Album Rating: 4.0

Overall pretty good, but literally any other song except for Dying in L.A would have been a better opener.



1) (F*ck a) Silver Lining 2/5

2) Say Amen (Saturday Night) 4/5

3) Hey Look Ma, I Made It 2.5/5

4) High Hopes 4/5

5) Roaring 20s 5/5 (easily the best)

6) Dancing's Not a Crime 4.5/5

7) One of the Drunks 2/5

8) The Overpass 4.5/5

9) King of the Clouds 4/5

10) Old Fashioned 5/5

11) Dying in L.A 4.5/5

I mean I probably would have rated the songs that if I was 13 again too

Album Rating: 4.0

Well, 14, so your not wrong I guess. What can i say, I enjoyed the album!

Might change as I get older, but I've always love Broadway-esque music, so maybe not.

Album Rating: 1.0

I would rate it a 0 if I could.

Catchy enough, I kinda enjoy some of it. Not a great album as a complete piece however

Album Rating: 2.0

It's not as culturally important as Fever you can't sweat out, not experimental like Pretty. Odd., it's not poor like the middle albums and not the breath of fresh air surprise the Death of a Bachelor was. Pray for the Wicked is just painfully mediocre with solid moments countered by weak songs with unmemorable tracks sprinkled in

Album Rating: 1.5

Finally listened to this yesterday. "Dying in LA" is a decent ballad, and "Dancing's Not A Crime" is pretty catchy in a not-entirely-annoying way. Overall, the album is just... really shrill, I guess. It's all trebly and loud and the songwriting isn't nearly good enough to excuse how viscerally irritating it is on a purely aural level.

Dancing's Not a Crime is a banger tbh

Album Rating: 2.0

The Overpass and the closer are fine

rest is enahgnajsa

I find it hilarious that songs from this are at the front of rock playlists on Spotify

worst band

Album Rating: 4.0

Panic and Fall Out Boy did have somewhat parallel careers, but Panic had a better output in the early going than Fall Out Boy did.

Album Rating: 2.0

I'd disagree, personally, but I've never rated either of their careers. DOAB is a really great album though

Album Rating: 1.0

Album is loud and obnoxious, but then again it's a Panic at the Disco album so what did you expect?

Album Rating: 2.0

aye, that's pretty much PATD to the tee. at least DOAB had some decent melodies and ideas though, this is more of the same without the interesting songwriting.

Unfortunately the first 5 or 6 songs on this album are still catchy as fuck and find their way into my head all the time.

Why did i comment on this thread FeelsBadMan

Album Rating: 1.5

This album sounds like Death of a Bachelor with less of everything that made DoaB fun. I kept waiting for a song/moment that made me go "oh wow that was actually pretty cool" but it never happened.

Album is actually a huge grower, I'm liking it a lot more than I did.

Album Rating: 2.5

i didn't mention this in my review but "one of the drunks" is pretty damn catchy.



"dancing's not a crime" might be the worst song Panic! has ever done. it's so derivative and cheesy.