|
User
Reviews 7
Approval 86%
Soundoffs 17
News Articles 1
Band Edits + Tags 3
Album Edits 34
Album Ratings 642
Objectivity 78%
Last Active 12-23-10 7:47 am
Joined 04-12-07
Review Comments 549
| They Aren't Not Overrated
An overrated list that doesn't have Nevermind, OK Computer, and Dark side Of The Moon??? WHAAAA??? | | 1 |  | Aerosmith
Rocks
I never got why this was the most loved Aerosmith album. | | 2 |  | Opeth
Blackwater Park
Overrated: The only type of list that REALLY needs moar Opeth. | | 3 |  | Kyuss
Blues for the Red Sun
Keep in mind this is one of my top 5 Bands. But this album isn't that much better than Wretch or Welcome to Sky Valley. | | 4 |  | Muse
Absolution
A great album, but not amazing. Plus I can only take so many of Matthew Bellamy's Gasps after every sentence. I can't be the only one who feels this way. OK maybe I am. | | 5 |  | Queen
A night at the opera
See News Of The World, plz. | | 6 |  | 2Pac
All Eyez On Me
Just because it's a Double cd with almost no filler doesn't make it a classic. | | 7 |  | Bjork
Homogenic
A great album, and her best. I'm sick of seeing it in the top 15 albums of the 90's. Because it's not. | | 8 |  | Mr. Bungle
California
Why do people refuse to admit there are 3 ok songs on this? | | 9 |  | Rush
2112
Overrated because Moving Pictures got so overrated, people started pretending to like this more. | | 10 |  | Slint
Spiderland
I love all of the bands on this list. Especially Slint, but C'mon. I'm not going to mention that other Band that I always do, but this gets more love than it should. That said, probably my favorite album on this list. | | 11 |  | Kraftwerk
Trans-Europa Express
As much as I hate putting this on here, it is overrated. Not even their second best album, yet somehow 90% of people here this before any other Kraftwerk album (Made up Percentages FTW!!!) | | 12 |  | Sonic Youth
Daydream Nation
I guess I just don't "GET" it. I've tried to "GET" it for two years now, and nothing. | | 13 |  | Pixies
Surfer Rosa
A nice little album. But I see it on far too many lists (In magazines and websites, not here.) | | 14 |  | Metallica
Master Of Puppets
Hey, OK Cumputer, Led Zeppilin IV, and El Cielo were spared. But this album has more reviews than entire artist careers do. My second favorite album on this list. | | 15 |  | Porcupine Tree
Fear Of A Blank Planet
Honestly, half of their albums are overrated. Really. | | 16 |  | Pink Floyd
Wish You Were Here
My least favorite of the well known Pink Floyd albums. Half of the album is Average, yes, average. | |
charlesfishowitz
04.16.08 | you know, ive never checked out anything by 12...ever.
...and master is a completely overrated album, but still decent..i personally like justice better. | BallsToTheWall
04.16.08 | I was fine until I found 7 here. Whats wrong with you Nancy? 7 is top 15. Tbh, there are alot of solid albums here, even Blackwater Park is great. 15 I agree on. | Big Baby Jesus
04.16.08 | Bad and overrated are 2 different things. The only albums here i Don't like are 1, 9, 15, & 16. 12 is somewhere in between. | charlesfishowitz
04.16.08 | also, it says ok cumputer in your description for master....cumputer....cum..
giggle. | freudianslipknot
04.16.08 | Never really understood what overrated/underrated meant tbh. I will say that #5 is totally incredible, as indeed is NotW. Also 2 and 14 rule. | Chewie
04.16.08 | tee hee | Chewie
04.16.08 | Altmer's gunna own yo ass for dissing WYWH | willfellmarsy
04.16.08 | My new favorite person on Sputnik, you forgot Thrice's discography but 2 is the most win ever...15 i m definately in agreement with as well. | Crysis
04.16.08 | "An overrated list that doesn't have Nevermind, OK Computer, and Dark side Of The Moon??? WHAAAA???"
But does have Blackwater Park and Master Of Puppets???? Whaaaaaaaaaaaa????? | PayneTiger777
04.16.08 | I'm sorry but to say that 15 is overrated just breaks my heart. I love that album. | Big Baby Jesus
04.16.08 | Thrice doesn't deserve any attention at all, or I would've put it in here. | Masochist
04.17.08 | Can't agree with #16 personally. It's my favorite of all Pink Floyd albums. | willfellmarsy
04.17.08 | high five my man Thrie ftl. | willfellmarsy
04.17.08 | ^^^fail...Learn how to spell Thrice when you say they fail n00b! | TheGreatD17
04.17.08 | I was going to get mad because I like a lot of these bands, but I would have to agree with all of these I guess. Opeth isn't overrated but I don't think BP is their best, Absolution is merely above average, and Mr. Bungle destroys California. Good call on the last two as well, but you shouldn't have spared El Cielo. | Doppelganger
04.17.08 | Your comment on #8 causes my eyes to redden and roll into the back of my skull | Serpento
04.17.08 | No way 5, 13, or El Cielo are overrated. otherwise yup. | Mendigo
04.17.08 | 16 rules so hard.
and 15 isn't overrated either.
but I agree with 2, 4, 12, 13 & 14. all of those are great albums (with Absolution being the weakest of them), but not as great as many want them to be.
and I wouldn't have been offended by seeing OK Computer & Dark Side of the Moon here ;) | Electric City
04.17.08 | im surprised no one's called you on Slint. |
|
