">
 

The Dears
No Cities Left


4.0
excellent

Review

by analrightstart USER (8 Reviews)
July 26th, 2005 | 28 replies


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


When i first bought this album i didn't really know what to expect, i had only heard one song off it at the time, and didn't know anything about the band at all, but it came with a bonus cd so i just had to buy it. To be hone3st the first time i listned i thought it was pretty bad, just your average pop rock band trying to be a little experiemntal but failing. But upon a second and third listen i realised this album was much better than i first thought.

SONG REVIEWS

1. We Can Have It - The perfect opening to an album, this song starts with a warm, clean guitar riff accompanied by some nice, touching vocals. It then turns into one of the most touching compositions i have ever heard. The fantastic drum beat kicks in and you're off on a journey into the heart and soul of Murray Lightburn. The vocals in this song are just brilliant, they are so personal... "Somewhere is the one that never will, burn out is out, their looking for a heart, looking for a home, looking for a hand to stroke his head. You're not alone, you're not alone...". Murray Lightburn deserves a medal for these lyrics alone.
5/5

2. Who Are We, Defenders Of The Universe? - Following 'we can have it' this song seems a bit weak, and light hearted at first. But after a couple of listens the chorus lyrics ("I can help you, you can help me") just get planted in your head, and you realise this song is pretty darn good. Based around some nice guitar work, this song flows well, but can get slightly broing at times.
4/5

3. Lost In The Plot - Possibly one of my favourite pop/rock songs ever made, but its hard to say. Once again Lightburn's lyrics in this song are just amazing.. "Leave me in the middle of the ocean, I can walk the rest of the way, and I promise not to cry anymore" and "It's the same old plot to these things". The song can be put into three sections, the first being the cool intro and having a heavier, touching, dramatic feel to it. Then it goes into a more light hearted 'groovy' verse, which then transforms into an almost angry finale. A fantastic song from start to finish.
5/5

4. The Second Part - From here on in the album loses its touch for me. The second part is the beginning of the end for this album, give or take. This acoustic number is hard to listen to, and can get boring. There are some nice bits in it and some cool lyrics like "I then arrived, 10 minutes early with no smokes, and i was broke, without a smoke". The end of this song is cool, but i usually give into the temptation to skip it before it gets there.
3/5

5. Don't Loose The Faith - A happier, brighter song than the first four, this song is catchy but it lacks something. It's a bit too straight forward, and the chorus is a bit weak and indifferent from the verses.
2.5/5

6. Expect The Worst/Cos' she's A Tourist - This song starts with a very dramatic piece of violin playing, followed by some creepy lyrics, and added tension from the drums coming in. Then it all stops for Lightburn to scream "My heart is aching, my back is breaking!" and it then goes into the same thing as before but this time more frantic and some almost opera like singing in the back ground.... quite dramatic actually. It then stops again for Lightburn to announce, "so you decided on old school..". After this announcment this song turns into a slow, dream like, lovable song with a lot of ambient noises in the back ground. There are some excellent bits in this song but its too all over the place, and can drag on.
3.5/5

7. Pinned Together, Falling Apart - this song starts with a minute of noise that would turn the sanest person insane. But after that it turns into a quite nice bass line, then joined by the rest of the band. Once again Lightburns lyrics are the stand out "I had been terrified, by the thought of losing you". The song builds up, and builds up for what seems like ages, then Lightburn explodes into some great 'No, no no!!!"'s, accompanied by a cool sounding guitar solo.
3.5/5

8. Never Destroy Us - Another acoustic number, but this time with a bit more feeling and rhythm to it. This song can be danced to quite easily, and the verses are extremely cool, with some awesome harmonies..."What do you say that we go down together and try to find out all the answers?" Then after the verse a few solo's take place, and then lightburn starts chanting "never destroy us". This song is really cool, fun and serious at the same time. The ending is pretty weird.
4.5/5

9. Warm And Sunny Days - The guitaring at the start of this song catches your attention immediately, and when the drums start you are sure you're in for another good song. And you aren't wrong, this is another really 'groovy' song. Held together by a repetetive guitar riff, and a some good bass playing. The chorus is of particular good quality.
4/5

10. 22: The Death Of All The Romance - This song starts well, with some nice lyrics, and a touching first chorus. But after a while this song drags out and gets rather boring. It does get a bit more exciting in the second chorus, and the instrumental ending is pretty good, with an inspirational trumpet solo, but the song as a whole lacks something.
3.5/5

11. Postcard From Purgatory - the drum line at the start of this song is quite daunting,a nd its made no less scary with the feedback coming from a guitar and an equally as scary bass line. This song builds up for a long time, and does get repetetive and boring, but if you are patient the song reaches an amazing climax. The drumming along with the guitaring in this song are astounding. At the very end of this song the song slows into a really cool heavy rock kind of sound, i like it alot.
3.5/5

12. No Cities Left - Starting with a nice piece of plucky guitaring, followed soon after by a full sounding, technical drum beat this song starts off well, like many of the other songs on this album. And once again lightburns lryics are a stand out feature. But again the song does get repetetive for a while, until everything stops for ligthburn's final prayer "Lets just keep fighting the end of the world. We will hold hands and make plans for life..." the song them turns into a faster, rockier, fuller sound than ever previously experienced in the album. It's a perfect ending to a weird but still nice album.
4/5


Overall this album is very hard to listen to from start to finish. No doubt it has some brilliant songs on it like, 'we can have it', 'lost in the plot' and 'never destroy us' but it lacks originality in every song. They end up all sounding very similar to each other, even to the point where you can't remember what piece of musid goes with what name. Aside from that though, the music and especially the vocals on this album are brilliant. It was worth the money just for thr vocals alone.



Recent reviews by this author
Mirrorline Double DotAlexisonfire Alexisonfire
Doves (UK) Lost SoulsThe Dandy Warhols Come Down
The Smashing Pumpkins Judas OThe Panics Crack In The Wall
user ratings (48)
3.8
excellent


Comments:Add a Comment 
br3ad_man
July 26th 2005


2126 Comments


Decent review, I agree with the rating.

We Can Have It = amazing

Scott Herren
January 16th 2006


192 Comments


22: The Death of All the Romance is better than a 3.5

Zebra
Moderator
January 16th 2006


2647 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'd give this a solid 4 out of 5.

I enjoy listening to most of these songs, although I don't think that there are any standout tracks. I don't typically enjoy pop/rock music but for some reason this albums just does it for me.

handsomerob2
January 20th 2007


58 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

This album just really bothers me most of the time. I find that the Dears have a lot of potential, but they just try to hard to be progressive. On "22: The Death Of All The Romance" is good for the first 2 minutes or so, but it just repeats itself until I'm forced to change it. About half of the songs on here are like that. I agree with most of your ratings, as my two favorite songs off this album are "We Can Have It" and "Lost In The Plot". I think you should have marked those ridiculously drawn out songs lower. Good review though.This Message Edited On 02.03.07

bloc
February 8th 2010


70694 Comments


Lost In the Plot takes be way way way back.

klap
Emeritus
February 8th 2010


12410 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

i have different album art for this yarrr

bloc
February 8th 2010


70694 Comments


The orange and black one.

klap
Emeritus
February 8th 2010


12410 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

yes indeedy



i actually own this CD now that i think about it

okcomputer1016
December 18th 2010


73 Comments


I love this album so much. I find this band to be so underrated, I think because they were "I have
feelings" rock that came out in the era of Coldplay, they were kinda written off as Coldplay-core, but
that's not true. I'd say they're more of a Smiths-meets-Blur thing. All three of these last albums
are great but to me this is definitely the best. Every song is like a tearjerker, although some are
stronger than others (it's frontloaded for sure.)

People who don't like the Dears' music must at least admit this album has totally awesome production,
I love it.

tef
May 12th 2014


209 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

NIce review. Amazing album IMO, very underrated. Unfortunately they never made a better album than this one.

bloc
September 15th 2015


70694 Comments


Ugh this is so fucking good, needs more attention

TurboOutrun
July 9th 2016


89 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Lost in the Plot showed up on my Spotify Discover Weekly recently and I checked out this album, it reminded me a lot of Blur in a good way.



I should get around to checking out the rest of their discography.

bloc
June 17th 2017


70694 Comments


So damn underrated. Lost In The Plot is one of my favourite songs ever

bloc
February 21st 2018


70694 Comments


Someday I may 5 this

Demon of the Fall
February 21st 2018


36051 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Interesting bump. This used to be my jam. Do you remember that video with the teddy bears in it? Heartbreaking.

bloc
February 21st 2018


70694 Comments


Holy fuck you got this rated? Damn son I might be in love...

Demon of the Fall
February 21st 2018


36051 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Oh my. My rating might be harsh actually, 4 seems appropriate.

bloc
February 21st 2018


70694 Comments


Really really nice to see that high rating (let alone any rating) man. One of the biggest surprises I've seen from you.

Demon of the Fall
February 21st 2018


36051 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

You shouldn't be surprised, my taste is immaculate. Joking aside, it wouldn't be an exaggeration to say this was one of my favourite albums once upon a time, I used to really dig the one after this as well but that wore off to a greater extent.

bloc
February 21st 2018


70694 Comments


Hmm, good to know there's dimensions to Demo that go beyond metal haha



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy