Nirvana
MTV Unplugged in New York


5.0
classic

Review

by scyther USER (41 Reviews)
July 30th, 2009 | 6 replies


Release Date: 1994 | Tracklist

Review Summary: We'll float around, hang out on clouds. Then we'll come down & have a hangover.

Kurt Cobain wasn't the best but was the first of those whose lives did not make any ***ing sense to break out into the mainstream and scream meaningless hatred at a world that understood him as much as we understand the Universe. But the grotesque beauty of his existence is the enigmatic shroud that prevents us from knowing just exactly what happened at his Lake Washington residence on April 5th, 1994 give or take a day. In death he is far more legendary than he could have been during life, but far less effective. His music reflected his laziness, his fiery excitement, sadness, and disgust - and such a person would be categorized as a suicide risk by anyone who didn't understand the millions of kids rocking out to Nirvana in a sweaty, sad excuse for a venue. These rigid John & Jane's created the psychological mess that is Kurt Cobain and his endless flock of supporters and obsessors. John and Jane are the bane of the sane the way their all the same. John & Jane say stay home, study, and Jimmy and Jenny say *** you, why should we? Well to get a proper education of course! To lead a meaningful life! What are you, a ***ing Anarchist? Why yes, we are. And so Jimmy & Jenny start running around, brandishing a flag, a metaphor they simply don't understand, and go ahead and got themselves killed by dirty stolen needles and a good friend named Hard Drugs. A meaningful life, what is that? Is it what John & Jane say it is? Is it a career? How come John & Jane have been following this generic formula for years and years and never strayed off course until they finally gave birth to Jimmy & Jenny? What the fuck happened? Kurt Cobain is the answer to that question, in the entire sad Seattle bum that he is. Kurt is a man who found comfort in nothing and an enemy in something. How could he concentrate on schoolwork and chores and responsibility if living under a bridge just wasn't so bad? Why the fuck should he? Imposition kills. What is duty but the opinion of someone else? What is work but embodying that opinion? What is study but absorbing that opinion? Opinions, mm-mmm, opinions! sang Kurt at his existential peak. Now you can hate me for hating society, but that society is your society and mine is my own and not yours to fiddle with, you self-righteous football-playing bastard. If we follow the footsteps of people we hate then where the hell are we going?

Kurt's final farewell was a little album entitled "MTV Unplugged In New York", the Nirvana version. Here it sounded like Kurt had at long last accepted his purpose on this planet and understood what he had to do so the children he'll leave in his wake will not awaken tired, confused and hating everybody every morning. The soothing rhythms of his poorly tuned acoustic guitar vibrated through my brain a long, long time ago and still do, reminding me of what happens when a chaotic individual reaches nirvana. I'm not a Buddhist but Christ, did this album totally spiral my view of Nirvana in a completely different direction. I was face to face with the man who took on the world and won, but he couldn't defend himself against buckshot. I wonder if that bumbling electrician who found the body thought about how so many people had lost their Jesus Christ when he saw him laying there, blood trickling from his head. I wonder if he'd seen this MTV special and noticed that the guy really didn't seem like a "suicide risk". How about a more thorough investigation? People who were like Kurt listened to Kurt and those people keep to themselves, an unsacred vessel of human anxiety. If there is a hell these people would go there because they have done nothing with their lives, and stand on the sidelines as big things happen much to the dismay of Martin Luther King Jr. When their leader was crushed by society's inevitable greed, they must have been crushed along with him because the raw power of Nirvana has yet to be duplicated. With MTV Unplugged In New York, the band let the world gasp a relieving breath for this "suicide risk", whatever the *** that means, is okay, he's okay and he's going to be healthy and fine. He's probably giving to charity now or something like that. Why would a philanthropist kill himself? What sense does this make?

What do we have left of Kurt's incoherent lyricism and his abrasive personality? A headless corpse dead before it was supposed to be. That's just ***ing wonderful. I can't write anymore, I'm sorry, I have to hop back on the train to American Dreamland. By the way, the last track on this CD is pretty ***ing great.

Things have never felt so swell.........



Recent reviews by this author
Zion I True & Livin'pg.99 Document #8
The Number Twelve Looks Like You Put On Your Rosy Red GlassesSleep Volume One
Radiohead AmnesiacTwo Gallants Two Gallants
user ratings (2149)
4.4
superb
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
Abaddon2005
July 30th 2009


684 Comments


a record review is supposed to have the actual record as its subject. a decent write up but come on, after 23 reviews this is quite awful for a review.

scyther
July 30th 2009


1606 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Well this is what this record means to me and if you don't like it you can go play football.

darthbarf
July 30th 2009


445 Comments


Dude it sounds like you were completely baked when you wrote this review.

That being said, I did read all of it, which I usually don't do cuz most reviews are boring. So despite having little description of the music your review did keep me interested.

scyther
July 30th 2009


1606 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I figured the six other reviews for this described the music well enough. And for the record I was dead sober when writing this.

Cesar
July 30th 2009


2732 Comments


I enjoyed reading this. I don't qualify it as a review, but other than that it is quite good.

Pos

Romulus
September 17th 2009


9109 Comments


Great review man, major (late) pos.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy