
Aids
02.22.11 | The Shape of Punk To Come is post-hardcore (but I see "hardcore" as somewhat of an umbrella term anyway)
Converge are Hardcore/Metalcore, I don't know why calling Converge hardcore makes you "lol," it's what they are.
but who cares, arguing about genres is stupid |
Inveigh
02.22.11 | good point Pit, although I always though of Zen Arcade as more hardcore punk than post-hardcore (we're splitting hairs obviously at this point). I mean, if hardcore's the umbrella term, then yeah Converge should count, because Integrity's on here (they're essentially metalcore too).
genre debates are so motherfucking confusing after awhile. |
porch
02.22.11 | zen arcade broke all the rules of traditional hardcore
and the bassist had a handlebar moustache |
Inveigh
02.22.11 | funny because that's now pretty much rule #1 of starting a hardcore band |
Blackbelt54
02.22.11 | yeah i kinda used "hardcore" pretty loosely |
AgentYorkMorgan
02.22.11 | Glad to finally see a Bad Brains album on a "top hardcore" list
I love that band |
cvlts
02.22.11 | god i was waiting for that |
Spec
02.22.11 | Needs Verse- Aggression. |
Inveigh
02.22.11 | "Glad to finally see a Bad Brains album on a "top hardcore" list
I love that band"
who the fuck is arcade fire |
cvlts
02.22.11 | was a little hungry for more, but veigh satisfied it |
Spec
02.22.11 | Who did "Songs To Fuck To?" |
Titan50
02.22.11 | >no Rites Of Spring
>wat |
Creature
02.22.11 | I would have added Hatebreed - Satisfaction is the Death of Desire, but nonetheless a solid list |
EyesWideShut
02.22.11 | list has some amazing shit man.. I got Refused as h/c also and Converge is to.
for recs check em out'
chokehold
hatred surge
backstabbers inc
mind eraser
extortion |
MrSnuffles
02.23.11 | lack of converge makes me happy. |
patroneyes
02.23.11 | http://bit.ly/hb2mN0 |
BringMeABrick
02.23.11 | Siiick list. |
djunior
02.23.11 | listen to Mountain Man |
Aids
02.23.11 | Mountain Man the non-hardcore band is so fucking good
listen to that Mountain Man |
LifeInABox
02.24.11 | lacking Cro Mags and the Bad Brains LP is too low. Some good bands, some not so good bands. |
omnipanzer
02.24.11 | lots o goodness but no Hatebreed :^(
Cheers on the rest though. |
ConsiderPhlebas
02.24.11 | "goddamn people need to learn what hardcore is
1
is not hardcore"
-UhhKris
"While Refused remains fucking dead for now, their music lives on in a must have collection of the most crucial hardcore ever created."
-Epitaph records
"Well, we weren’t crusties by any means. Our two favourite bands were Manliftbanner and Born Against – and then Slayer of course. But we clearly defined ourselves as a punk/hardcore band. I mean, there was a metal edge to our music, but in the attitude, in what we did, in how we did it, in the politics we had, and in the life we led, we definitely identified as a punk band."
-Dennis Lyxzen, vocalist from Refused |
Aids
02.24.11 | people getting all pissy about Refused being called Hardcore are ridiculous. personally I'd call TSOPTC post-hardcore but is it really that big of a deal? |
ConsiderPhlebas
02.24.11 | Call it what you want, that's not an issue. When retarded kids who know nothing about hardcore start saying people need to learn what hardcore is, it's time to bring out the big guns. |
Funeralopolis
12.13.14 | "Cryptopsy, Gorguts, and Ulcerate would trash half of these hardcore acts just by heaviness alone. I'm not saying the list is wrong, it's just, hardcore's "metal" moments, rather, it's heaviest sections cannot hold a candle to death metal. I.E. Deftones - Adrenaline vs Cryptopsy - None So Vile. Some may say I can't do that, "two different genre's" argument, but screw it! I'm me I do what I want! jk I'm not that ignorant, but first getting into metal, listening to slayer and pantera and stuff, the thought came to me that, "This stuff is heavy, but there's gotta be something heavier." Another example, the first CD I ever listened to was Rusted Root's 'When I Woke.' That first track, "Drum Trip," I thought NO SONG in the world could top it, and then I met Jamie Saint Merat...and now I'm in a battle of wishing I had my ignorance back (ignorance is bliss), then I digress and say FUCK THAT and thank sputnik m/... Awesome list regardless dude, Shai being #1 is deserved, and y u no have Chain of Strength or Inside Out?!? =)"
|