At the Gates The Red in the Sky Is Ours
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
bloc
August 1st 2016


70186 Comments


This is pretty bad

pissbore
August 1st 2016


12778 Comments


if you have terrible taste in music i can understand that statement, sure

but if you have the "ears to hear", so to speak... well, then you'd surely make a different statement.

Mystletainn
August 1st 2016


4049 Comments


perhaps the problem isn't with the album, perhaps the problem is with your ears

pissbore
August 1st 2016


12778 Comments


a-fucken-greeeeeeed

EvoHavok
August 1st 2016


8082 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

What don't you like about it, bloc?

Thalassic
September 1st 2016


5738 Comments


So...At the Gates' greatest work only gets a 3.6? That's not nice

Ocean of Noise
September 1st 2016


10970 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yea this site doesn't know the power of early ATG

Spacesh1p
September 1st 2016


7716 Comments


Early AtG >>>>>> Later AtG

Ocean of Noise
September 1st 2016


10970 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

SOTS is still excellent though tbh.

Spacesh1p
September 1st 2016


7716 Comments


Not so much my cup o tea, but I love this and Burning Darkness.

Ocean of Noise
September 1st 2016


10970 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I mean, it's consistent, polished, mainstream melodeath. There's a lot to like about it. It just pales in comparison to their first two albums which are not of this world

Spacesh1p
September 1st 2016


7716 Comments


Yeah I am just not as much of a fan of melodeath but as far as melodeath goes, it's a winner.

Spacesh1p
September 1st 2016


7716 Comments


Gardens of Grief also rules.

Ashen
September 1st 2016


1543 Comments


this is the only AtG album I ever really listen to

Ocean of Noise
September 1st 2016


10970 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Check WFIKTBD again dude.

Ashen
September 1st 2016


1543 Comments


I need to listen to gardens of grief again too. it has been ages

Thalassic
September 1st 2016


5738 Comments


"I mean, it's consistent, polished, mainstream melodeath. There's a lot to like about it. It just pales in comparison to their first two albums which are not of this world"

Yeah, I mean, I know a lot of people hate SotS with a passion, but I think it's effective at what it sets out to do. And I think the sound of that album is still way more vicious and the songs are still way more memorable than the bands that ripped that album off.
The first two AtG albums though (as well as the Gardens of Grief EP) are just so incredibly off kilter and have such a creeping sound, it really evokes a feeling of outright dread in the listener. I mean the riffs on this album...they are just "wrong". A riff shouldn't sound like some of the riffs on this album do. There are no reasons to create riffs that sound so horrifyingly spectral and otherworldly. Yet they did, and the results are magnificent. No other band has ever really copied what AtG did on this album or even on WFIKtBD for that matter. Why did bands copy SotS? Because despite all its strengths, it's easy to copy. Why didn't those bands copy TRitSiO or WFIKtBD? Because they're just unable to; the music on those albums is just something that could only be captured at one moment in time.


Shadowmire
September 1st 2016


6660 Comments


i don't hate it with a passion but where i listen to their first two records on a regular basis, there is little chance i will ever spin slaughter
it's an ok album but honestly, even cutting red in the sky and burning darkness out of the equation, there were better releases by their contemporaries in the same style
maybe i will dig it more one day for some reason

Mystletainn
September 1st 2016


4049 Comments


Sputnik has a lot of questionable metal album avgs I wouldn't worry about it too much

Spacesh1p
September 3rd 2016


7716 Comments


What a great album, bumpin this



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy