rockandmetaljunkie
11.18.14 | 1) The most influential
2) The best overall album |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.18.14 | make your picks guys |
NeroCorleone80
11.18.14 | Paranoid for both. None of these are the band's bests though imo. |
betray
11.18.14 | i'd say 1 is probably both most influential and best overall album |
demigod!
11.18.14 | Paranoid
Sad Wings
Powerslave
|
manosg
11.18.14 | Out of these, I think 2 is the most influential and 3 the best but I'm curious to see how many people will choose 1. |
JamieTwort
11.18.14 | None of these are my favourite by their respective bands but if I had to rank them based on personal preference I would have to say:
LZ II
Paranoid
Machine Head |
JamieTwort
11.18.14 | Paranoid has to be the most influential. |
FruityCatOfDoom
11.18.14 | Dad rock m/ |
RVAHC13
11.18.14 | 1 is the best overall album by the best overall band |
ArsMoriendi
11.18.14 | LZ II is better than Paranoid, and Led Zeppelin is better than Black Sabbath, but Sabbath is still more influential. Love them both.
Don't know much about DP, but the 5 songs I know by them never really caught my attention. |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.18.14 | my pick would be 2 for both occasions |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.18.14 | "Dad rock m/"
m/ |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.18.14 | "5 songs I know by them"
which ones ? |
thacoconut94
11.18.14 | Paranoid is by far both |
pedro70512
11.18.14 | "I think 2 is the most influential and 3 the best" [2]
Deep Purple are criminally underappreciated. I use that instead of underrated because those who have heard Made In Japan get it. |
TalonsOfFire
11.18.14 | 2 reigns supreme on a fronts but the others are still at least 4.5s |
adr
11.18.14 | 2 > 3 > 1
Who's Next and Maiden tho |
TalonsOfFire
11.18.14 | Priest?? |
Cygnatti
11.18.14 | Worst list ever. |
mandan
11.18.14 | As far as the Trinity is concerned, it'd go like this for me:
MiJ
MoR
PG
Outside of that, tough choice. |
mandan
11.18.14 | Oh, and regarding your question, I'd say Paranoid is best of the 3. Hard to say which is most influential though. |
demigod!
11.18.14 | "Worst list ever."
learn 2 rock cunt |
ArsMoriendi
11.18.14 | "which ones ?"
Child in Time, Highway Star, Smoke on the Water, Space Truckin', and Woman from Tokyo. Space Truckin' is pretty sick actually... but I never felt a compulsion to really dive into DP. |
demigod!
11.18.14 | also i never got why people considered zepp a metal band, but out of these i'd rank em:
Paranoid
Machine Head
LZ II
|
ArsMoriendi
11.18.14 | "why people considered zepp a metal band"
For the same reason why people consider The Velvet Underground and The Stooges, punk. They heavily influenced the genre. |
trve
11.18.14 | dad-rockers are pretty narrow-minded.
>dad listens to sabbath, priest, iron maiden
>dad hates mastodon because they "suck at playing guitar"
pls dad. |
pedro70512
11.18.14 | dad hates mastodon because they sound like "the devil screaming in a cave." |
trve
11.18.14 | lol he said something like that to the new gorguts album |
Ryus
11.18.14 | mastodon sucks but gorguts do not |
pedro70512
11.18.14 | I agree with the second half of that |
tempest--
11.18.14 | my dad loves mastodon |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.18.14 | I also love Mastodon XD |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.18.14 | "but I never felt a compulsion to really dive into DP"
You shouldn't let 4 or 5 songs to determine that for you, I understand your reluctance, but if I were you
and I wanted to decide whether a band is really worthy of my money, I would first listen their best 2 albums
in their entirety and then, decide. So, I would suggest you to pick 2 albums and fully check them before you
make up your mind. |
zakalwe
11.18.14 | If we had Slayer as well the whole planet could go suck a fuck |
Snowdog808
11.20.14 | Paranoid is my favorite out of these three, but I also have In Rock and Houses of the Holy as 5s. |
MrSirLordGentleman
11.20.14 | "Don't know much about DP, but the 5 songs I know by them never really caught my attention." "Child in Time"
OMG |
pedro70512
11.20.14 | ^ right? |
DikkoZinner
11.20.14 | 2 1 3 |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.20.14 | You really can't judge one band with only 5 songs.
And yeah
"Don't know much about DP, but the 5 songs I know by them never really caught my attention." "Child in Time"
That's kinda sad... |
ArsMoriendi
11.20.14 | I know I can't judge them on 5 songs. I'd still try an album by Deep Purple, there's just so many other artists that peak my interest more. In other words, they're perpetually on the back burner.
|
pedro70512
11.20.14 | Yeah, just like the R&RHOF voting >.>
(pique*) |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.20.14 | I can understand that, I'm only saying you should try to listen to 1-2 Deep Purple albums in their entirety before commit your self to the other more "attractive" artists. |
pedro70512
11.20.14 | Don't make it like homework for him, man. He'll get it when he gets it. |