iSkane
03.22.11 | Fun fact: I knew and had the PT discography before I found Sputnik. |
fr33convict
03.22.11 | I ranked these guys a little while ago. Your order is interesting to me. |
Scoot
03.22.11 | 3,5,1 = 1,2,3
interesting ranking |
dnor
03.22.11 | I agree 1 could be 1, but 3 is definitely 2 if 1 is 1. |
cb123
03.22.11 | deadwing has to be a bit higher to i think |
awal16
03.22.11 | 3,1,2 the rest
10 is definitely right though |
InFiction
03.22.11 | Interesting order. Although I dislike how everyone tends to neglect Deadwing a lot. I fucking love that album. |
iSkane
03.22.11 | Dunno, I just seem to like Lightbulb Sun more than most of the others. In Absentia just got boring after a few hundred listens whereas LS stayed awesome. |
AnotherBrick
03.22.11 | 3 is way too high.
voyage 34 and sky moves sideways are the best, and followed by fear |
tkxxx7
03.22.11 | all these "3 = 1 if 2 = 4" statements hurt my head |
awal16
03.22.11 | well if we're going to include voyage 34, then yeah, that's first |
iSkane
03.22.11 | I just ranked the LPs. But Voyage 34 is fantastic. |
AnotherBrick
03.22.11 | apparently my list is in sputnik oblivion but i made a list ranking everything Wilson has done. From PT to Blackfield, to Bass Communion, to Incredible Expanding Mindfuck, etc
now i'm pissed its gone |
G3N3R1C
03.22.11 | Ugh, fuck... i can't even rank them. It's too hard. PT is one of those bands who's albums are constantly shifting around in the ranks for me.
All i'll say is this: Stupid Dream is just as good as the albums that are constantly listed as "their best albums", The Incident is WAY better than it's given credit for, and their worst is probably The Sky Moves Sideways. (i haven't heard OTSOL though) |
Defeater
03.22.11 | "Fun fact: I knew and had the PT discography before I found Sputnik."
They've been pretty mainstream for awhile now. |
omnipanzer
03.22.11 | so, 6-10 you do not rec? Is that right? |
KILL
03.22.11 | 3 and 4 are best |
Edwin
03.22.11 | 9 could do with a little more love for sure. |
iSkane
03.22.11 | @omnipanzer I do rec them all. I just didn't have much to say about them |
Gyromania
03.22.11 | 9 is easily their best imo |
Defeater
03.22.11 | lol their best |
greg84
03.22.11 | I'm not a huge fan, but I can safely say Lightbulb Sun is my favorite. |
Jethro42
03.22.11 | 5, 3, 1, 7, 9, 2, 4, 6,
Never heard 8 nor 10 |
Gyromania
03.22.11 | Defeater: deal with it. |
RooseveltsGhost
03.22.11 | The Incident is way more awesome than most people, including you, give it credit for. Kneel and Disconnect, Blind House, Time Flies, Octane Twisted, Yellow Windows, (holy fuck yes) Circle of Manias, I Drive the Hearse. All of these songs are just on the first Incident disc, forget the superb second disc with Flicker. Listen to The Incident again and reflect on this list.
|
iSkane
03.22.11 | I think The Incident is amazing, but it just doesn't stand to their other stuff. I fucking love this band and honestly it was a close race with everything except 1. 1 was the obvious winner (and 10 was the obvious loser) |
Defeater
03.22.11 | "Defeater: deal with it"
oshitdamn |
ev0ken
03.22.11 | for me, voyage 34 is my favorite thing they ever done. i constantly listen to that album. |
MarvellousG
03.22.11 | Disagree a bit with this. FOABP, LBS and The Incident are tied at number 1 for me, but FOABP and LBS are probably what I'd have as my number 1 & 2 respectively. You underrate TSMS in my opinion, but fair enough other than that |
tiesthatbind
03.23.11 | 3, 1, 5, 4, 2, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 |
PayneTiger777
03.23.11 | Deadwing has always been my favorite for some reason. |
scissorlocked
03.23.11 | Signify is the fuckin best |
CrownOfMagnets
03.23.11 | cocaine's a hell of a drug |
scissorlocked
03.23.11 | incident sucked |
