">
 

The Raconteurs
Broken Boy Soldiers


4.0
excellent

Review

by Auldy USER (12 Reviews)
May 13th, 2006 | 11 replies


Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist


When this album was first announced a few months ago, someone from NME.com said something along the lines of 'this is the greatest rock album since Nirvana's Nevermind'. Wow, massive statement, but coming from NME these days outlandish statements have no credibility. On any normal day Jack White is an amazing blues and rock musician, he has the guitar skills, the voice, and the crazy white boy attitude of Detroit. Throw in a similar music veteran Brendan Benson and add a little bit or rollicking country spice with two of the boys from The Greenhornes (Jack Lawrence and Patrick Keeler) and you get a true rock 'super group' of sorts, with the potential perhaps to live up to NME's claims.

*Special Note* The Raconteurs are called The Saboteurs in Australia

This album can almost be divided into two types of songs, and while both Jack White and Brendan Benson share vocals on this album, I prefer to split them into the more Rock tracks and the more slow country influenced tracks.


If you haven"t heard Steady As She Goes yet you probably have no ears. It"s been played a lot on all sorts or radio stations and music video shows and for good reason, it"s an awesome track. The thrashing guitars and Jacks vocal work are both as excellent as you would expect, but you can add in some nice key work, and most importantly, drums. People who don"t like the White Stripes base this opinion often on Megs drumming, but she"s got nothing to do with the album and you have Keeler who can do a fill, and do them well. Store Bought Bones is probably the most (if only) White Stripeish track on the album, and it has an awesome little solo and general vibe. Broken Boy Soldiers is another fairly damn right awesome track and is definately a highlight.

Of the slower songs, you can tell some are more influenced by The Greenhornes end of The Raconteurs. Intimate Secretary, Yellow Sun and Hands all stand out, but they don"t stand out by much as the whole disc is great. Swear word starting with F great.

I know this reviews a little lose and doesnt have a great deal of detail, but I almost feel as though this album doesn"t need it. You listen to it once, and all you want to do is play it again, and that is the key to a great album.

And does this album live up to the Nevermind claim? Well, I don"t think it is as "influential" Nevermind was, but it is definitely a better album music wise. This is going to be one of the great albums of 2006, and hopefully they go live in a big way.



Recent reviews by this author
You Am I Hi Fi WayYou Am I Sound As Ever
Abbe May Howl & MoanOasis Dig Out Your Soul
The White Stripes White Blood CellsThe Wrights Evie
user ratings (624)
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
Hep Kat (4)
...

Muisee (3)
...

TwistandShout (4)
Broken Boy Soldiers is surprisingly good, but the ending is lacking. Could be better, but what could...



Comments:Add a Comment 
Jacaranda
May 13th 2006


684 Comments


Review could be a bit longer I'm thinking.
I thought your rating for this album was retarded though. This album is no where near a classic. Its nothing special.
Ya, too little details and too much opinion.This Message Edited On 05.13.06

ImTheFloor
May 13th 2006


59 Comments


I am a fan of the Racontours.

BUT A 5? A classic? A 3, I'd say is more acceptable. The review had very little detail, and was not well-written.

ThaFleastyler
May 13th 2006


36 Comments


Yeah mate, gotta agree with Jac and Iluvatar - plus, the review lacks coherency, and frankly, it probably could have done with a spell/grammar check and a proof-read before posting.

As far as the Raconteurs are concerned, the album hasn't hit here in NZ yet, but I've heard the 2 songs on the website and have to say they don't sound like instant classics. Catchy, yes. But not instant classics in the vein of things like Nevermind. BUT (to their advantage) the drumming sounds better than the White Stripes and Jack White sounds good - which really just confirmed for me that Meg is the weakest link. Goodbye.

Senor_Whippy
May 13th 2006


367 Comments


I'm sure a few of you may know, I'm a very big White Stripes fan and I think Jack White is one of the greatest musicians in America today, but this record has really let me down. It's nothing more than bland, uninspired FM Rock. I was expecting something a little more harder and challenging but instead we're just left with this. Sure, it is pretty nice to finally hear Jack playing with a Drummer who exactly has talent but the album as a whole is as weak as dish water. Disappointing Mr. White, I'd recommended you don't give up your day job anytime soon.

CharmlessMan
May 13th 2006


169 Comments


That was more of an introduction to the band, and doesn't really count much as a review, sorry, but it needs some work. I think Jack white is over-rated so I wouldn't go near the Saboteurs, seems like an album full of self-indulgent wank to me. 'Steady As She Goes' is a shit song. This Message Edited On 05.13.06

masada
May 13th 2006


2733 Comments


[quote=Review]If you haven’t heard Steady As She Goes yet you probably have no ears. It’s been played a lot on all sorts or radio stations and music video shows and for good reason..[/quote] No, it hasn't really.

[quote=Review]I know this reviews a little lose and doesnt have a great deal of detail, but I almost feel as though this album doesn’t need it. You listen to it once, and all you want to do is play it again, and that is the key to a great album.[/quote]

1. What Iluvatar said.

2. Don't tell me what I want to play this album again. It probably sucks, anyway.

Auldy
May 15th 2006


350 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

yeah, i just cant be bothered writing a decent review anymore. my bad

AlienEater
May 20th 2006


716 Comments


Don't bother writing anything then.

Sepstrup
May 20th 2006


1567 Comments


Or write a blurb

Auldy
May 21st 2006


350 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

see i thought i did have it set on blurb...

willfellmarsy
April 7th 2008


3847 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I know this reviews a little lose


Na man it's a lot of lose...yeah i know the reviewer of this may not even visit this site anymore but i' looking for info bout this band and i see that oppurtunity to create a lol-tastic response and i jump on it.

I'm ashamed of myself but more of my fellow posters to not use this before me.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy