mryrtmrnfoxxxy
05.16.14 | i can argue that 2 is better than 1 |
adr
05.16.14 | you can't, because it's not.
also 5 is so damn low |
TalonsOfFire
05.16.14 | Yeah I wrestled a lot with where to put the debut as it used to be my #1 favorite by them |
sapient
05.16.14 | I wish the production on 1 and 2 hit a bit harder, a bit closer to 3's, I'd like them better if that was the case |
NeroCorleone80
05.16.14 | Swap 1 and 2 and then move 5 up to 3 and I'd agree completely with this |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
05.16.14 | Swap 1 and 2 and then move 5 up to 3 and I'd agree completely with this [2] |
DikkoZinner
05.16.14 | Best band |
NeroCorleone80
05.16.14 | ever |
BMDrummer
05.16.14 | 2 is 1 |
TalonsOfFire
05.16.14 | There's three amazing songs on the S/T, but Wicked World, Behind the Wall of Sleep, and The Wizard, while great, aren't amazing enough to have it eclipse 3 and 4. Plus the other songs on the debut, while still good songs, aren't even written by them |
TalonsOfFire
05.16.14 | I'm still really conflicted about it though. Honestly if I made this list tomorrow I'd probably move 5 to 3 |
NeroCorleone80
05.16.14 | The Wizard is amazing and Wicked World is just a bonus track |
TalonsOfFire
05.16.14 | I have a weird version of the S/T so I can barely tell what's a cover and what the bonus tracks are, all I know is that Warning is one of the best covers I've ever heard |
NeroCorleone80
05.16.14 | Evil Woman and Warning are the only covers |
manosg
05.16.14 | Being around at the time when 10 was released was magical for a Sabbath fan. It was pretty awesome to read that they were reunited and about to release a live album.
For me their s/t is in their top 4 but yeah nice ranking. |
KingdomOfTyrant
05.16.14 | Master of Reality is 1 |
TalonsOfFire
05.16.14 | K so then the S/T is under 25 minutes of Sabbath so how could it be better than 3 and 4 that each have 5+ amazing
songs |
Veldin
05.16.14 | EELLLEEECCCTTRRRICCC FUNNNEEERRAALLLLL |
Friday13th
05.16.14 | Nice. As long as 1 and 2 are in their place and 8 and 9 are last it's a good ranking. |
ArsMoriendi
05.16.14 | I've only heard 1-6 and.
4 is still my 1. 2 is 2 though.
|
FruityCatOfDoom
05.16.14 | Volume 4 is better than Sabbath Bloody Sabbath. |
ExplosiveOranges
05.16.14 | Master of Reality is their best, hands down. Great list, though. |
TalonsOfFire
05.16.14 | Master of Reality and Paranoid are pretty much interchangeable |
mandan
05.17.14 | I disagree about 5 having filler, but opinions.
Top 2 is Top 2, although I'd switch 'em personally.
I still need to jam 4 again. |
TalonsOfFire
05.17.14 | I guess they all have some filler it's just annoying that over 1/3 of the album is covers there's only 24 minutes of original Sabbath |
Snowdog808
05.17.14 | 5 is so damn low [2]. It should be in the top three, though the other two in the top three are ones we agree on. |
mandan
05.17.14 | Lol Talons, I guess we have different ideas of what constitutes filler. |
TalonsOfFire
05.17.14 | I was slightly disappointed when I found out they didn't write Warning, and they never even cover another song again. I still love it but I'm just saying, there's only 25 minutes of original Sabbath on the s/t compared to the others which have at least 10+ more. |
NeroCorleone80
05.17.14 | The original material there is some of their best songs though.
Also, none of their first 6 have filler except for FX on Vol. 4 |
TalonsOfFire
05.17.14 | Yeah I guess 3 4 and 5 are interchangeable, they all have about 15 minutes on them I don't care about and about 30
minutes of perfection, same with 1 and 2. Like I said in the description, choosing the top 5 was almost impossible and if I
made the list now I'd probably move 5 to 3. |
mandan
05.17.14 | FX could be considered filler, but it's all opinion. |
TalonsOfFire
05.17.14 | What else would FX be lol |
mandan
05.17.14 | I consider it a necessary transition point from Changes to the next track. Makes the switch less abrupt imo. I should give Vol. 4 another listen soon tho, and see if my opinion sticks. |
MrSirLordGentleman
05.17.14 | Abrupt changes are good
Solitude-Into the Void |
mandan
05.17.14 | All auditive perspective man. |
TalonsOfFire
05.17.14 | To be fair Solitude's sort of an extended interlude, I mean its still a real song and amazing but it's more like Planet Caravan than say Symptom of the Universe |
mandan
05.17.14 | Yeah, and those interludes serve a purpose imo.
I also like Am I Going Insane (Radio), although its prob the least strong track on Sabotage, considering how solid the rest of the songs are. |
deslad
05.18.14 | Nice ranking. I'd say 4 is 2 imo. |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.12.14 | nice ranking |
StKiyo
11.12.14 | Maybe it's an unpopular opinion, but I think 13 is better
than Vol. 4 |
NeroCorleone80
11.12.14 | 13 is great but far from Vol. 4. Even Mob Rules is easily better |
TalonsOfFire
11.12.14 | 13 and Vol. 4 are pretty much tied for me, both albums production annoys me at times but 13 is more consistent |
NeroCorleone80
11.12.14 | The best tracks on Vol. 4 absolutely destroy anything on 13. |
ArsMoriendi
11.12.14 | Never heard 13, but Vol 4. is probably the weakest out of the original 6. Still a 4 though. |
NeroCorleone80
11.12.14 | Its one classic song away from a 4.5 |
eddie95
11.12.14 | 5 is too low but good ranking |
StKiyo
11.12.14 | Jammed Vol 4 a few times but I can't think of any standout tracks on it. 13 has End of Beginning / God Is Dead. Maybe it's a grower for me. |
NeroCorleone80
11.12.14 | Wheels of Confusion, Under the Sun, Snowblind and Supernaut are as good as any song on the other first 6, and
easily beat anything from 13 |
TalonsOfFire
11.12.14 | The s/t used to be my 2nd favorite but the others just have a lot more to them |
ExplosiveOranges
11.12.14 | Vol. 4 is aight |
