">
 

John Frusciante
Shadows Collide with People


4.5
superb

Review

by The Ashtray Girl USER (17 Reviews)
January 14th, 2005 | 24 replies


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


John Frusciante - Shadows Collide With People


John Frusciante is the guitarist from Red Hot Chili Peppers, who was with them to make Mother's Milk, Blood Sugar Sex Magik, Californication and By The Way. He has released a number of solo albums, and Shadows Collide With People is his most commercially successful to date, his latest effort, Will To Death, having not been in the shops long enough at the time of writing to compete.

Whilst the track names may seem to indicate this album is very strange and not very accessible, in fact it is very easy to get into in my opinion. Admittedly he does use some rather weird-sounding instruments on many of the tracks, and there are a few strange instrumentals, but in fact many of the songs have very simple, memorable melodies. The lyrics are somewhat interesting, such as Regret, which simply consists of "I regret my past, stay alone" repeated many times. That sounds like it should be boring and repetitive, but in fact it's one of the highlights of the album.

Probably one of the most surprising aspects of the album for Chilis fans is that John's voice sounds nothing like it does on their records when he backs Anthony Kiedis. He actually has a much lower, rockier voice that is very enjoyable to listen to.

The album plays very well as whole, there wouldn't be any point for me to do a track-by-track analysis because it all flows and merges into one piece of music a lot of the time. He has got some variety in the record as well, with some nice upbeat songs like This Cold making a change from the more mid-tempo songs that make up most of the album. Other highlights include Every Person and Second Walk.

This album has a really nice groove to it, a proper underground gem that is part of a growing movement of fans who love Frusciante's solo work in itself. It's beautiful, often surprising, interesting, original and exceedingly pleasant to listen to. For anyone looking for some mellow and pleasant without being tacky nor boring, this may well be the album for them.

Track Highlights

Wednesday's Song
Every Person
This Cold
Second Walk
Carvel
Regret
Ricky



Recent reviews by this author
Tom Vek We Have SoundMercury Rev All Is Dream
Alanis Morissette Jagged Little PillBloc Party Silent Alarm
Red Hot Chili Peppers Blood Sugar Sex Magikt.A.T.u. 200 km/H In The Wrong Lane
user ratings (526)
4.1
excellent
other reviews of this album
Zaine (4.5)
...

EVedder27 (5)
Whether it’s the skepticism of Ricky or the sheer optimism of The Slaughter, “Shadows Collide Wi...



Comments:Add a Comment 
pixiesfanyo
July 7th 2004


1223 Comments


Awesome CD

roee_co
July 19th 2004


6 Comments


[CENTER][IMG]http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00018TI5E.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg[/IMG]

Shadows Collide With People[/CENTER]

Track List:
1. Carvel
2. Omission
3. Regret
4. Ricky
5. Second Walk
6. Every Person
7. -00Ghost27
8. Wednesday's Song
9. This Cold
10. Failure33 Object
11. Song To Sing When I'm Lonely
12. Time Goes Back
13. In Relief
14. Water
15. Cut-Out
16. Chances
17. 23 Go In To End
18. The Slaughter

Credits:
John Frusciante, Josh Klinghoffer, Chad Smith, Omar Rodrigues, Flea, Charlie Clouser

Review:
After John Frusciante's last solo album "To Record Only Water For Ten Days" and the last album with his band(Red Hot Chili Peppers) "By the Way", John Frusciante comes back big time and produces a great album that emphasizes his deep connection with music and his love for it, if its by a melody song or kick *** guitar solo.

Songs Review:
1. Carvel - the song begins with a weird slow intro and bursts into a medium/fast song. This is a great song to begin with and really shows John's singing skills.

2. Omission - a song written by John Fruscinate and his friend Josh Klinghoffer, which has a combination of both singing together different lyrics. the song then goes into a fast rocking part and ends the song with a awesome guitar solo by John himself. One of my favorites.

3. Regret - a melody song with only 2 lines of lyrics, "I regret my past, stay alone". when I first heard the song I was really suprised John regrets his past, but then i heard an interview saying the song isn't serious, and that he doesn't regret his past which was a relief.

4. Ricky - another melody song with deep lyrics which i believe is about his past and how he was afraid to be himself.

5. Second Walk - After a melody song, the album come back alive by a hard rocking drum intro and an amazing solo by John which shows his skills with the electric guitar. One of my favorites songs in the album.

6. Every Person - that is a problem in the album in my opnion, after a hard rocking song we get another melody which slows the album down.

7. -00Ghost27 - the first instrumental in the album which I honestly think they just took a broken cd played it in a cd player and recorded. it really sounds awful and doesn't relate to the album in my opnion.

8. Wednesday's Song - a medium tempo song that goes into a catchy chorus. I particulary like the bridge in the song.

9. This Cold - a fast song that starts with just guitar and drums and then at the second chorus you get awesome bass lines that goes throughout the song. Now I have no idea whether Flea plays the bass to this song or John, but the bass is really incredible in this song and adds a lot. One of my favorites songs in the album.

10. Failure 33 Object - the second instrumental of the album which is better than the first however doesn't have a good feeling with the album. the instrumental is guitar with loads of effect and with some computer effects as well, sounds like a techno song.

11. Song To Sing When I'm Lonely - a nice medium tempo song with another catchy chorus that has deep lyrics.

12. Time Goes Back - a medium tempo song which uses the bass in a good way, even if it doesn't have an amazing bass line it sure adds a great touch to the song. The song also shows John's singing skills to sing back up vocals and the vocals themselves.

13. In Relief - the song begins with an interesting intro but good, and goes into a melody song that doesn't boring you.

14. Water - the song starts with a weird intro as if the song was an instrumental but then goes into the funkiest song in the album with amazing bass lines and guitar lines that are put together in such a good way. the song has a catchy chorus with a high vocals by John. the song then goes into a rocking outro with an amazing guitar solo that ends the song. One of my favorites in the album.

15. Cut-Out - the song starts as a medium tempo song with a great bass based chrous that bursts into an a hard rock part with amazing drums skills done by either Chad Smith or Josh Klinghoffer.

16. Chances - a kinda boring song with a medium tempo speed that again I don't understand why it was put after a hard rock song.

17. 23 Go In To End - the last instrumental which in my opnion is beautiful and shows that John has skills with music even if its not played by guitar. a truely amazing music piece.

18. The Slaugther - the perfect song to end this album which has a catchy chrous and a great feel of music with deep lyrics that truely reflects John's skills.

Overall Rating:
3.5/5

manuscriptreplica
July 19th 2004


431 Comments


Which track is Omar Rodriguez on?

pixiesfanyo
July 19th 2004


1223 Comments


He's on a couple I think it's 13 and 17

roee_co
July 19th 2004


6 Comments


its actually 16 and 17

Kiedisfan69
July 20th 2004


42 Comments


I love the song Omission! IMO, it's the best song on the CD. Oh, and it's good to know that he doesn't really regret his past! RHCP will live in my heart forever.

roee_co
July 20th 2004


6 Comments


[QUOTE=Kiedisfan69]I love the song Omission! IMO, it's the best song on the CD. Oh, and it's good to know that he doesn't really regret his past! RHCP will live in my heart forever. [/QUOTE]

Yeah, I was scared first time I heard the song. And yeah Omission is great

Kiedisfan69
July 23rd 2004


42 Comments


This cd has already been reviewed.

their review > your review

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=209224&highlight=Frusciante

MildlyAmusingWankCushion
October 2nd 2004


17 Comments


I think you are a little harsh on the score for this album. its full of great songs and you put it down because you dont like the melodic songs so much....JF is all about that, so if you don't like the style of music don't bother to slag it off. However, if you do like melodic music JF is your man, IMHO the best and most underrated songwriter in music right now. His music is just simply beautiful and touches me like no other artists music ever has. definite 5/5 but as JF is in the middle of releasing an album a month things are only getting better...each album is better than the one before it with plans for another couple of heavy rocking albums similar to the velvet underground and then a purely acoustic album to follow. what a legend...

The Ashtray Girl
October 3rd 2004


108 Comments


I reviewed this first.... meh

MildlyAmusingWankCushion
October 3rd 2004


17 Comments


[QUOTE=theashtraygirl]I reviewed this first.... meh[/QUOTE]

Where is your review?

I wanna see some JF reviews!!

thecrazykid
October 3rd 2004


11 Comments


[QUOTE=MildlyAmusingWankCushion]Where is your review?

I wanna see some JF reviews!![/QUOTE]

:lol: You wanna see 2 reviews that are for the exact same CD? I like this review, I don't know about the other one because I've never seen it.

Anyway, I love John Frusciante and "Shadows Collide with People" is one of the best CDs that came out this year! (Green Day's "American Idiot" was pretty cool too.)

Also, I'd like to agree with you people that said that they're glad "Regret" wasn't true.

...A 3.5? dude, that score sucks!

MildlyAmusingWankCushion
October 3rd 2004


17 Comments


^^^

good man...not sure about the green day =/

i actually wanna see reviews for JF's other albums. If you didn't know, he released a few CD's recently, one being "The Will To Death" which IMHO is better that Shadows, and an EP - the Dc EP - which is possibly the most beautiful 15 minutes of music i have ever heard. I just want to make people see John Frusciante because lots of people say they have never heard any of his music, and i like to pass on music which i think is good for others to enjoy. This guy is excellent, so i would like to see what people think if they listen to his music, because its very good!

thecrazykid
October 3rd 2004


11 Comments


^ You should do some John Frusciante reviews!

MildlyAmusingWankCushion
October 3rd 2004


17 Comments


I might well have to seen as nobody else seems to want to. I'll try, but no guarantees because i dont think im very good at that sort of thing, and im very busy with schoolwork....but maybe.

thecrazykid
October 9th 2004


11 Comments


It's ok, it was just a suggestion.

caspian
January 23rd 2005


38 Comments


I havent heard tis yet, however< i've heard some of the song of his "To only record water for 10 days" or whatever its called, and its incredibly. I have to buy it.

Aeaon
August 2nd 2005


188 Comments


I should give his solo stuff a listen sometime. I think he's a really good guitar player.

Hugh Jass
September 1st 2005


92 Comments


I've been after this CD for ages but I'm fed up of it never being in the sale. mmmm pie.

rohan
October 11th 2005


2 Comments


You'd be suprised at the simplicity of his guitar work, it's all basically three chord but the other instrument layering is quite complex.. I'm thikning of doing a review of "to record only water for 10 days", but its quite a big album



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy