Nurse With Wound
To the Quiet Men From A Tiny Girl


3.5
great

Review

by chris. USER (51 Reviews)
March 1st, 2017 | 10 replies


Release Date: 1980 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Disjointed noise; Conjuring up new feeling I haven't felt in music before

'Hell is empty and all the devils are here'
- William Shakespeare

I'm gonna be honest, I came off this record extremely confused. I guess some of that is my part to blame. Coming from a background of pop punk, emo, and other forms of mainstream rock, this was my first forte into music of the Experimental/Noise variety. And what a journey it was. To the Quiet Men From A Tiny Girl showcases a soundscape and presents a feeling I’ve not yet experienced in music yet. Confused, disjointed, and on-edge.

To the Quiet Men From A Tiny Girl is around 50 minutes long, stretched across 3 tracks. Each are similar in presentation, but present a different soundscape. Lyrics are nowhere to be found besides randomly sampled voices and singing sprinkled throughout, but what it lacks in words more than makes up for it in pure noise. Almost nothing sounds conventional in this album; nothing sounds normal, which makes it such an anomaly to me.

The album opens with "Umbrella Link", the shortest track coming in at a minute and twenty seconds, serving as more of a prelude to the next track than standing on its own. The song starts with heavy feedback filling the silence until a short guitar riff cuts it off, immediately leading into the next track. "She Alone Hole and Open" is where the true sound of the album begins. The track starts off with saws, hammers, and power drills, all of which serve as percussion for the entire album. Randomly, synth noises pop through the percussion and leave as suddenly as they appeared. The song devolves into something I can only describe as hellish pig grunting and saxophone noises until the track comes to a close. Writing it out, it seems silly but the finished product actually works in some respect. It’s cohesive in spite of its dissonance. It just works together to create a mood and atmosphere I haven’t seen anywhere else.

"Ostranenie", the next and final track, begins by piercing your ears; a high pitch permeating throughout the soundscape. Wails come through in the distance in different tones, pitches, and structures. Sampled voices and sound bites pop up randomly and frequently. The song gives off the tone of the album more than anything. This is a dungeon. You are in hell, and slowly going insane. At least, that’s my take on it. Midway through the song, a music box comes through and plays a charming and haphazard melody for a few minutes, until near the end of the song, where the track finishes out with an amalgamation of all the noise heard throughout the album since the beginning until now. Out of the three tracks presented on the album, "Ostranenie" is the most powerful.

The issue of rating this has been plaguing me for the last hour or so. I couldn’t listen to this regularly. I couldn’t see myself ever coming back to it actually. I don’t really like the style of the genre, and I don’t ever see myself liking it. However, I can appreciate this as music, albeit different from anything I’ve heard. I can appreciate the effort, the craftsmanship that went into making such a harrowing atmosphere and tone. While I may never come back to it, I do invite anyone else to listen to the album just once to see their thoughts on it. It’s a different experience and one that may open your eyes towards new tastes in music.



Recent reviews by this author
AJJ Good Luck EverybodyPrince Daddy and The Hyena Cosmic Thrill Seekers
Malibu Ken Malibu KenForests Spending Eternity In A Japanese Convenience Store
Greta Van Fleet Anthem of the Peaceful ArmyKero Kero Bonito Time 'n' Place
user ratings (17)
3.6
great


Comments:Add a Comment 
McTime50
March 1st 2017


1021 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

written for the random album game. if you see any spacing or spelling errors, assume that I'm probably in the middle of fixing those

McTime50
March 1st 2017


1021 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

alright, i got the text aligned the way I wanted it, everything all ironed out.



this was fun, it was interesting to take on something I'd never have listened myself. can't wait to see other peoples reviews for their albums.

TVC15
March 2nd 2017


11372 Comments


I absolutely love these guys' album Merzbild Schwet. I can't imagine how much of a shock listening to this must have been, but a job well done! I'll make a note to listen to this in the future

Conmaniac
March 2nd 2017


27693 Comments


interesting review my man. I like your honest approach of saying how you really don't know much about this genre instead of trying to act like you do. I could give some edits if ya want but it'd mostly be little stuff

McTime50
March 2nd 2017


1021 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I'd be glad to take any small edits you could give, always willing to improve writing.

Conmaniac
March 2nd 2017


27693 Comments


"Each one of them sound similar in presentation" -- very awkward sounding imo, possibly due to the "them" and how a presentation can't really sound like anything. maybe try saying something along the lines of "Each of the different songs are very similar in how they are presented to the listener, but offer a different soundscape"

2nd paragraph you should vary your sentence lengths as it starts to read a bit bullet-pointy. I guess that could be said for most of the review, try switching up some sentence structures and maybe combine sentences together to have the review flow a bit better.

"empty noise" like silence? or do you actually mean noise that is empty sounding

""She Alone Hole and Open" is where the weird starts." I get the informal approach but this just sounds silly.

""Ostranenie", the next and final track, begins piercing your ears." begins by? again this whole paragraph suffers from the short/bullet point sentence style

"I couldn’t see me ever...see me liking it." myself for both "me"s

McTime50
March 2nd 2017


1021 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I've attempted to hit all the points you brought up, thanks for pointing them out!

Dewinged
Staff Reviewer
March 2nd 2017


32047 Comments


Good review man, nicely done. I would have probably skipped the last paragraph, or closed the review with a conclusion related to the band, the album, or smth like that. No need to express the fact that you don't know the band or the genre.

Have a pos!

McTime50
March 2nd 2017


1021 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

thanks for the pos man! while I wouldn't usually end a review like this, the circumstances are special. Can see where you're coming from though.

Divaman
March 2nd 2017


16120 Comments


"This is a dungeon. You are in hell, and slowly going insane. At least, that’s my take on it."

Wouldn't it be funny if the artist's take was something like "It's a hot summer day and I'm at the ice cream stand with my family."

Anyway, very enjoyable read.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy