BMDrummer
03.22.14 | So far, probably Crack the Skye because it's well arranged and barely includes any wankery. It also has the most emotion of any Mastodon release. |
Grindalicious
03.22.14 | Hearts Alive |
climactic
03.22.14 | definitely leviathan, no contest imo |
Kalopsia
03.22.14 | "Here I'll offer up 5 (sort of) objective reasons"
I'm eagerly awaiting the first ever objective opinion about a piece of music. History is going to be made here folks |
Grindalicious
03.22.14 | Remission for me |
zakalwe
03.22.14 | At this moment in time Remission. The thing really does rock like a beast. |
mandan
03.22.14 | I'm torn between their first 3, although it's prob either Leviathan or Blood Mountain. |
KriegdemKriege
03.22.14 | Well, since Leviathan is a solid 3.5, I'd say nothing makes it a classic. |
Funeralopolis
03.22.14 | "What Makes Leviathan a Classic?"
nothing |
adace1
03.22.14 | Crack the Skye for me. It was the album that got me into the band and their best imo. |
VisionsFromTheDarkSide
03.22.14 | Probably Leviathan for me but the best stuff off Crack the Skye is better than any of their other stuff (i.e. The Czar) |
RiffOClock
03.22.14 | "assuming you enjoy at least one"
assume again |
Trebor.
03.22.14 | Mastodon are probably the most OK band I've ever heard |
climactic
03.22.14 | but riffs man |
pissbore
03.22.14 | amazing song by sinister agreed |
Insurrection
03.22.14 | best mastodon but not even close to a classic |
Crysis
03.22.14 | the guitar solos make it a 5/5 |
Wadlez
03.22.14 | Crack the Skye.. Being the first one I jammed. Trebor bringing the meh opinions once again. |
pedro70512
03.22.14 | It's a 5. Blood Mountain is probably my favorite for sentimental purposes but Leviathan is a stupendous album. |
pedro70512
03.22.14 | ^ Slaughter of the Soul |
conesmoke
03.22.14 | A classic within sludge metal maybe. |
BloodandRainbows
03.22.14 | Does that not make it a classic overall? I mean, calling something a classic requires context. |
Avagantamos
03.22.14 | "Mastodon are probably the most OK band I've ever heard"
exactly how I've always felt |
MoosechriS
03.22.14 | my fave mastodon is crack the skye, the writing and the sequencing work with the concept to just seemingly make something bigger than the sum of it's parts. I've had times listening to the solo in the czar and i swear i've been transported to another place in space and time. But i do love all Mastodon, this is a close second for me and was my favourite until crack the skye. Also i agree with 3 so much, Brann Dailor's performance on this just helps elevate everything up a few more notches. |
Relinquished
03.22.14 | "A classic within sludge metal maybe"
nope |
Judio!
03.22.14 | Well done list but in my opinion Crack the Skye > |
BMDrummer
03.22.14 | "making of a classic= influence>popularity>songwriting"
This is why I've always thought a 5/5 should mean "masterpiece" instead of classic because you shouldn't always rate based on cultural significance/influence. |
conesmoke
03.22.14 | Up yours relinquished you know I'm right bitch. It sits right next to oceanic. |
Dolving999
03.22.14 | "Artwork - I may catch some flak for this"
How so? That artwork is godly, I wouldn't expect another thing from Paul Romano. |
Nikkolae
03.22.14 | dunno if its a classic but it sure as hell is good, im more of a Remission kind of guy and Blood Mountain can suck it |
BloodandRainbows
03.22.14 | The Hunter can suck it. Pretty bland album and it wasn't any better live. |
climactic
03.22.14 | "the guitar solos make it a 5/5"
heh heh...i get it |
BMDrummer
03.22.14 | @spookynewghostfriend Yeah, I have some albums that are considered classics (e.g. The Velvet Underground & Nico, Dark Side of the Moon), but I do have some that are personal (e.g. My War, Songs About Fucking). |
neurisis17
03.22.14 | @Dolving999
Mainly because it doesn't have anything to do with the actual music, and I wasn't sure if that would be relentlessly pointed out. |
BloodandRainbows
03.22.14 | The full artwork to this is amazing, with the great wave and stuff. I have a poster of it above my bed. |
FadedSun
03.22.14 | White!...whale! Holy!...grail! |
rockandmetaljunkie
03.22.14 | album's not a classic |
Uranium
03.22.14 | The last 5% of Moby Dick deserves a standing ovation and yet the other 95% sucks horribly |
BloodandRainbows
03.22.14 | As long as everyone's standing at the end. You're right though, there's a whole lot of not much happening in the middle third. |
DominionMM1
03.22.14 | i prefer remission |
BigPleb
03.22.14 | Its all about the fucking riffs, same with Remission. |