SCREAM!
04.06.14 | Tough calls will be made
Red
Animals
CttE |
ArsMoriendi
04.06.14 | Animals
Close to the Edge |
BMDrummer
04.06.14 | Lamb Lies Down
Animals
Close to the Edge |
mandan
04.06.14 | Red
(only heard Aqualung once)
TaaB |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | Oh man!!!
Red
Aqualung
CTTE (my #1 over #2) |
mandan
04.06.14 | You like Tull more than Floyd Friday?
Interesting.
I'm pretty sure JT will vote for both Tull albums and The Lamb. |
SCREAM!
04.06.14 | Yeah I kind of expected JT's vote to be the only one Aqualung got considering the opponent it's up against |
zakalwe
04.06.14 | Red
Animals
Brick |
mandan
04.06.14 | Nero's gonna pick Red, Animals, and CttE. |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | About the same, but I do like WYWH and Darkside a lot better than Animals. I don't feel it has enough new musical ideas to compete with Floyd's previous two albums though it does have great guitar from Gilmour. |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | and yeah dannyboy you pegged JT |
Greem
04.06.14 | Lamb Animals Brick |
MrSirLordGentleman
04.06.14 | Red Animals CttE |
SCREAM!
04.06.14 | @Friday, I disagree. Dark Side and WYWH both have a sort of airy/spacey feel to them whereas Animals is a lot more down to earth and straightforward. Although it still sounds very much like a Pink Floyd record (which it should) it feel like a pretty big stylistic change from the previous few albums |
TheSpaceMan
04.06.14 | Red,
Animals,
Thick as a Brick |
Hovse
04.06.14 | Red
Animals
Close to the Edge |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | @SCREAM! Yeah that makes sense. Maybe it's the less spacey feel that loses its magic on me. |
adr
04.06.14 | Red
Animals
Thick as a Brick |
JamieTwort
04.06.14 | You guys seem to think this is more of an easy choice for me than it actually is. Animals is one of my all time favourite albums. Red is up there with my favourite prog too but yeah as you predicted...
The Lamb
Aqualung (so close)
Thick as a Brick (not even remotely close) |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | @JT It's cool bro you have friends that know you ;) |
mandan
04.06.14 | Tull's gonna get eliminated, sorry JT. I'd say I like 'em more than Yes too, but Yes fans outnumber Tull fans by far. |
JamieTwort
04.06.14 | It's alright, I know in my heart that Thick as a Brick is the true worthy winner. |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | At least CTTE I mean it's topped lists before and stands at #1 on progarchives. It's an evergreen album (hehe) among proggers young and old. |
menawati
04.06.14 | very difficult..
Red
Animals
Close to the Edge |
mandan
04.06.14 | Big KC fan eh mena? |
menawati
04.06.14 | my favourite band i suppose overall yes |
KILL
04.06.14 | red
animals
ctte |
mandan
04.06.14 | ^^sweet, they were awesome so I don't blame you. |
Jethro42
04.06.14 | The Lamb
Aqualung
Close to the Edge |
mandan
04.06.14 | I'll bet that was hard Jethro. |
Jethro42
04.06.14 | yes that was hard. |
menawati
04.06.14 | denied his name on the 3rd choice |
SCREAM!
04.06.14 | the disciple who denied the Tull |
mandan
04.06.14 | Lololololol |
Jethro42
04.06.14 | Close to the Edge is the best album ever. |
FruityCatOfDoom
04.06.14 | Red, Animals, Thick |
JokineAugustus
04.06.14 | Red
Animals
Close To The Edge
|
TwigTW
04.06.14 | The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Animals
Close to the Edge |
mandan
04.06.14 | Red, Animals and CttE should win by the look of things.
Sad to see Genesis out of the running, looks like it's gonna be down to Yes, Floyd and KC.
Should be a battle for the ages. |
emester
04.06.14 | Red
Animals
CTTE |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | yeah but that's 3 Floyd albums in the running so Floyd has a 50% chance, Crimson a 33.3% chance and
Yes a 16.7% chance. Of course we all know that means nothing haha |
menawati
04.06.14 | all depends on the matchups so SCREAM is the puppetmaster |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | Just call my name, cause I'll hear you SCREAM! |
mandan
04.06.14 | I believe CttE won last time, so it'd be cool to see a different winner. |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | It would also be cool to see complete CTTE domination! Too soon? |
SCREAM!
04.06.14 | I'm fine with CttE domination tbh haha |
menawati
04.06.14 | see, subtle puppetmastery i told you |
theacademy
04.06.14 | and it doesnt matter
if the vision shatters
its the nudity
that much is understood
and it better be
it better be
it better be good |
SCREAM!
04.06.14 | @menawati puppetmastery can only go so far! No matter how I match things up only one album can come out on top in the end |
menawati
04.06.14 | no man, i bet you have an excel spreadsheet with all sorts of stuff on it so you can make sure the matchups lead to the best chance possible of knocking out all likely challengers to CttE |
SCREAM!
04.06.14 | Guess I didn't think my spreadsheets through properly cause it looks like it'll be going up against Floyd next round |
Friday13th
04.06.14 | Put CTTE against WYWH. If CTTE still wins then shut up all ya haterzzzzz |
menawati
04.06.14 | gonna bet on animals |
TheSpaceMan
04.06.14 | [2] |
fallenbird
04.06.14 | Red
Animals
Close To The Edge |
NeroCorleone80
04.06.14 | Red
Animals
Close to the Edge |
mandan
04.06.14 | ^as I predicted. |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
04.06.14 | red
aqua
close |
KILL
04.06.14 | fragile is out silent are you upset |
NeroCorleone80
04.06.14 | Easy choice. All 3 of them are top 5 prog for me. |
JaySpiral
04.06.14 | Oh jeez, this is the hardest one yet. Red vs The Lamb and CttE vs TaaB are so close. |
Onirium
04.06.14 | This time it's a pretty easy choice:
Red
Animals
Close to the Edge |
SCREAM!
04.07.14 | Next wave is the final 6...if you thought shit was tough now... |
Onirium
04.07.14 | It will probably all end up with Close to the Edge vs. In the Court of the Crimson King (or WYWH) |
SCREAM!
04.07.14 | I don't see ItC making it past those PF albums tbh but I could be wrong |
ArsMoriendi
04.07.14 | The fact that Fragile is already out makes me sad. Also I think The Yes Album didn't make it either. :( |
SCREAM!
04.07.14 | nope CttE is the only one that made it past the Yes vs JT round. Fragile had it tough though going against Thick as a Brick |
JaySpiral
04.07.14 | The Lamb
Animals
Thick as a Brick (I guess, ugh) |
mandan
04.07.14 | Yup, Red defeated Lamb. Sad to see Gen wiped out, but that's life. |
SCREAM!
04.07.14 | Red, Animals and CttE live to see another round. Can't say I'm sad to see Genesis go though |
mandan
04.07.14 | To each their own dude. |
eddie95
04.08.14 | Red
Animals
Brick |
lensag
04.08.14 | red
animals
thick as a brick |