gwh45
03.18.11 | Missing Dr. Strangelove : ) |
ffs
03.18.11 | this is a music website m8 |
Samshine
03.18.11 | Don't see how this is relevant to music
(but 4 is awesome) |
Rev
03.18.11 | I'm not a huge Floyd fan, but Jupiter and Beyond the Infinite + Echoes = fucking nuts |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | "Missing Dr. Strangelove : )"
Knew that was comming haha. Sorry for all the random question marks in there by the way. Don't know how to prevent that from happening. |
NigelH
03.18.11 | Good list. Kubrick is probably my favorite director, even though I've only seen 1,2,3, and parts of 4. |
MO
03.18.11 | I agree with 2001 being first. Such an incredible movie. Me and the band actually named our EP "And Beyond the Infinite". |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | Haha damn, I thought I was being original when I named my first song "Jupiter and Beyond the Infinite." |
omnipanzer
03.18.11 | How do you contain it to 5? |
Idnuf
03.18.11 | I HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATE 2001 with such fervor it makes me lightheaded. Excellent write-ups though. |
omnipanzer
03.18.11 | Full Metal Jacket
Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb
A Clockwork Orange
2001: A Space Odyssey
The Shining
Barry Lyndon
Lolita
Eyes Wide Shut
Honorable mention to A.I. It would have been so much better if Kubrick had done it. Instead you got Steven Spielberg's version of a Kubrick movie. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | "I HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATE 2001 with such fervor it makes me lightheaded. Excellent write-ups though."
Haha thanks man. Yeah it's a obviously a pretty divisive movie.. you're definitely not alone. Pretty much all of my friends that I made watch it hated it. The only two that liked it absolutely loved it though.
"How do you contain it to 5?"
It was pretty necessary or I would've been writing for like 3 hours =) |
MO
03.18.11 | Spartacus was great too |
omnipanzer
03.18.11 | "It was pretty necessary or I would've been writing for like 3 hours =)"
Fair enough. |
omnipanzer
03.18.11 | I HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATE Spartacus with such fervor it makes me
lightheaded. I don't blame Kubrick for that one though there was a tremendous amount of studio
interference (and Heston interference)on that one. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | "Honorable mention to A.I. It would have been so much better if Kubrick had done it. Instead you got Steven Spielberg's version of a Kubrick movie."
Definitely. Honestly I liked A.I. a lot more that most people seem to. It definitely had some brilliant moments but it had pitfalls too. It sucks that he didn't live long enough to make it on his own for sure. |
vmcoia91
03.18.11 | Lolita and Barry Lyndon are so much better than Eyes Wide Shut and Full Metal Jacket. |
omnipanzer
03.18.11 | "Honestly I liked A.I. a lot more that most people seem to."
I did to but I watched with the fact that it was Kubrick's baby in mind. I wasn't expecting an new E.T. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | I've actually never seen Spartacus... I'm kind of hesitant because Stanley himself said he hated how the movie turned out and that he is ashamed his name is attached to it.... that was a pretty big deterrent haha. |
omnipanzer
03.18.11 | ^ don't watch it imo.
"Lolita and Barry Lyndon are so much better than Eyes Wide Shut and Full Metal Jacket."
I agree about EWS but not FMJ... not even close. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | "Lolita and Barry Lyndon are so much better than Eyes Wide Shut and Full Metal Jacket."
Barry Lyndon is SOO good yeah. It was hard to not include that on the list but there are a couple scenes from Eyes Wide Shut that just really hit me hard. I wasn't totally blown away by Lolita. It was obviously a very good movie relative to other things coming out at that time but I feel like he hadn't reached his full potential yet at that point. I've only seen it once though.. should probably watch it again. |
vmcoia91
03.18.11 | Honestly, Eyes Wide Shut is pretty bad. Also, never understood the love for FML. I'll admit the first hour or so is good, but then it goes all down hill. At least the top 3 in this list is kind of right. |
vmcoia91
03.18.11 | Oh and The Killing is way underrated. Watch that if you haven't and make sure to watch Spartacus it's good. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | "Honestly, Eyes Wide Shut is pretty bad. Also, never understood the love for FML. I'll admit the first hour or so is good, but then it goes all down hill. At least the top 3 in this list is kind of right."
I actually agree to an extent about Full Metal. I do think the first half is stronger than the second. The ending doesn't quite have the same impact that he is usually capable of and the transition from the boot camp to the war does take away a bit of the flow. It's not enough to overshadow all the amazing themes and scenes in my opinion though. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | I'll probably watch Spartacus at some point.
"Oh and The Killing is way underrated. Watch that if you haven't"
I have the same feeling about Eyes Wide Shut haha. I really need to see The Killing though... I couldn't find a way to get access to it but I think it's streaming on Netflix now. I definitely don't expect it to breach this list but I'm sure it's a good movie at the very least. |
Titan50
03.18.11 | Oh God... The Shining is the most intense thing... |
KILL
03.18.11 | so good |
Josh D.
03.18.11 | Excellent list, probs my ranking. |
theacademy
03.18.11 | eyes wide shit has exactly 1 scene worth watching and any 13+ year old boy knows exactly what it is |
Josh D.
03.18.11 | EWS is underrated. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | "Excellent list, probs my ranking."
Thanks. Yeah Eyes Wide Shut is definitely underrated. It's not his best movie but it's far better than what most directors ever accomplish. The construction of the plot and how the characters subtly parallel each other is extremely well done. Plus is just has that distinct Kubrick atmosphere that can't be reproduced. The music mixed with the cinematography is amazing as always with him. |
vmcoia91
03.18.11 | I like the fact that you didn't include Paths of Glory. I think that's Kubrick's most overrated movie. |
Kubrick
03.18.11 | Yeah it's probably pretty clear from my choices that I prefer his more recent movies to his early ones. Not that his early films are bad by any stretch of the imagination (the ones I have seen at least). I personally feel like he just hadn't really reached the potential he was capable of at this point in his career. He was making great movies but nothing I've seen from that era captivates me as much as the films on my list, especially the top 3. I think his shift into color films was where he really hit his stride and just made masterpiece after masterpiece. |
FearThyEvil
03.19.11 | 2 and 4 are outstanding movies. |
vmcoia91
03.19.11 | I don't know if you watch foreign films or not, but if not check out some Federico Fellini, Jean-Luc Goddard, and Ingmar Bergman films. Since you like Kubrick so much you'll love these directors if you don't already. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | 1, 2, and 3 can be interchangable for me. There are so many good scenes in The Shining that blow me away, ACO is all around incredible, and 2001 is basically/literally beyond words.
Can't make up my mind. |
vmcoia91
03.19.11 | re-watched 4 tonight and yeah it's no where near his best. Sorry, but it's not. |
telebyrd
03.19.11 | Fantastic list. Eyes Wide Shut is my last Kubrick film on this list to view. I'm holding out. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | If it weren't almost 3am and I wasn't really drunk and didn't want to sleep all day tomorrow, I would totally hit some The Shining, but it's just not the best time. I will tomorrow. |
vmcoia91
03.19.11 | Josh D. please tell me you've seen the better Kubrick films like Barry Lyndon and Lolita. |
Slum
03.19.11 | I really hate 2001, love all the other films of his that i've seen though |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | I have this 5 movie boxed set of these movies, plus a documentary about him. I haven't seen his other ones really. I feel bad for saying it, but it's difficult for me to get around to them. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | "I really hate 2001"
Time to die. |
vmcoia91
03.19.11 | How can someone not like 2001 it's the perfect movie |
vmcoia91
03.19.11 | lol @ Static. Lolita and Barry Lyndon are great. Both sadly underrated. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Hate 2001?
Everyone hates you. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | http://30.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_li9n3nkF4T1qd66x8o1_500.gif |
vmcoia91
03.19.11 | Oh and when I said "better" films I just meant that Lolita and Bary Lyndon are better than Full Metal Jacket and Eyes Wide Shut. Nothing compares to ACO and 2001, in terms of Kubrick's work. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | If you claim to like cinema, and dislike 2001, fall down stairs.
If you're just a general movie person and dislike 2001, get punched in the ovaries.
It rules, is what I'm saying.
"I'm afraid....Dave" |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | What's lol about that, that means it is better than...well, most movies ever. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | I'm this close to sexting you with that attitude. |
Slum
03.19.11 | Pretty lame movie tbh |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Fuck you, man, it's time to go pole-to-pole. |
MUNGOLOID
03.19.11 | no matter how hard i tried, i could never sit through one viewing of 2001. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Fucker. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | I am SO angry. |
Trebor.
03.19.11 | I agree, but swap 5 with Dr. Strangelove |
Slum
03.19.11 | What static said |
erasedcitizen
03.19.11 | Nay, A Clockwork Orange is pretentious garbage. 2001 is a bit of a masterpiece. |
Slum
03.19.11 | How so? For ACO |
Trebor.
03.19.11 | All his movies are awesome so why argue |
erasedcitizen
03.19.11 | I think it's his worst script ever. It's boring and the themes became irrelevant after the rebellious generation it catered to grew old. The book, while also pretty boring at least fully developed Alex's character who is much smarter and more self aware than the movie makes it seem. Kubrick took the book out of context to make a controversial Hollywood flick. He never even filmed the actual ending. |
Slum
03.19.11 | lol it's a discussion, not an argument. |
Edwin
03.19.11 | A Clockwork Orange
2001
The Shining
Dr. Strangelove
Full Metal Jacket |
Trebor.
03.19.11 | Let us discuss why it is not an argument.
Sarcasm is hard to type |
Kubrick
03.19.11 | "I don't know if you watch foreign films or not, but if not check out some Federico Fellini, Jean-Luc Goddard, and Ingmar Bergman films."
Yeah I watch foreign films. I actually have some films by these guys in my Netflix queue (had to actually check because that thing is like swamped with movies that I don't even remember adding haha). Thanks for the rec though, I'll check them all out for sure.
"Fantastic list. Eyes Wide Shut is my last Kubrick film on this list to view. I'm holding out."
Thanks dude. I actually did the same thing with Barry Lyndon. It was his last color film that I hadn't seen and I went like a whole year waiting to see it because I just didn't want to run out. I was so blown away by the cinematography in that film. Nearly every frame of it looks as though it could be a painting in a museum. It was worth watching just for that.
"I really hate 2001, love all the other films of his that i've seen though"
Kinda surprises me actually. Most people I've watched 2001 with that didn't like it don't really like Kubrick movies in general. If you generally like his style and direction idk how that movie could not blow you away. It's pretty much the ultimate Kubrick movie. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | There is so much more to 2001 than it seems. |
MO
03.19.11 | Totally, not many people get the symbolism at all to 2001. I think people are just getting smaller and smaller attention spans and any movie that has a slow pace is considered bad or boring. |
Slum
03.19.11 | Yep that's it, you got me |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Busted. |
ConsiderPhlebas
03.19.11 | Disagree strongly with 5 but the rest hell yeah |
aok
03.19.11 | david lynch > stanley kubrick. What? Yea, I just did ... (also clockwork orange is one of my fav movies of all time) |
thebhoy
03.19.11 | 5 for me would be Barry Lyndon for me. 2 Would be 2001 and 1 would be Dr. Strangelove.
Barry Lyndon's cinematography is spectacular but the best part of that film is the lighting (and yes I am making a rather unnecessary differentiation). |
aok
03.19.11 | and btw, i don't actually believe that, but david lynch is really freakin awesome |
HeavyB
03.19.11 | Clockwork Orange blows nut. Shining, Dr. Strangelove, and 2001 are the shit though. |
Kubrick
03.19.11 | "and btw, i don't actually believe that, but david lynch is really freakin awesome"
Hahaha ok I was gonna say... David Lynch is awesome though I agree.
"Totally, not many people get the symbolism at all to 2001. I think people are just getting smaller and smaller attention spans and any movie that has a slow pace is considered bad or boring."
Yeah there is symbolism in essentially every single scene of the movie. To me it's just incredible how accurately he was able to predict the development of technology and man's relationship to it considering the time period that he made the movie. Obviously I don't mean accuracy in a literal sense where man has moved into space. But just the foresight of how machines and technology would ultimately control us and become more than just tools at our disposal (like the bone was to the ape at the beginning of the film).
One of the best scenes ever is when the film first switches to the ship on it's way to Jupiter. There's that really sombre cello suite that plays and you just watch scenes of the "pilots" walking around the ship. The music and the visuals capture the feeling of isolation so well. Also, the scene where his parents sing happy birthday to him through the monitor as he sits expressionless and you slowly realize that he can't respond to them because it is prerecorded. That whole sequence is so powerful in such a subtle way. |
MUNGOLOID
03.19.11 | "He never even filmed the actual ending."
that was because the ending was censored out in when it was published in America. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Yeah, another part was added years later. Besides, since when do you have to make a film adaptation of a book exact from cover to cover. |
ConsiderPhlebas
03.19.11 | Kubrick took the book out of context to make a controversial Hollywood flick.
You fucking moron. The book and film were written in collaboration and the film came out first. Half the ideas for the film and book were Kubrick's. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | The film came out 9 years after... |
drasticaction74
03.19.11 | all incredible movies. kubrick is a legend |
ConsiderPhlebas
03.19.11 | I've got the audiobook of 2001, with an intro by the author reading from his diary, saying that Kubrick initiated the project and because of some technicality, managed to get the film out first. Not even gonna bother looking at the dates, I'm just gonna take his word for it. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Oh, I thought he was talking about ACO. |
Kubrick
03.19.11 | "Yeah, another part was added years later. Besides, since when do you have to make a film adaptation of a book exact from cover to cover."
^This. Perfect example: The Shining. Has anyone read the book? It is completely different from the film. Dick Halloran actually ends up saving Danny and Wendy in the book and the hotel actually explodes due to an overheating boiler, which is what kills Jack. There isn't even a hedge maze in the book. Stephen King has come out and said that he hates Kubrick's movie because he basically changed the plot entirely. The book focuses a lot more on the Overlook being haunted and that was what caused Jack to go crazy. The movie is much more about isolation and what that can do to someone. Kubrick adapted the story to make it into a good movie. The book itself doesn't translate very well to film.. which is actually proven because King responded to Kubrick's movie by overseeing a new film that follows the book exactly. Not surprisingly, the film is absolutely terrible.
I guess my point with all that is that books usually never translate directly film. I always treat them as two separate things even if a film is based on a book. Any changes that are made to a book that enhance the movie and make it a better translation for film is always welcomed for me. IMO Stan had a very good sense of how to adapt source material into a truly great film instead of getting bogged down in the details. |
drasticaction74
03.19.11 | ^ this |
Kubrick
03.19.11 | It's actually kind of hilarious how badly Stephen King books translate to film. There's gotta be upwards of 40 film adaptations of King books and they are all so bad. The only good ones that I have seen are Carrie, Misery (which is a fantastic book.. couldn't put it down), and The Shining, and best of those three radically changed the story in the book. I'm pretty terrified as to how the Dark Tower series is going to translate. I was excited when J.J. Abrams was at the helm but now I'm extremely apprehensive. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | I haven't read The Shining, but I've read about the differences from the film, for which there are many. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | I want to see Misery. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Time to watch The Shining in lieu of going to a hockey game. |
Kubrick
03.19.11 | @andcas Yeah I agree actually. I used to read a lot of Stephen King when I was younger.. I read The Shining in 7th grade. He does have some great books. I really loved Misery and The Shining and I'm actually rereading some of the Dark Tower series right now (never finished it back when I started it a long time ago). But I definitely agree that he has a lot more mediocre books than good ones.
"I want to see Misery."
It's really good.. don't expect anything on the level of The Shining though. I would say the book Misery still better than the movie, although they are both very good. The Shining movie is way better than the book though (I might be a little biased but oh well). Either way they are both some of the Stephen King's best. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | "Favorite scene: The unmasking of Cruise's character at the "party" (if the piano didn't send chills down your spine you had your TV on mute)."
That piano is fucking creepy, and it's only like 3 or 4 notes. Damn.
Favorite part of The Shining is the 2 long single takes they do when Jack is walking towards Wendy as they back, right up to and including the "Wendy, give me the bat" part. It's just awesome when he's like "I said I'm not gonna hurt ya. I'm just gonna bash your brains. I'm gonna bash them right the fuck in", and then the Nicholson laugh.
Probably my favorite single line is when Wendy bugs him while he's writing, and at the end of the scene he says, "Why don't you start right now and get the fuck out of here". Lol. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | Both of those bands can drown in my mouth-gravy. |
Kubrick
03.19.11 | "That piano is fucking creepy, and it's only like 3 or 4 notes. Damn."
Lol yeah. I actually think it's only two alternating notes the whole time. The only difference is sometimes he raises or lowers the octave that he's playing them in. That whole scene is pretty terrifying.
And yeah that scene from The Shining where she is backing up the stairs and Jacks slowly follows is amazing. There are seriously way too many standout scenes in that movie.. it's so hard to choose the best one. The scene that you're talking about when Wendy bugs him while he's writing is so good too. Shelly Duvall plays that scene so perfectly. She tries to be so chipper and make pleasant conversation and you can literally see the hurt in her eyes when Jack shoots her down. The look on her face always gets me. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | I'm at the scene right now in which Jack first talks to Lloyd.
Shelley is from an area of town about 15 minutes from me. |
AngelofDeath
03.19.11 | Clockwork is probably my favorite. Great job on the write-ups. |
SloppyMilkshake
03.19.11 | 4 and 2, nah. Though to be fair, Full Metal Jacket is 1/2 amazing and 1/2 average. |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | I'm afraid....Dave. |
Slum
03.19.11 | Bash them right the FUCK in |
Josh D.
03.19.11 | "Are you out of yer fuckin' mind?"
Almost every line of his after they move in to the hotel is awesome. |
Kubrick
03.19.11 | "Clockwork is probably my favorite. Great job on the write-ups."
Thanks =) |
JohnnyBarrett
10.30.11 | Clockwork,Strangelove( Sellers does one of the best actings ive ever seen),2001,full metal, Barry Lyndon. I don't really like Eyes wide shut, probably cuz i dont like the actors on it. |
Piglet
10.30.11 | the first 30 minutes of 2001 is a bunch of monkeys banging sticks on stuff hahah |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | Yeah tbh I would swap Eyes Wide Shut for Barry Lyndon now that I've seen it a few more times. Still love Eyes Wide Shut.
"the first 30 minutes of 2001 is a bunch of monkeys banging sticks on stuff hahah"
You bet your ass it is. |
robertsona
10.30.11 | i just watched the shining and pretty much shit my pants it was so good
dude has a hell of an eye, man. the room 237 bathroom, the ballroom bathroom, the room jack types in, everything is perfect. i could watch a film of just the camera moving throughout the hotel for an hour or two probably |
foxblood
10.30.11 | yeah the shining is incredible |
someguest
10.30.11 | they should show every kid who wants to join the army Full Metal Jacket |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | :DDDD
Yeah, the cinematography in The Shining is masterful. Kubrick's style is so perfect for horror too.. it's all based on atmosphere and never resorts to cheap bullshit. Even his non-horror films have some truly terrifying scenes just because of the way they are shot and the music he uses. He's definitely my favorite visual director by far... you can always identify a movie as his just based on the way it is framed. |
robertsona
10.30.11 | it's like a series of awesome paintings that just burst with "possibility"
this is a hard concept for me to describe but, like, a lot of his shots have hallways and doors and passages that aren't explored and it's really exciting to me. it's like his movie is an "open universe" where you can imagine the film going down a bunch of different paths (in both the literal and figurative sense) yeah something |
Josh D.
10.30.11 | My top 3 are the same as yours, but they can interchange depending on my mood. I actually have an old German vinyl press of the ACO soundtrack and an old 2001 vinyl soundtrack, two of my favorite possessions. I can understand people not being able to get into his movies, but they really are that good. I'm glad you included Eyes Wide Shut, I think it's underrated. I think one of his best traits was creating tense moments just through the dialogue.
My favorite scenes:
1 - the whole "open the pod bay doors" section, followed by The Dawn of Man
2 - hard to say, but I love Jack talking to Grady in the bathroom. So intense. All of the scenes with him in the Gold Room are good. Followed by the long single shots of Jack backing up Wendy to the stairs.
3 - probably the same as yours
4 - never really got into it, but the first half of the movie is good :/
5 - the same as yours, for the same reason. |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | Yeah I get what you mean haha... he was so skilled at portraying a sense of scale. A lot of the time the sets he uses and the locations in his movies are as much characters as the actual people. The Shining is a perfect example of this.
Personally I think his most beautiful movie is Barry Lyndon... if you haven't seen that I highly recommend it because it seems like you really appreciate his visual style like I do. Seriously, every single frame of that movie looks like a painting in a museum and that's not an exaggeration. |
robertsona
10.30.11 | god, you know i will! man i'm actually still reeling from this movie, mostly because it was -exactly- what i was looking for at the time |
Josh D.
10.30.11 | Didn't realize this is an old list that I've already posted in. Oh well. |
InAbsentia
10.30.11 | Good list. One of my favorite directors. |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | "I think one of his best traits was creating tense moments just through the dialogue."
This is so true. Perfect example is the scene where Kidman tells Cruise about her fantasy with the naval officer. That scene is just one very long block of dialogue but it is one of the most intense scenes in the entire film. I actually read somewhere he took 2 weeks just filming that one scene. |
Josh D.
10.30.11 | That's why I like Jack talking to Grady so much. The surroundings help a little (the room being all
red, mimicking the blood pouring scene out of the elevators, sort of), but them staring at each other,
the slow speaking, the accusations (if you can call them that). It's perfect. |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | "god, you know i will!"
Do it. It's a totally different kind of movie though.. basically a period piece. The setting is just as much of a character as the hotel in The Shining though and all of his framing techniques are there... and amplified to be even more picturesque. I'm telling you I could watch the movie on mute without a problem haha. |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | " but them staring at each other, the slow speaking, the accusations (if you can call them that). It's perfect."
Definitely. |
foxblood
10.30.11 | it's funny that steven king didn't like kubrick's interpretation of the shining very much. and that critics hated the movie when it came out. like damn that movie is perfection |
WashboardSuds
10.30.11 | the Shining is probably my favorite thing ever |
Acanthus
10.30.11 | He's got some amazing films that's for sure, but I'll not be watching 4 again as it really was "meh" besides the quotes; good, just not anything I want to rewatch. |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | Yeah Steven King hates the movie haha. He is just pissed that Kubrick changed the story so drastically. You probably haven't read the book I'm assuming.. but yeah there are HUGE plot lines that are totally left out, the fates of some characters are completely changed, and the hotel doesn't explode (yes, the hotel in the book explodes). |
foxblood
10.30.11 | why are you assuming i didn't read the book haha, i did. the changes are drastic but really i prefer the movie's storyline. i especially prefer The Overlook living on and Hallorann dying rather than The Overlook being destroyed and Hallorann living. the endings are pretty much opposite considering king had the hotel explode and kubrick had the hotel freeze |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | Oh wow my bad haha.. idk the movie is just generally more well known than the book so a lot of times I just assume people haven't read it.
Yeah I prefer Kubrick's version of the story too, especially for a film. King's stories pretty much never translate to film well unaltered. Film is just a totally different medium and a story structure that works well in a book definitely doesn't always translate. King actually oversaw the production of another movie/miniseries for The Shining that follows the book exactly... it's over 4 hours long and pretty terrible. He basically proved that Kubrick's changes were superior for film. |
patroneyes
10.30.11 | My personal opinion:
2001/clockwork
fmj
the shining
dr strangelove |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | "Lynch > Kubrick"
No waayyyyy. Lynch is definitely an awesome director but.. yeah. Not even close to Kubrick for me haha. |
foxblood
10.30.11 | yeah i totally agree. i saw that miniseries a long time ago, it wasn't very good. it was pretty stupid looking in the miniseries watching jack wield the croquet mallet rather than the axe. |
Kubrick
10.30.11 | Haha omg yeah. The croquet mallet vs axe boils down the whole difference between book and film so perfectly. It just does not look as menacing... at all. |