ManintheBox
01.17.13 | Death wouldn't be here if not for thash, but death metal has far superior bands and has evolved way more than thrash metal which hasn't really progressed at all since the early 90s. So Death Metal IMO |
oltnabrick
01.17.13 | i like dm more. theres more diversity between bands |
YankeeDudel
01.17.13 | black metal |
ffs
01.17.13 | They Both FUckin Suck |
thumbcrusher
01.17.13 | I prefer thrash |
oltnabrick
01.17.13 | crust punk |
Keyblade
01.17.13 | DM all day everyday |
Atari
01.17.13 | thrash don't even have to think about it |
MO
01.17.13 | dm easy |
Sapient.
01.17.13 | Death metal, like people have said it has more sub genres and generally more technicality. Also Death is one of my favorite bands so I have some bias |
JamieTwort
01.17.13 | Thrash |
Propose
01.17.13 | death metal easily |
manosg
01.17.13 | Thrash all the way |
Evreaia
01.17.13 | black metal [2] |
TBliss2
01.17.13 | Rush |
TheNotrap
01.17.13 | What you consider most important?
Difficult to tell.
At the moment DM is definitely more important and one of metal's most exciting sub-genres. But thrash came first, bands like Metallica, Slayer or Kreator helped to shape DM early sound (Possessed, Death).
Historically: Thrash
Now: Death Metal (with all its sub-genres) |
huguitoescorza
01.17.13 | very interesting answers |
GiaNXGX
01.17.13 | avant-garde jazz, death metal is for losers that do heroin and are very depressed that's why they listen to amon amarth cannibalist corpse and dat shit, take a look at thise album covers brathan this is not even beautiful, this is satanic you'll burn in hell, praise the lord all hail jesus praise god and save your soul otherwise youll regret it when you die and mister satan places your testicles inside his penis |
intotheshit
01.17.13 | Another pointless list from the world's most pointless human being. |
GiaNXGX
01.17.13 | hey hello someguest's alt |
evilford
01.17.13 | great answer by the notrap
lots of aspects go into it. thrash came first, and ultimately was the most significant force in creating death metal. BUT, since then, thrash stagnated and dm grew and evolved, and yeah I think since at least the mid 90s, both genres have been pretty stale. it's been a downward spiral of decreasing demand (people that want to hear it) and then supply (bands that play quality dm or thrash), but I think the demand these days is more there for dm than thrash. overall, more people want to hear it/see it evolve it seems.
very close, I love both genres a lot. thrash ultimately is probably more important historically. but for what I love the most as a genre overall I have to pick DM cuz = 1. chuck, 2. death, and 3. immolation |
evilford
01.17.13 | all that said, I think dm is more relevant in 2013 |
DrMaximus
01.17.13 | black metal [3] |
bloc
01.17.13 | Death metal has definitely had more of an impact as it still thrives today in various forms (whether we like those forms or not), but you give me a classic of either genre and I'll probably rather listen to the thrash one. |
J0ckstrapsFTW
01.17.13 | DM |
KILL
01.17.13 | tbliss knows |
bach
01.17.13 | I prefer death metal, but Thrash is of more importance. |
JokineAugustus
01.18.13 | dm always. I am bias as well though. Thrash created death metal though so I respect it. |
foxxxythnksustnk
01.18.13 | death |
ViralOblivion
01.18.13 | DM fer sure |
oltnabrick
01.18.13 | lil b - based jam |
foxxxythnksustnk
01.18.13 | wait underoath is death right
or thrash? |
oltnabrick
01.18.13 | they are doom metal |
KjSwantko
01.18.13 | tie between DM and TM for me. |
YankeeDudel
01.18.13 | Melodeath is like a mixture of death, thrash, and heavy. It is quite simply the perfect storm. |
ShadowRemains
01.18.13 | dm |
YankeeDudel
01.18.13 | I was half joking but yea melodeath was pretty much my teen years. When its done well its great but theres alot of meh out there now. I guess theres only so much you can do with the sound. |
Hyperion1001
01.18.13 | "Melodeath is like a mixture of death, thrash, and heavy. It is quite simply the perfect storm."
ha no
dm > |
foxxxythnksustnk
01.18.13 | melodeath is the best as long as it is a hypocrisy album |
evilford
01.18.13 | melodeath ugh |
JokineAugustus
01.18.13 | Melodeath is getting stale though I still love some stuff. |
pissbore
01.18.13 | 70s priest is better |
Insurrection
01.18.13 | death |
Atari
01.18.13 | thrash |
Hawks
01.18.13 | Dm wins it's not even close. |
oltnabrick
01.18.13 | metallica |
Atari
01.18.13 | Thrash wins it's not even close |
pissbore
01.18.13 | sadus |
Hawks
01.18.13 | Well that was clever wasn't it? |
Atari
01.18.13 | Always. But seriously it's a close call I just love thrash |
evilford
01.18.13 | Coroner makes it a dam close fight |
dsroka005
01.18.13 | ^this.. but i think DM has progressed more |
ChuckyTruant
04.23.13 | is this even a question? |
ReturnToRock
04.23.13 | Thrash metal is more important since it birthed death metal, but death metal has gone through the most changes and is the broader, more evolved scene presently. Thrash bands got stuck in 1986 for the most part. |
ChuckyTruant
04.23.13 | what pedro said
DM is waaay more fun IMO |
NeroCorleone80
04.23.13 | Death has more variety, you can have fast or slow paced death metal, you cant have slow paced thrash |
pissbore
04.23.13 | thrashing deathblack metal |
DrHouseSchuldiner
04.23.13 | 80s thrash>80s death
90s thrash=90s death
2000s death is better
2010s death is better |
BloodSweatandBeers
04.23.13 | wow pissbore that wuz so funi did u come up wth that all on ure own |
DrHouseSchuldiner
04.23.13 | love both hard tho |
ReturnToRock
04.23.13 | "Death has more variety, you can have fast or slow paced death metal, you cant have slow paced thrash"
Grip Inc., AJFA-era Metallica. |
Scum
04.23.13 | love both, but i prefer dm |
evilford
04.23.13 | overall I prob like thrash more these days
still love dm tho |
CaptainHadouken
04.23.13 | Death metal evolved from thrash, sooo yeah. But both are equally important IMO |
Atari
04.23.13 | i'm so happy to hear you say that ford : )
although it's hard to beat the thrash/death mix |
Funeralopolis
04.23.13 | death metal is the best genre ever |
evilford
04.23.13 | my top 5 dm edge out my top 5 thrash (death, immolation, atheist, morbid angel and gorguts vs heathen, coroner, anacrusis, sabbat and sepultura), but overall, I like thrash better I think. I'm aware of the "genre limitations", I just dig the essence a little more than dm |
BrieLarson
04.23.13 | I can do all kinds of screams I just need a band :( |
pissbore
04.23.13 | sadus agreed |
demigod!
04.23.13 | i prefer death metal for sure but i still love a good deal of thrash bands |
Hawks
04.23.13 | death metal is the best genre ever [2] |
pissbore
04.23.13 | Hawks did u check out in the sign of evil yet |
demigod!
04.23.13 | do it hard hawks |
Hawks
04.23.13 | Gonna d/l right now just for you Piss. |
Atari
04.23.13 | it obviously depends on the band there are some fantastic dm bands but overall the list of thrash bands i enjoy is like 3 times as long |
apert
04.23.13 | blasphemer is probably the best sodom song ever |
pissbore
04.23.13 | sweet im wearing my witching metal shirt right now and i am pleased |
pissbore
04.23.13 | is 7 up? |
Cygnatti
04.23.13 | "avant-garde jazz, death metal is for losers that do heroin and are very depressed that's why they listen to amon amarth cannibalist corpse and dat shit, take a look at thise album covers brathan this is not even beautiful, this is satanic you'll burn in hell, praise the lord all hail jesus praise god and save your soul otherwise youll regret it when you die and mister satan places your testicles inside his penis"
hey base :D |
sixdegrees
12.29.17 | hey base [2] |