">
 

My Chemical Romance
Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge


4.5
superb

Review

by rebelindreamland USER (1 Reviews)
May 18th, 2006 | 44 replies


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


Many people often dismiss My Chemical Romance as a crappy, mainstream, emo band, and often comment on the band members' appearances. What they fail to understand, is that behind the hype, and behind the Gerard Way fangirls, this is truly a great album with many fantastic songs. (This is my first review, so if it kinda sucks, sorry.)

Helena, the album opener, is one of MCR's most well-known songs. That's for a good reason, because it's a great song. This song was written about Gerard Way's late grandmother. The lyrics are great, and the guitar is really well played as well. The intro is a little weird to me but it doesn't detract from the song as a whole. A great album opener and example of MCR.

Following Helena is Give 'em Hell, Kid. This song has nifty guitar work, especially at the beginning. The song, from what I can tell, is a bit more cheerful than the other ones (it seems like an "I miss you so much" kind of song but there are a few lines that make me think it's a breakup song or something). I hardly ever listened to this song when I first got the album but it's sort of grown on me.

To The End falls into both the weird ("Let's go down! This elevator only goes up to ten") and morbid ("And say goodnight to the heart you break
And all the cyanide you drank") categories of MCR songs. I like this song, the tune is very catchy and the lyrics are pretty interesting. This song, like Helena, is a good "first MCR song" for new fans.

The next song, You Know What They Do To Guys Like Us In Prison, is probably my favourite song on the album right above Thank You For The Venom. This song has insane guitar all the way through, and mixes humour ("I miss my mom!") with an underlying anti-homophobia message ("How we're just two men as God had made us ... Pain in my heart for your dying wish, I'll kiss your lips again"). Additional vocals from Bert McCracken from The Used help this song stand out as one of MCR's best.

I'm Not Okay (I Promise) is often cited as a generic emo song. Although the theme does seem rather emo, that doesn't mean the song sucks. The chorus is pretty repetitive (it's basically "I'm not okaaaaaaaaay" over and over) but the guitar (especially in the intro) and vocals are superb. This song was supposedly written based on Gerard Way's actual life experiences. Despite the flaws this is still a very nice song and it's one of the MCR songs that's better to listen to when you're in a bad mood.

The Ghost of You isn't a bad song, but it doesn't really fit in with the rest of the album. The song is slower than most, and I find the vocals aren't as good as other songs (I had the same complaint with Hang 'em High). This is one of the sadder songs on the album. I honestly don't listen to it that much... it's not that it's terrible, it just doesn't fit in with the album's mood that well.

The ending of The Ghost of You holds and speeds up into The Jetset Life Is Gonna Kill You. This song follows the mood (and vocal quality) of The Ghost of You but the instrumentals are better and fit in better with MCR's style. Again, it's a song that I don't listen to all that much, but it isn't BAD, it's just... averagey.

Interlude is probably one of my least favourite songs on the album. The instrumentals and vocals are both too quiet, and I find even when I turn the volume up it's hard to tell what he's saying. The instrumentals aren't much to write home about either. The title most likely comes from the fact that it's an "interlude" between the first and second halves of the album. This song isn't much but it does make a decent intro to Thank You For The Venom (similar in nature but not as well executed as the pairing of "The Hellion" and "Electric Eye" from the Judas Priest album "Screaming for Vengeance").

Blending right into the ending of Interlude, Thank You For The Venom begins. This is my other favourite song on this album, just under You Know What They Do To Guys Like Us In Prison. I love the drumming in this song and the lyrics are also very well done. This is a song I like to listen to when I'm a bit sad, but it's just as good to listen to when I'm in a good mood.

Hang 'em High "is a song about suicide. Don't do it." -Gerard Way
This song starts out with a whistle-like intro and then proceeds into the style known in MCR's "harder" songs. Again, this song has amazing instrumentals with the drumming, although Gerard seems like he's trying to be too loud at some points so I don't think the vocals are quite as top-notch as other songs like Helena. This however only detracts a little from the overall quality of the song.

It's Not A Fashion Statement, It's a ***ing Deathwish is yet another song that's good and everything, I just hardly ever listen to it because I don't find it exceptionally fantastic. The lyrics are good, the drumming is great, the vocals are alright, it's just... too average. It's a good MCR song, just nothing to write home about.

Cemetary Drive, like The Ghost of You, is a lot slower than most of MCR's songs. However, the vocals and lyrics are better than The Ghost of You's, so this makes it a better song in the end. The constant drumming beat throughout the beginning of the song and the bridges is pretty nifty, and it heats up for the chorus which is accompanied by guitar which is almost hard to hear under the drumming. Overall, this is definitely MCR's better "slower" song.

The album then ends with I Never Told You What I Do For A Living. From what I can understand it's basically a song about a murderer, who obviously never told you what he does for a living until now. This song fits the "Murder scene" mentioned in Give 'em Hell Kid. The instrumentals in this song are pretty good and the vocals are pretty good, about at the level of You Know What They Do To Guys Like Us In Prison. This is a good song and ends the album pretty well.

Overall, Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge is an excellent album buried under the hype, the fangirls, and the "emo" lyrics and themes. I would definitely recommend this album to anyone who likes heavier music and doesn't mind lyrics with occasional morbid/death-related themes.


user ratings (3197)
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
Acey
May 19th 2006


2578 Comments


rebelindreamland

if you call them "emo" lyrics, why do you say everything about them not being "emo". it kinda confused me.


Society Sellout
May 19th 2006


292 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Just a few tips:



1. Never, ever, ever, ever, splash a 'emo' label on any music because people everywhere will do one of two things: 1. Tear you apart because you obviously don't know what emo is(Which is most likely on this site.). 2. Automaticly relate the band you are reviewing along with almost every band they hate that employs "emo" qualities(screams, mascara, blah blah) and your whole point will be lost.



2.



(This is my first review, so if it kinda sucks, sorry.)




Don't do this. Just don't. When people read reviews they are looking for an opinion that maybe more informed than theirs. Anyone can ask his idiot friend who sits next to him in biology what they thought of an album and get a half assed review, when they read a review they are looking for something they didn't know or that might interest them. By making a statement like the above you are really saying "This review sucks, don't bother reading because I don't know what I'm doing". Even if you don't know what you are doing don't let your readers know that ;).



Anyways hope that helps some, as far as the content of the review goes you did pretty well. Only suggestion I would have for that would be maybe longer overall opinion with some substance to support your opinion as well.

pattern_recognition
May 19th 2006


950 Comments


^^^^^^^^^^
What they said.

204409
Emeritus
May 19th 2006


3998 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Also, another hint is don't come to the site and have your first review be something you're completely biased towards or one that has already been reviewed 6 times. Maybe test the water with an original album and soemthing you don't necessarily poop your pants over to test how to qualify an album.

The Sludge
May 19th 2006


2171 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Also, dont poop your pants your just better off using a toilet.

The Jungler
May 19th 2006


4826 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

(This is my first review, so if it kinda sucks, sorry.)


I couldn't give if it was your first or tenth, if your writing a review, make it good so you don't have to apologize.



Your review lacks some detail, but you seem fairly smart and some of your descriptions were good. Next time try to do an overall review of the album, instead of reviewing each track seperatly.



Also, I know everyone else has said it but, don't use the word emo, because you don't know what it means, which isn't really your fault, because the mainstream calls this emo.



I have said this in at least five reviews, I kind of like this band.



Read all your other comments, they all leave good advice.



pulseczar
May 19th 2006


2385 Comments


Wow, some of you guys are really harsh. Have you seen some of the other debut reviews around here?
You have a good writing style, and if you can write that way in an overall style or put more detail into track-by-track reviewing, you'd be a very good reviewer.

cool guy91
May 19th 2006


25 Comments


MCR sucks


diego182
May 19th 2006


25 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

MCR sucks

anguspage007
May 19th 2006


64 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This record had good moments and bad. But some of these guys had a point. Never feel like you have to apologize. We dont know how many you have done, and if you arent happy with what you do, then why would you post it? I liked your review, and although I am not a huge fan of the guys, they have good tunes, and I am willing to give them a chance. The emo label is one of may that will live on forever, so let it go. Whiney or not, people will or wont like it.

Two-Headed Boy
May 19th 2006


4527 Comments


originally posted by cool guy91:
MCR sucks
originally posted by diego182:
MCR sucks


This is really lame. At least give a reason as to why they suck.

Steerpike
May 19th 2006


1861 Comments


Don't try reasoning with cool guy91. He's the most inappropriately named person on the site, and after dropping his little turds of comments, he vanishes from that page completely.

Anyway, the review shows potential, but the bias really shines through. Tone it down next time.

As for the emo thing, here's the funny truth: MCR themselves dislike being labelled as emo. They unabashedly admit to being a pop band and that they have nothing to do with real emo. They are confused as to why their fans insist on attaching that label to them.This Message Edited On 05.19.06

diego182
May 19th 2006


25 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

lol not sure, i just dont like them, they try to be darks but they cant.

nag*with*a*gun
May 19th 2006


420 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

gerard has a great voice throught the whole album... I think the whole quality of them doesn't waver...



123 AV8Rs.

Jimmy
May 19th 2006


736 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

My Chemical Romance is as a crappy, mainstream, emo band, and they all look like self-absorbed douchebags

mike_heuer35
May 19th 2006


1 Comments


All I can say... I'm putting anything or anyone on a pedastal... people need to quit being fucking douchebags in general... if you don't like the music then just dont say anything there is a difference between constructive critisism and pure pig-headedness... music is an expression of something you feel... so you can't relate... that doesn't make the music bad... it just means you can't relate... if the music makes sense to even one person... then I think its worth while... I mean if you're music has ever saved a life... then you're probably doing something right... as to people shooting it down... MCR must be doing something right if they have made it this far and honestly they have balls for going on a shit music station like mtv... i mean typically we consider that like fan suicide but why should it be so disasterous to spread your message even if you do it over the airwaves of some of the crappiest tv known to the human race.... also if you don't like em... do a background check... they've lead some interesting lives... and if you don't like "three cheers for sweet revenge" i'd suggest checking out their first cd "you brought me your bullets i brought you my love" it has alot of raw emotion mixed in with theatrical story telling which music rarely sees... so some of its downer and not the happiest big deal... most of the time people listen to that because its such a common emotion... but if you are looking for an almost humorously upbeat yet ironically sad MCR song check out "Headfirst for Halos"

now don't trash this too bad... i mean ya some it probably sucks and you won't agree but you are entitled to your opinion... call me what you want... i'm just stating a fact that by denouncing someone for what they feel... what they believe... it's flat out cliche hypocracy... look in a mirror and analyze yourself bit... take it easy

-mike

The Jungler
May 19th 2006


4826 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Mike, is your period button broken or something?

Steerpike
May 19th 2006


1861 Comments


]they try to be darks but they cant.


What the fuck? What the hell is that supposed to mean? What the hell are "darks"?

My Chemical Romance is as a crappy, mainstream, emo band, and they all look like self-absorbed douchebags


Not emo, retard. If you don't know, don't bother opening your mouth.

-mike


My eyes are bleeding from that huge mass of a post.This Message Edited On 05.19.06

nag*with*a*gun
May 19th 2006


420 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

yeh. and: who cares what they look like?



that was a long first comment. I think mine was "green day rocks" or something to that extent.

Bron-Yr-Aur
May 19th 2006


4405 Comments


"lol not sure, I just dont like them. they try to be darks but they just cant."

Perhap the most justifiable and thought-provoking argument of the century. I concede to your vast amounts of knowledge, and appeal to your great sense of judgement. This Message Edited On 05.19.06



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy