These guys need to break up. They're so much better apart than they are as a unit.

Except RHCP are actually really solid. Stadium Arcadium was an excellent release.

Digging: Emery - ...In Shallow Seas We Sail

agreed

Digging: Genesis - Seconds Out

Stadium could have been better.

Digging: Dave Matthews Band - Crash

Stadium Arcadium was shockingly bad. Unless you like bad teen pop, shitty attempts at recapturing
their old funk rock sound and crappy ballads

I already knew this, I am friends with Anthony Kiedis.

Digging: Converge - Axe To Fall

^really? or am I just really gullible?

Digging: Maths - Descent

just gullible

Yeah, I'm 17, I live halfway across the country, and I'm friends with him.

and they DO need to break up
not because they're horrible, but because Frusciante is amazing solo

Stadium could have been good if It was one cd.

Digging: Do Make Say Think - Other Truths

My point exactly. Away from the band, Frusciante releases cool solo albums. Flea has done interesting stuff with the Mars Volta, played with Thom Yorke etc. Then, as RHCP, they just release bland radio rock

I like their stuff up until One Hot Minute, I'm yet to hear anything past Blood, but I'm curious.

wow

Album Rating: 5

this is a good thing IMO. Stadium Arcadium would have been epic if it was only one disc long.

Digging: Opeth - Ghost Reveries

um, i like pianos.

Digging: Lil Wayne - Da Drought 3

they are all great musicians with the ability to make a complex intricate meaningful rock record, yet as a unit they churn out mediocre pop rock crap, why?

Digging: Southgang - Tainted Angel

I don't understand how Stadium Arcadium is "teen girl rock" aside from Dani California and Snow having significant air-time.

One Hot Minute is really underrated.

One Hot Minute is amazing-I can't see any chilis release being less than a 3

Digging: Grayceon - This Grand Show

one hot minute is tight yo. anthony kiedis needs to stop trying to sing so well and just get back down with his old energetic self.

Digging: Animal Collective - Fall Be Kind

Keep rollin with the nonsensical metaphysical lyrics as well

I am real interested in hearing OHM, Navarro and RHCP seems cool.

Album Rating: 1.5

RHCP are terrible.

Digging: Sarah Blasko - As Day Follows Night

its not.

Album Rating: 1

stadium arcadium would have been so much better as a single album

Digging: Devin Townsend Project - Addicted

RHCP were doomed once Chad got taken in by Hollywood. I must say i'm more impressed by his comedy work than his drumming ability

Digging: Every Time I Die - New Junk Aesthetic

RHCP were doomed once Chad got taken in by Hollywood. I must say i'm more impressed by his comedy work than his drumming ability

he can play a mean cowbell.

Digging: Edge Of Sanity - Crimson

People still listen to this piece of shit band?

Digging: Ulcerate - Of Fracture and Failure

boring band is boing

Digging: A Forest of Stars - The Corpse of Rebirth

I found the biography Scar Tissue to be really fascinating. But these guys are not exactly a band I enjoy listening to.

Digging: This Is Your Captain Speaking - Storyboard

the only thing i actually enjoy by them is the intro to that snow song. guitar is killa.

I really dig their first few albums and then they went stale with Californication.

Album Rating: 1

band is nostalgia

Digging: The Flaming Lips - Embryonic

Exactly.

they throw down musically, and live harder then most musicians half their age, they need to go back to the punk funk sound of their 80's releases

awesome. Pretty excited.

Digging: Porcupine Tree - Stupid Dream

Fuck yeah early Chili's is capital O for Orsum. Mellowship slinky rides my crotch along the likes. Totally fell over after Californication though.

yay! stadium was alright, i agree it should have been cut to one CD but the songs that were good were really good.
i'm really psyched :D

Digging: Red Hot Chili Peppers - By The Way

excellent news. not surprised to see the usual rhcp hate. can't enjoy any bands that are popular..

Digging: The Strange Boys - And Girls Club

rhcp hate is ridiculously unfounded, stadium was solid, one hot minute is lame

Digging: The Red Chord - Fed Through the Teeth Machine

i agree. stadium arcadium wasn't great, but it had a lot of really enjoyable tunes. you have to really put an effort into disliking the chili peppers

Digging: Rise Against - Revolutions Per Minute

you have to really put an effort into disliking the chili peppers.

so true

Digging: Maps and Atlases - Tree, Swallows, Houses

"Smith didn't rule out the band going in an electronic direction " I have a bad feeling about this

Could be interesting.

Digging: Olivier Messiaen - Quatuor pour la fin du temps, I/22

I just can't picture these guys experimenting and the result being good, take We Believe for example

Album Rating: 5

bssm rules no1 can deny

Digging: Metal Church - Metal Church

I found the biography Scar Tissue to be really fascinating. But these guys are not exactly a band I enjoy listening to.

I'l give it a try as I still listen to BSSM and OHM on occasions and they are quality. Havent realy liked anything after 2000 tbh. This will probably be very average with the odd good track. Please no pop this time though.

Slight error in the news. Stadium Arcadium was released in 2006 not 2007.

Digging: Ganon - As Above, So Below

I thought Stadium Arcadium had its fair share of good tracks (the second half of the first disc and good amount of the second), it's just the lyrics that felt uninspired to me in a lot of songs. Wet Sand is still one of my favorites of theirs. I wouldn't mind them experimenting with piano and the like, cause I thought By The Way had some great songs that were out of their usual style.

Digging: Silversun Pickups - Swoon

I too don't understand the Chili's hate on this site, although I could see how people might not enjoy their later releases... (I personally think most of it is pretty badass.)
People just need to chill out, save the hating for the real shit. Like 99% of all commercial "indie."

The problem is they peaked in 1991, but stoners and impressionable teens still hail them as music gods or something, hence the backlash from a community of people who care a lot about music. Stadium Arcadium was bland as hell too, even a single disc wouldn't have been that good.

Digging: Bruce Springsteen - The Rising

californication was their peak

Digging: Modest Mouse - The Moon & Antarctica

BSSM is their best album by a wide margin.

i think it's very close between the two. a lot of the songs on bssm i just don't like

Agreed with BSSM.
I won't (and frankly couldn't) argue that they're the greatest band to walk the earth, becuase they're not (although that's subjective).
I still really enjoy their stuff though.

No. RHCP shouldn't break up unless they start getting sour which they haven't after all these years. Stadium Arcadium was a phenomenal release as an alternative rock album and a great double disc. They're my favorite "old" band because of their genre changes.
Listening to a song off of Freaky Styley and then listening to a song like "Snow" makes me appreciate their journey outrageously.

And Frusciante can still do solo stuff, he's a man of many products.

Go to hell all haters, non-believers, et cetera

Digging: DJ Krush - Jaku

The problem is they peaked in 1991, but stoners and impressionable teens still hail them as music gods or something, hence the backlash from a community of people who care a lot about music

Reading this comment made my day.

Digging: Jesu - Silver

Stadium Arcadium was terrible. Jesus christ they've turned into old pussies

if RHCP goes electronic, then i will lose all faith in humanity

Stadium was good but no BSSM. This new one will be good as well but no BSSM. Have to respect these guys they keep coming out with good music. Might not seem groundbreaking because you hear them all the time and for so long but name a band that sounds like RHCP they are so unique.

There's nothing good about the riff/melody to Fortune Faded. It's literally the worst thing I've ever heard. I'd rather listen to The Feeling, and that's me stepping way outside of my comfort zone.

one who can hate on rhcp has travelled many a dark path - ancient chinese prverb

Californication > BSSM

Digging: Pixies - Surfer Rosa

^Yes

^absolutely not..

much more diverse than BSSM. Although they both rule.

Stadium Arcadium was terrible. Jesus christ they've turned into old pussies

is converge still going to be as hard when they're as old as these guys?

Digging: The American Dollar - A Memory Stream

i hope not...a good band can age like fine wine or cheeses, even to where the slow evolution provides no "best" stage, but several equally desirable stages to choose from depending on taste. By The Way will always be my favorite.

Plus they're one of the few "old" bands that aren't completely full of themselves or turned into snobs.

is converge still going to be as hard when they're as old as these guys?

Maybe. Maybe not.

Meh, this better be better than staduim. That was WAAY TOO LOONG ANNND BOORRIINNGG. AN electronic aspect might be interesting. Electro-funk rock anyone?
Also
RHCP have aged well. If they tried to be their young selves, it would be sad. It's like they haven't matured at all. I prefer their funk-hop to their radio drivel, but at least they've kept on maturing instead of releasing the same thing year after year. And yeah, they are MUCH better seperated right now. Flea is awesome with yorke and fruisciante is the shiz solo. SMith has his own jam band, the only one who NEEDS RHCP anymore is Kiedis. pooor kiedis.

Digging: Blur - Parklife

Benzum you are such a dick, why must you try so damn hard to impress us with your elite alternative music opinions?

Yes these dudes are mainstream but damn they put out solid albums. Stadium arcadium was awesome and way better than by the way.

Digging: Them Crooked Vultures - Them Crooked Vultures

ohh Sputnik, you never cease to polarize my emotions with humour and bewilderment. Don't understand a lot of this thread, apparently there's just a lot of in-closet Chili fans on here afraid of marring an elitist opinion

Digging: Nightrage - Wearing a Martyrs Crown

i wouldn't mind some electronic chilis i mean hey it'd be something different right

electronic and funk have always gone well together, just listen to herbie hancock's headhunters.

Frusciante and Flea are awesome.
But the other two guys suck.

Digging: Dinosaur Jr. - Bug

why must you try so damn hard to impress us with your elite alternative music opinions?

Just for the record, I never do this. Plus I don't consider myself to even have that much of an
elitist taste in music. Who says I'm trying to impress anyone? Take it easy man.

Maybe you should try watching some live stuff sometime, Mr. Coffee.

RHCP really aren't that good, Frusciante is much better solo.

Digging: Stars Of The Lid - And Their Refinement Of The Decline

Everybody Hates Benzum, an uproarious new sitcom coming soon to sputnik

So are you. Go back to being gaslightanthem that was cooler

i predict this will sound the same
as everything else they've done

Digging: Those Who Lie Beneath - An Awakening

Youre thinking of Audioslave dipshit

I thought Stadium Arcadium was pretty great, but it definitely got old quicker than most RHCP releases. It should have been one disc, lotsa stuff on there should have been unreleased or just b-sides. I'm interested to hear new material, but not as interested as I was 3 or 4 years ago.

BSSM, Mother's Milk, The Uplift Mofo Party Plan and Californication are their best, but I haven't really heard a bad album by them (never heard the self-titled). One Hot Minute is pretty boring though, save for Warped and Walkabout.

Digging: Felt - Felt 3: A Tribute to Rosie Perez