macadoolahicky
03.30.12 | I might be the only one that thinks this, but I am surprised that they did not add Portal's drummer. I doubt they'd add him at number one, but you never know. |
MMX
03.30.12 | Some of these album's shouldn't be here at all |
someguest
03.30.12 | I love the album art for 8. I should probably listen to it. |
macadoolahicky
03.30.12 | Yea MMX I don't know why they picked some of them either. I am glad they picked 2 though. |
J0ckstrapsFTW
03.30.12 | 5,10,12,17,19 are great |
DotEight
03.30.12 | Wow some of this list is wack as fuck. |
oltnabrick
03.30.12 | 18, 17, 10, 5, 4, 3 are my favorites
I wish Abe from Deftones was on here instead of Sevendust (seriously Sevendust). |
evilford
03.30.12 | well, Danny Carey probably should be on here, but I don't know if he does anything outside of Tool lol
honestly I think Brann Dailor is probably the best skill-wise, but I'm not sure their latest album is his best work. Tomas Haake and Des Kensel would be up there for me. also, I like Joe Lester a lot but I wouldn't put him in front of any of those three. |
evilford
03.30.12 | and yeah Abe Cunningham should be on here too |
oltnabrick
03.30.12 | 24, 16, 15, 14, 13, 11, 8, 25 dont need to be there. Nothing new |
Shuyin
03.30.12 | should have Vitek (RIP) |
macadoolahicky
03.30.12 | From what I have heard, Danny Carey has been doing stuff outside of Tool. |
evilford
03.30.12 | yeah. if he hadn't he would easily been DQ'd by their rules, but last I knew he's still pretty damn good |
SpiritCrusher2
03.30.12 | off topic, but Meshuggah just put their new video on the internetz: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1J00l_BEts&feature=youtu.be |
SpiritCrusher2
03.30.12 | oh and 17 should be much higher |
AfterTheBreakdown
03.30.12 | good to see 15. |
fraderic
03.30.12 | what a shit list they made |
ultradevilgod
03.30.12 | missed Tim Yeung of Divine Heresy, Max Duhamel of Kataklysm, Flo Mounier of Cryptopsy, Dave Haley of Psycroptic and John Longstreth of Origin |
macadoolahicky
03.30.12 | MESHUGGAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! But I wish they did a video for a different song, maybe Marrow |
SpiritCrusher2
03.30.12 | ^ exactly |
KILL
03.30.12 | sean for life |
BlueW
03.30.12 | metal sucks |
KILL
03.30.12 | gd website yea |
SpiritCrusher2
03.30.12 | KILL if you mean Sean Reinert then I have to agree with you, he is probably my favourite drummer ever |
bloc
03.30.12 | Great site, I've been reading up on this list as well. Curious to see who is next. Neil Peart? Does he count? |
MO
03.30.12 | some good but they left out quite a few from not so famous bands, like Ulcerate, etc |
HitlerIsGod
03.30.12 | jaimie saint merat had better be on that fucking list |
UnnamedOcean
03.30.12 | Brann Dailor I suppose. I don't really listen to him much, but I do like that his style is unique and not just all double bass and shit like that. |
coneren
03.30.12 | umm |
MO
03.30.12 | brann dailor is overrated as fuck |
HitlerIsGod
03.30.12 | brann dailor's playing is masturbatory but i like it |
UnnamedOcean
03.30.12 | Dailor isn't mind blowing, but he is very tasteful. Most metal drummers these days aren't. |
evilford
03.30.12 | how is Brann Dailor overrated? |
iswimfast
03.31.12 | 7 can't be because 10000 days was more then 5 years ago. Which sucks because Danny Carey should on there. |
ChuckyTruant
03.31.12 | you should put the names of the drummers |
macadoolahicky
04.01.12 | iswimfast, he's done work outside of tool. |
SpiritCrusher2
04.02.12 | lol at #1. I really hope it's a joke http://www.metalsucks.net/2012/03/30/1-scott-hull-agoraphobic-nosebleed/#more-88448 |
Evreaia
04.02.12 | Well there first #1 on the guitarists list was a joke so I wouldn't be surprised by this one. |
ChuckyTruant
04.02.12 | yeah. kirk hammet is crap |
SpiritCrusher2
04.02.12 | well at least he plays his instrument lol |
KILL
04.02.12 | hes hardly crap |
ChuckyTruant
04.02.12 | ^ yeee |
evilford
04.02.12 | Kirk Hammet crap? you're crazy |
Imperial
04.02.12 | HAhaha #1 is fucking hilarious. |
MO
04.02.12 | lol seriously what a fucking joke |
Imperial
04.02.12 | It would have been the greatest April Fool's joke. |
Imperial
04.02.12 | Except it was posted March 30th which is not April 1st which means it's set in stone. |
MO
04.02.12 | they wanted to beat the deadline |
Katechon
04.02.12 | "Jarvis also claims that Hull has a violent, alcoholic pet octopus in his control room that programs all of Scott’s drums for him"
Yeah, sounds like a joke. Y'all are dumb for falling for this. |
evilford
04.02.12 | is that the actual list up there? |
Katechon
04.02.12 | Yah, except the #1 on Metalsucks is Scott Hull. |
MO
04.02.12 | we'll see if they change it in the next couple days katechon |
Imperial
04.02.12 | It's a joke obviously. |
Katechon
04.02.12 | "we'll see if they change it in the next couple days katechon" Obviously they will. |
macadoolahicky
04.02.12 | They'll probably post the legit one later today. It will still probably be a disappointment. |
macadoolahicky
04.02.12 | They're now doing the user poll to find the users' top choice. Go vote if you desire to! I voted for Ignis Fatuus of Portal and Mario Duplantier of Gojira |