jmh886
10.08.13 | Woohoo |
PunchforPunch
10.08.13 | The Sixth of June |
MeatSalad
10.08.13 | Happy to see 16 here |
jmh886
10.08.13 | I don't even know what genre they fall under. Whatever it is, it's awesome. |
dathvada321
10.08.13 | best metalcore album list that includes haste the day and august burns red but not underoath=bad list |
SIMBOLIC
10.08.13 | 21 is best metalcore |
Potating
10.08.13 | 21 isn't metalcore. Also, no Converge or Zao? Shame and disgrace :P |
MeatSalad
10.08.13 | Converge is 9
|
Nocturnal
10.08.13 | Attack Attack! - Someday Came Suddenly
Emmure - The Respect Issue
A Day To Remember - Homesick
Bring Me The Horizon - Suicide Season
Asking Alexandria - Stand Up and Scream
Not sure if these are metalcore or hardcore bands. Whatevs |
jmh886
10.08.13 | I pretty much hate all those bands^ |
jmh886
10.08.13 | Also, I only consider later Underoath metalcore. Maybe disambiguation would be 27. Not a fan of Zao. And yea In Flames could be called something else I guess, but they're pretty close. |
YUJOS
10.08.13 | 21 is best metalcore (2) |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
10.08.13 | underoath - cries of the past |
Trebor.
10.08.13 | Colony wut |
Trebor.
10.08.13 | "And yea In Flames could be called something else I guess, but they're pretty close."
no, just cuz you inspire a genre doesn't mean you are a genre, plus the founders of metalcore weren't even influenced by that shit, it wasn't until melodic metalcore that bands started aping every riff from Slaughter of The Soul |
CK
10.08.13 | Way to not include a single Misery Signals album |
jmh886
10.08.13 | ^Ahh huge fuck up. They're one of my favorite bands. Controller would probably be top 5. My brain sucks. |
jmh886
10.08.13 | hey trebor. who cares. |
intotheshit
10.08.13 | First of all, this list is laughable. Second of all, 21 is not
metalcore. Third of all, later Underoath? Dude, their first
few releases are as metalcore as it gets.
God, you're dumb. |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
10.08.13 | thx pit tell him about cries of the past |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
10.08.13 | reported |
Trebor.
10.08.13 | "hey trebor. who cares."
clearly you do
BOOM ROASTED |
CK
10.08.13 | "Underoath? Dude, their first few releases are as metalcore as it gets."
lolwut |
Trebor.
10.08.13 | Isn't the first one unblack metal or some shit |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
10.08.13 | ive always regarded cries to the past as metalcore not gonna stop now (cuz it is |
CK
10.08.13 | Act of Depression maybe but I can't hear it at all on Cries. AOD is a shit album though |
Avagantamos
10.08.13 | knut - challenger
best metalcore ever |
jmh886
10.08.13 | reported? jesus, come on man |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
10.08.13 | my bud sonic is gonna wipe u off this site |
jmh886
10.08.13 | Cool man. Have fun with that. |
Ecksavie
10.08.13 | in before Spitfire and Scarlet |
JustinKing
10.08.13 | Knut - Challenger [2]
Deadguy - Fixation on a Coworker
Comity - The Deus Ex-Machina as a Forgotten Genius (Andy Warhol Sucks)
Zao - Liberate Ex Inferis
Scarlet - Cult Classic [2]
Spitfire - The Dead Next Door [2]
As the Sun Sets - 7744
Breather Resist - Charmer
Morning Again - As Tradition Dies Slowly
Martyr AD - On Earth as It Is in Hell
Integrity - Humanity Is the Devil
7 Angels 7 Plagues - Jhazmyne's Lullabye
Anam Cara - Ready to Live
Skycamefalling - 10.21
Heartscarved - ...And Tomorrow We Escape
From Here On - Hope for a Bleeding Sky
Dead Blue Sky - Symptoms of an Unwanted Emotion
Unruh - Setting Fire to Sinking Ships
Undying - At History's End
Training for Utopia - Plastic Soul Impalement
The Secret - Luce
Scars of Tomorrow - Rope Tied to the Trigger
Quell - One Man's Struggle with the English Language
Reflux - The Illusion of Democracy
Playing Enemy - I Was Your City
Kiss It Goodbye - She Loves Me Not...
Nehemiah - The Asphyxiation Process
Life in Pictures - By the Sign of the Spyglass |
DanielNightLewis
10.08.13 | Justin, I am getting the feeling that our posts in these lists will be more or less identical...
Good call on Dead Blue Sky though, forgot all about them. |
jmh886
10.08.13 | Thanks for that list! I've only heard a couple on there so I shall try to check some of it out. I think Ill ive heard is 7 angels and zao
|
witchxrapist
10.08.13 | lol thread
my taste is better than all yall |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
10.08.13 | same |
JustinKing
10.08.13 | @jmh I know you said you don't particularly like Zao, but give them a few more spins. They do grow on you.
@Daniel Dead Blue Sky's album is fantastic. One of my favorites, actually. I try to vary up my suggestions a bit from time to time, but I always have some constants. |
jmh886
10.08.13 | i dont not like zao. ive only heard two of their albums and i just wouldnt put them on a top list. listening to that liberate album as we speak.
@witchxrapist im pretty open minded and love suggestions. so instead of being a douche make some. |
JustinKing
10.08.13 | There are definitely some of their albums that aren't as accessible as others, like The Fear Is What Keeps Us Here or Parade of Chaos. Liberate and Where Blood and Fire Bring Rest, perhaps even The Funeral of God, are probably their best albums, and especially the best starting points for the band. |
Ecksavie
10.08.13 | Totally called it. Good list though, Justin. Should get him started pretty well. |
DanielNightLewis
10.08.13 | @Justin, I'm listening to it now, when the vocals come in on Ascension of Beauty hits so hard! There were so many amazing 1-shot bands around that time who seemed to pour everything they had in to one release and then implode.
Add these to the pile:
Crydebris - The Severing
Found Dead Hanging - Dulling Occam's Razor
Blood Has Been Shed - Spirals
Burnt By The Sun - Soundtrack to the Personal Revolution
Battle for Paris - Superstar
Cubic Space Diviosn - s/t
Hunt/Gather - False Monuments
|
Curse.
10.08.13 | III: In The Eyes Of Fire> The Oncoming Storm
You wouldn't call any of PTW's other albums metalcore but you will call In Flames, Darkest Hour, LOG, PTH, and TDEP metalcore. ok. |
jmh886
10.08.13 | To each his own. I like 3, but the oncoming storm is my jam. And yes about ptw, maybe tear from the red, but after you come before you they werent even close. And you can make a valid argument for the other bands not being metalcore, but I genres are so subjective so I dont care. But darkest hour is 100% metalcore. What the hell would you call them? |
NoMeansYes
10.08.13 | 21 could not be more incorrectly placed. Learn to music. |
jmh886
10.08.13 | Heard blood has been shed. I added a few of those bands to my impossibly long queue so hopefully ill get to it eventually. |
jmh886
10.08.13 | Sure it could. I could have put it in a best rap album list. |
jmh886
10.08.13 | all genre arguing aside, i always lump a lot of these bands together because i started listening to them at the same time. |
intotheshit
10.09.13 | That's a good reason to call them all the same genre. Good call. |
SIMBOLIC
10.09.13 | intotheshit bringing truth |
witchxrapist
10.09.13 | Acting like you don't recognize the varying degrees of metal-to-hardcore ratios and different eras of sounds is funny.
|
witchxrapist
10.09.13 | the true top 50 metalcore list:
http://i.imgur.com/QIGVM1I.jpg |
jmh886
10.09.13 | God you people are so petty. I apologize for putting a couple bands on a list that may or may not be in the same subgenre as other bands. Important things people. |
jmh886
10.09.13 | Also, every one of these bands is described as "metalcore" by sputnik. |
jmh886
10.09.13 | I'll change the name of the list to "best metalcore/other bands that are almost metalcore but some people may disagree that I started listening to around the same time" albums. |
jmh886
10.09.13 | boo ya |
jmh886
10.09.13 | @futures those first to haste the day albums are the shit. they never recovered when they lost jimmy. music wasnt bad after that but it was never the same. i really hope trenches does some more stuff. |
jmh886
10.09.13 | @witchxrapist. I have a bunch of those bands on my list. |
Inferis
10.09.13 | No love for Zao? |
NoMeansYes
10.09.13 | Should have re-named to just "bands/albums I started listening to at the same time" and all would have
been forgiven. In flames did perhaps go a bit metalcore in recent years but sure as shit nowhere near
it in the beginning. Couple of decent albums on here though |
witchxrapist
10.09.13 | my list sucks i forgot knut |
jmh886
10.09.13 | Agreed. I just wanted to make the point that most of this list is indeed metalcore and ppl just gave me shit for one or two out of place bands. Whatevs.. |
Havey
10.09.13 | where are all 'other' bands
misleading title
shit list too |
Curse.
10.09.13 | Darkest Hour is a melodeath band, basically. Don't let John Henry's vocals fool you |
jmh886
10.09.13 | man I'm never putting a genre in a list title ever again. |
Curse.
10.09.13 | Or you could just know what you're talking about |
Kman418
10.09.13 | check out octaves |
jmh886
10.09.13 | No I just listen to music instead of arguing with strangers about what genre is what. |
jmh886
10.09.13 | Ive listened to octaves. Theyre aight. |
ChopSuey
10.09.13 | "No I just listen to music instead of arguing with strangers about what genre is what."
lol. he just got owned. Besides, its true. Never argue about stupid shit |
jmh886
10.09.13 | For reals. I always let myself get into them on this site, but there are so many users that make petty comments like that, it's so hard not to. Thankfully there are enough constructive users to keep me on this site. |
ChopSuey
10.10.13 | I feel the exact same way. Thats why I've been on this site less often. Social degenerates I tell ya |
