TheNotrap: Comfortably Numb - Floyd Ranked

TheNotrap 09.18.11	The Dark Side of the Moon is in my opinion the best album ever recorded. What’s your favourite Floyd?
JamieTwort 09.18.11	My top 5: Animals WYWH Dark Side Meddle The Wall
TheNotrap 09.18.11	Not usual to see Meddle so high JT ;-) The Piper, Final Cut and Meddle are all pretty close in my book
AdamKPeter 09.18.11	WYWH, Dark Side, the rest
Irving 09.18.11	http://www.whypinkfloyd.com/index.php
Cipieron 09.18.11	WYWH, Dark Side, the rest [2]
Colliiiin 09.18.11	WYWH, Animals, The Wall, Meddle, Dark side.
someguest 09.18.11	Wish You Were Here Meddle Animals Dark Side
AngelofDeath 09.18.11	Meddle and Saucerful of Secrets are way too low.
AngelofDeath 09.18.11	WYWH, Animals, The Wall, Meddle, Dark side. [2]
tarkus 09.18.11	You criminally underrate Meddle
TheNotrap 09.18.11	@Angel. I love all their records. Let's say all their work bellow Final Cut are pretty close
Jethro42 09.18.11	waveuponwaveofdementedavengermarchcheerfullyoutofobscurityintothedreammmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
TheNotrap 09.18.11	@tarkus. No I don't...I don't underrate any of their work. I'm a huge Floyd fan
JamieTwort 09.18.11	"Not usual to see Meddle so high JT ;-)" Meddle actually gets quite a lot of love on Sputnik and I can certainly understand why, it's a superb album.
JamieTwort 09.18.11	Good to see 5 so high, that album is rather underrated IMO.
TheNotrap 09.18.11	Haaha I see that now. Yes its an amazing album, like most of their work
tarkus 09.18.11	Meddle is my favorite, I could understand someone putting it fourth or fifth on a list, but when I see it at 9 I tend to get mad
TheNotrap 09.18.11	"Good to see 5 so high, that album is rather underrated IMO." Agreed. The Division Bell is brilliant. Songs like What Do You Want from Me, Poles Apart, Marooned, Keep Talking and specially High Hopes are amazing. Extreme underrated.
someguest 09.18.11	"Meddle is my favorite, I could understand someone putting it fourth or fifth on a list, but when I see it at 9 I tend to get mad" word
TheNotrap 09.18.11	@tarkus No need to get mad. Like I said I absolute love Meddle (I already listen that album at least 50 times), I just love 1-8 a little more. We're talking about rock masterpieces here. All their work is great...it's all a matter of opinion.
Jethro42 09.18.11	3, 4, 1, 9, 2, 5, 11, not too sure about the rest given my lack of deep knowledge of it. Ummagumma is weird but pretty good.
tarkus 09.18.11	The studio disc of Ummagumma has some garbage on it The live disc is good
TheNotrap 09.18.11	"Ummagumma is weird but pretty good" Yes..it's weird trip...perfect record to hear in a good mood...
Jethro42 09.18.11	Set the control for the heart of the sunnnn Over the mountain watching the watcher
Nagrarok 09.18.11	Wish You Were Here Dark Side of the Moon The Wall Meddle Animals (must give this one more attention though) Odd ranking for 5-9 I must say.
Jethro42 09.18.11	You know what? DSOTM = WYWH = Animals I just decided it.
TheNotrap 09.18.11	And I'm wondering who could be writing this sooong.
Divine 09.18.11	A Saucerful Of Secrets>DSOTM Yea, I said it
AnotherBrick 09.18.11	glad you ranked their albums and not fucking songs, although i disagree with the rating
TheNotrap 09.18.11	DSOTM = WYWH = Animals All great. All 5/5 But Dark Side will always be my fav. Their most consistent album IMO. Also amazing sound engineering by Alan Parsons. BREATHE BREATHE IN THE AAAIIRRRR
Jethro42 09.18.11	the heart of the sunnnn the heart of the sunnnn the heart of the sunnnn the heart of the sunnnn
TheNotrap 09.18.11	A Saucerful Of Secrets>DSOTM Well it's your opinion and I respect that. I've got a friend who says Piper it's their best. The people above 50 arguably prefer the first 2. Specially their debut with Syd Barret
Jethro42 09.18.11	''The people above 50 arguably prefer the first 2. Specially their debut with Syd Barret'' phew....
Divine 09.18.11	Yea TheNotrap, I prefer the Syd Barret era of the Floyd. A Saucerful of Secrets and The Piper At the Gates of Dawn are the only Floyd albums I have ranked as 5's
Divine 09.18.11	And I'm 19 so yea
TheNotrap 09.18.11	LIME AND LIMPID GREENASECONDSCENE A FIGHT BETWEENTHEBLUE YOU ONCE KNEW Syd Barret was completely ahead of its time
Jethro42 09.18.11	Acid Barret
TheNotrap 09.18.11	Not usual a 19 old kid like Barret so much. I'm glad.
Jethro42 09.18.11	(R.I.P. Syd)
TheNotrap 09.18.11	"Acid Barret" Completely...He just take the journey too far...
TheNotrap 09.18.11	Waters always have an amazing admiration for Barret.
Divine 09.18.11	I really love you and I mean you the star above you, crystal blue Well, oh baby, my hairs all end about you... I wouldn't see you and I love to I fly above you, yes I do Well, oh baby, my hairs all end about you... Floating, bumping, noses dodge a tooth the fins a luminous fangs all 'round the clown is dark below the boulders hiding all the sunlight's good for us 'Cause we're the fishes and all we do the move about is all we do Well, oh baby, my hairs all end about you... Floating, bumping, noses dodge a tooth the fins a luminous fangs all 'round the clown is dark below the boulders hiding all the sunlight's good for us 'Cause we're the fishes and all we do the move about is all we do Well, oh baby, my hairs all end about you... I really love you and I mean you the star above you, crystal blue Well, oh baby, my hairs all end about you...
TheNotrap 09.18.11	I must recheck The Madcap Laughs asap.
TheNotrap 09.18.11	I wish I could put on caps here the brilliant The Great Gig in the Sky. Timeless magic moment
Obfuscation24 09.18.11	8 is their best album come at me
TheNotrap 09.18.11	Yep The Final Cut is a great album. I always believed Roger should released this record under his name...but yes it's a great record. Probably the most dense of their discography.
TheNotrap 09.18.11	The debut Roger Waters IMO
Obfuscation24 09.18.11	Thank you for agreeing, it definitely gets overlooked because of butthurt PF/Gilmour fanboys
TheNotrap 09.18.11	I love both. Love Roger for his genius songwriting and Gilmour for being the best guitar player I ever heard. Their musical combination made my favourite music.
Obfuscation24 09.18.11	yeah i love both just the two extreme sides of fans skew vies of the albums
TheNotrap 09.18.11	Agreed. Sometimes people just don't catch the big picture
andrikos 10.22.11	WYWH > Animals > DSOTM > The Wall > Meddle > The Division Bell is my Pink Floyd upper echelon... I enjoy the rest too of course...
TheNotrap 10.22.11	Excellent choices Glad to see you like The Division Bell. Amazing but sometimes underrated record.
andrikos 10.22.11	Indeed it is. This is the album I chose to turn my kids (10 & 11) into Pink Floyd fans. I told them to be patient with it and it worked! ;)
TheNotrap 10.22.11	@andrikos Good work dad ;) My oldest son don't care much about music but my youngest always smile when I listen to High Hopes.
GnFnRs87 11.30.11	Wish You Were Here The Dark Side Of The Moon Animals The Wall Meddle The Division Bell My top 6 but WYWH is possibly the greatest album ever made, sorry to disagree NoTrap but I prefer it to DSOTM ......... just
GnFnRs87 11.30.11	Wish You Were Here The Dark Side Of The Moon Animals The Wall Meddle The Division Bell My top 6 but WYWH is possibly the greatest album ever made, sorry to disagree NoTrap but I prefer it to DSOTM ......... just
GnFnRs87 11.30.11	Wish You Were Here The Dark Side Of The Moon Animals The Wall Meddle The Division Bell My top 6 but WYWH is possibly the greatest album ever made, sorry to disagree NoTrap but I prefer it to DSOTM ......... just
TheNotrap 11.30.11	To each his own dude ;-) WYWH is also an absolute classic. 5/5 in my book. Great to see The Division Bell on your top 5. Amazing album.
Aids 11.30.11	best band of all time. well, tied with GY!BE
Spec 11.30.11	Get two the fuck down.
Aids 11.30.11	holy shit no way is ummagumma last
TheNotrap 11.30.11	I love all their work dude... I needed to pick one and it was Ummagumma - 1/2 original album.
Aids 11.30.11	I love all their work except for The Final Cut, fuck that shit and idk, Ummagumma was one of the first records i found when I was sifting through my dad's vinyl when I was like 12. that shit blew my mind. objectively it's just ok (for Floyd standards) but fuck me, no way it's the worst thing they've done. Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving with a Pict kicks major ass, and is one of the greatest song names ever. haha don't mind me, I'm extremely opinionated when it comes to Pink Floyd
TheNotrap 11.30.11	Same here. Great to see you like Floyd that much. It's very hard to rank these guys., almost all their work is great. Some dudes prefer The Dark Side of the Moon, others Animals or Wish You Were Here... One thing I know, Pink Floyd is one of the greatest bands of the past century. Their music is just timeless.
TheNotrap 11.30.11	One of the few bands that won the timeless status
Aids 11.30.11	for me it goes: Wish You Were Here Animals Dark Side of the Moon The Wall ------------------------ (all 5/5) A Piper at the Gates of Dawn Meddle A Saucerful of Secrets Ummagumma Atom Heart Mother The Division Bell Obscured by Clouds Momentary Lapse of Reason Soundtrack to the film More The Final Cut (basically a Waters solo album) or something like that
Aids 11.30.11	I mean any band that can have the masterpiece that is DSOTM come in at #3 is timeless. fucking amazing band.
TheNotrap 11.30.11	Indeed, The Final Cut is basically Waters first solo album but I still love it. Great to see The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn so high. Great debut, Astronomy Domine is such a trip ride... You need to feed your love for The Division Bell. Amazing album IMO, 5/5 in my book.
InAbsentia 11.30.11	Animals is by far their best album.
KILL 11.30.11	the final cut higher than meddle bro
Spec 11.30.11	Basically just rank Wish You Were Here, Dark Side Of The Moon and Animals at number one.
TheNotrap 11.30.11	The Dark Side of the Moon, The Wall, Wish You Were Here, Animals and The Division Bell are all 5/5. My lowest Floyd rank is 4, so it's easy to see how much I love these guys.
TheNotrap 11.30.11	@KILL If I made this list today I will probably switch those two...But it's always difficult to rank these guys.
Jethro42 11.30.11	the final cut higher than meddle bro[2] nonetheless
Jethro42 11.30.11	oh =]
InAbsentia 11.30.11	"Basically just rank Wish You Were Here, Dark Side Of The Moon and Animals at number one." Nah Animals > DSotM and WYWH
KILL 11.30.11	nah
InAbsentia 11.30.11	Nah. Animals is #1
KILL 11.30.11	nah fuck off
luschlotz 11.30.11	WYWH,ANIMALS,DARK SIDE, THE WALL, MEDDLE----AL 5'd I Hate 5 and 6, especially 6. Nice too see another big FLoyd fan around (like if we were little)
TheNotrap 11.30.11	I'm gonna make a controversial comment but to fully understand Pink Floyd you need to fly....an hallucinogenic ride I mean.
SylentEcho 12.18.11	I know I'm in the minority when I say this, but I'd put Division Bell at number 2.
TheNotrap 12.18.11	Indeed but you're not alone dude. The Division Bell is an amazing album. What's your top 5 btw?
jefflebowski 12.18.11	I think you're underselling meddle here
Piglet 12.18.11	Dark Side is the most eloquent, complete records of all time. I would rank it up there in the Top 10 of all time.
KILL 12.18.11	agreed
TheNotrap 12.18.11	"Dark Side is the most eloquent, complete records of all time" Indeed Piglet. The greatest album ever made. @Jeff Like I say above, If I made this list today I will probably switch #8 and #9.
KILL 12.18.11	i think 6 is prob the worst floyd album
TheNotrap 12.18.11	I believe you know how much I love A Momentary Lapse of Reason Kill. I love all their work... Making this list was really a hard task for me. Floyd is my absolute favourite band.
jefflebowski 12.18.11	yeah, fair enough. Good ranking though, the top 3 are pretty much interchangeable 5's as far as I'm concerned
SylentEcho 12.18.11	[b]My top 5 are:[/b] Dark Side Of the Moon Division Bell Wish You Were Here The Wall Animals
TheNotrap 12.18.11	^ 5/5 top 5. Similar to mine (same records in a different order): 1. The Dark Side of the Moon 2. The Wall 3. Wish You Were Here 4. Animals 5. The Division Bell
xfearbefore 12.18.11	I'd have ranked Piper higher personally, but I love British psychedelia from the 60s. Glad to see the Division Bell get some love though, underrated album. I'd probably have Piper and Meddle slightly above it, but not by much. Everything else on the list I agree with.
TheNotrap 12.18.11	"I'd have ranked Piper higher personally, but I love British psychedelia from the 60s." Syd Barret's songwriting is mind-blowing. Astronomy Domine is one of the most iconoclastic British psychedelia songs ever released.
SylentEcho 12.18.11	Agreed, that song is madness.
Jethro42 12.18.11	Floating down the sound resounds Around the icy waters undergrounnnnd
TheNotrap 12.18.11	Lime and limpid green a second scene a fight between the blue you once kneeew
Jethro42 12.19.11	Best cover ever; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvVJCaQcTUY
TheNotrap 12.19.11	^ Indeed. Great cover.