City and Colour
Sometimes


5.0
classic

Review

by craigtotheposta USER (2 Reviews)
March 10th, 2017 | 4 replies


Release Date: 2005 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A man and his guitar

Where were you, when your first love broke your heart? When the people around you disappointed you more than you could understand. When it was your hardest day. Where were you? Where. Where were you. When you felt like she didn't love you anymore. When you felt like no one loved you anymore. When on the day of her funeral, you fell apart. Where were you. Can you be that honest? Can you express the pain you felt. For me, there is no true way. For anyone is there. It is honestly. It is only only honestly that separates us from all the minutia. From all the pointlessness.

There has to be a point in all of this.
There has to be. Listening to this album, it all floods back. The way that you can love someone so much more than they can ever love you. The way you can blame yourself for every mistake. Th way you can beg for things to be better. The way you wanted them to stay. The way you can let go.

This is more than an album. This is an expression from a man who doesn't know where he is going. Doesn't know where to go or where he has been. It is honest, it is earnest and it is the kind of pain we can face when we love those who don't love us back.

It is a man and his guitar; in complete transparency. With no boundaries, with no moments in between and nothing to hold back. So simple but so true. This is what makes this album as special as it is. It is no complicated swan song. It is no great statement of truimph. No. It is the way that one can feel lost in all of this. All of this great big world. And still not know. But you have to sing it. You have to say it. And even if it isn't perfect, it is yours. It is all we have in this. All of this world of ours. To give our truth.

This is why this album is something special. It is that complete moment of truth. Where one can tell their story. And one man, and one guitar can come together. And they can say all that needs to be said.

That we are unsure, but thats okay. That we can make it through all of this.

That we all feel like this sometimes.


user ratings (892)
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
innerdark (3.5)
Alexisonfire vocalist's solo effort is solid, but has room for improvement...

Two-Headed Boy (3)
A promising debut, if a little on the repetitive side....

ThePriest (4.5)
Without a doubt my favourite acoustic album of all time. and for good reason....



Comments:Add a Comment 
DrGonzo1937
Staff Reviewer
March 10th 2017


18318 Comments


What a great review.

2453
March 10th 2017


24 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Is this even a review?

I mean, your only statement considering the music itself is "It is a man and his guitar; in complete transparency" and even that's not exactly true, because if you listen closely, most songs are accompanied by ambient keys.

And I get that that's not the point of your write-up, but even then it's still just you telling us how you feel about this album in a sort of poetic manner, without reinforcing your opinion by explaining how exactly the music manages to trigger your emotions in this particular kind of way and where its strengths may lie in spite of its considerably mellow, stripped down style. Because this record holds a special place in my heart too, I'm able to relate to your words, but if I'd never listened to any C&C at all, this review would leave me wondering why you 5'd it, because you barely cover the music at all.

Sorry if I come off like a prick, I don't even really dislike your way with words (I even kinda love what you did there with the final lines), but I sometimes feel like these artsy kinda reviews easily run the risk of lacking any bones to have all of this fluffy, emotional hyperbole stand on its own.

Snake.
March 10th 2017


25269 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

yeah this is not a review sorry



would fit better as a soundoff if it were shorter

Satellite
March 11th 2017


26539 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

"This is more than an album."

lol fuck off



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy