Telemarketer
08.13.14 | If you're gonna make a list like this, at least give specific examples and use a much more
professional tone. Although I do agree that Kid A is criminally overrated.
Also, it's ironic that you rant about overrated albums after devoting an entire list to that Brand New
album. Talk about overrated... |
Ryus
08.13.14 | 1 wrong
2 wrong
3 correct
4 wrong
5 wrong |
StallionMang
08.13.14 | U2 sucks but the rest are either hard 5s or hard 4.5s so |
BMDrummer
08.13.14 | 1 wrong
2 wrong
3 correct
4 wrong
5 wrong [2] |
Funeralopolis
08.13.14 | 1 wrong
2 correct
3 correct
4 correct
5 wrong |
Funeralopolis
08.13.14 | kid a is so grossly overhyped it is ridiculous album is good for a few listens |
Torontonian
08.13.14 | agree on 3 and 4 can't argue about others cus i havn't heard them. |
L4titudes
08.13.14 | naw |
SeaAnemone
08.13.14 | man if only Kevin Shields had riffs like animals as leaders guy huh |
L4titudes
08.13.14 | cept 3.. U2 sucks [2] |
iBlue
08.13.14 | needs opeth |
pannkakesangen
08.13.14 | no i love opeth... maybe you can make your own list with them on it would love too see that! :) |
Artuma
08.13.14 | "can't argue about others cus i havn't heard them"
listen to them asap ffs |
Tunaboy45
08.13.14 | "its like god made it or something"
Radiohead made it, which is close enough. |
Ryus
08.13.14 | Radiohead made it, which is close enough. [2] |
pannkakesangen
08.13.14 | "Radiohead made it, which is close enough."
thats why people cringe at radiohead fanboys |
ChoccyPhilly
08.13.14 | Everything popular with critical acclaim is bound to be overrated by some |
Telemarketer
08.13.14 | "Radiohead made it, which is close enough." thats why people cringe at radiohead fanboys [2] |
Ryus
08.13.14 | 5.0 classic
Arctic Monkeys Whatever People Say I Am, That's What...
Brand New The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me
DJ Shadow Endtroducing.....
Green Day Dookie
Interpol Turn on the Bright Lights
Metallica Metallica
Nas Illmatic
Pavement Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain
Primal Scream Screamadelica
Radiohead OK Computer
Slipknot Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses)
Slipknot Slipknot
The Smashing Pumpkins Siamese Dream
The Smiths The Queen Is Dead
The Smiths Hatful of Hollow
Tool Aenima
their best album, even better than lateralus in my opinion
Wu-Tang Clan Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers) |
pannkakesangen
08.13.14 | Boards of Canada Music Has the Right to Children
Bruce Springsteen Darkness on the Edge of Town
Converge Jane Doe
Cryptopsy None So Vile
Frank Ocean Channel Orange
Joy Division Closer
Kanye West My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
My Bloody Valentine Loveless
Nas Illmatic
Neutral Milk Hotel In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
Pink Floyd The Dark Side of the Moon
Pixies Doolittle
Radiohead OK Computer
Say Anything ...Is a Real Boy
The Strokes Is This It
The Weakerthans Reconstruction Site
Van Morrison Astral Weeks
Wu-Tang Clan Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)
where are you going with this? |
Matthaios
08.13.14 | Actually, I agree with all of these. 1 is very good but by no means the best shoegaze album ever.
Good work. |
laughingman22
08.13.14 | dam didn't know anybody could hate the pixies |
deathschool
08.13.14 | Another carbon copy list. I swear I've seen this before. Also, yer rong. |
Tunaboy45
08.13.14 | "It's popular and has critical acclaim, therefore it is automatically overrated." |
Havey
08.13.14 | jävla knäppgök |
Judio!
08.13.14 | dammit leave kid a out of this what did it ever do to you? |
Torontonian
08.13.14 | No offense dude. even though on the ones i've heard i agree on that they're overratated. Your not really giving good explanations as to why they are overrated. Also you make it seem like these albums are flat out BAD, which the ones i've heard are not, overrated but still decent. |
ChoccyPhilly
08.13.14 | I didn't say everything popular with critical acclaim is overrated, i just meant stuff that is will be called overrated more often |
Tunaboy45
08.13.14 | Yeah I know. People call the downward spiral overrated all the time when I think it deserves the praise it gets. People always have to bring Kid A into it. 14 years on, it's still probably the most divisive album around. |
Shuyin
08.13.14 | 08.13.14 5 Insanely Overrated Albums 08.13.14 Top 10 Slipknot Songs |
ChoccyPhilly
08.13.14 | Well anyone outside the sphere of people who love the album to death are gonna call it overrated cos of all the praise it gets regardless of what the album is. You might as well rename the list "albums i don't like as much as most of you" |
Ryus
08.13.14 | 07.31.14 American Idiot Ranked |
Tunaboy45
08.13.14 | Well anyone outside the sphere of people who love the album to death are gonna call it overrated cos of all the praise it gets regardless of what the album is. You might as well rename the list "albums i don't like as much as most of you"
[2] |
Snake.
08.13.14 | how the fuck are we supposed to take you seriously when you posted a comment like this on youtube:
Baconhead - Bacon A
1. Everything In its Right Bacon
2. Bacon A
3. The National Bacon
4. How To Disappear Bacon
5. Baconfingers
6. Baconmistic
7. In Bacon
8. Baconteque
9. Bacon Bell
10. Bacon Picture Soundtrack |
pannkakesangen
08.13.14 | "how the fuck are we supposed to take you seriously when you posted a comment like this on youtube:
Baconhead - Bacon A
1. Everything In its Right Bacon
2. Bacon A
3. The National Bacon
4. How To Disappear Bacon
5. Baconfingers
6. Baconmistic
7. In Bacon
8. Baconteque
9. Bacon Bell
10. Bacon Picture Soundtrack"
HAHAHAHAHA how the fuck did you know that you creep? |
Tunaboy45
08.13.14 | I laughed |
Tunaboy45
08.13.14 | "Baconteque"
"Baconmistic"
"Baconfingers"
Best ones. |
ChoccyPhilly
08.13.14 | Bacon Bell sounds tasty |
KrazyKris
08.13.14 | Pinkerton?
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo. |
BMDrummer
08.13.14 | lol just found it |
Artuma
08.13.14 | bacon |
pannkakesangen
08.13.14 | this is fucking hilarious |
ExcentrifugalForz
08.13.14 | user that loves coldplay bashes pixies
smh |
CoolFool1O1
08.13.14 | It's all opinion. |
tempest--
08.13.14 | Doolittle rules |
BMDrummer
08.13.14 | Its Ok but it isnt Ok Computer |
SourAK
08.13.14 | 1 is the only good album here |
NorthernSkylark
08.13.14 | she got hips like cindarella is cool line, bitch |
Hawey
08.13.14 | du är inte den vassaste kniven i lådan du inte |
pannkakesangen
08.13.14 | fuck off svensexa |
NorthernSkylark
08.13.14 | gå nu hjem |
Veldin
08.13.14 | I agree mighty list-maker. They're all good, but by no means the bee's knees. |
LaVidaLoca
08.13.14 | Rrrrrrrrrricky and his albums are all 5s. |
Pheromone
08.13.14 | tbh I agree with everything else but 2 is the best album ever and it isn't even the best pixies |
Supercoolguy64
08.13.14 | I agree with 5
Don't hurt me sputnik |
YakNips
08.13.14 | what an original list how long did it take u to come up with it |
Supercoolguy64
08.13.14 | Hey be happy that he didn't include something like converge |
YakNips
08.13.14 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8EJNGW3kbY |
InbredJed
08.13.14 | 1 wrong
2 wrong
3 correct
4 correct
5 correct
3 out of 5 ain't bad. but damn are you wrong about 1 and 2, hard. |
scottpilgrim10
08.13.14 | w
r
o
n
g
5 |
FrankieFrog
08.14.14 | Agreed super hard on 1. Loveless is boring as fuck. |
Avagantamos
08.14.14 | ALTARS OF MADNESS |
AmericanFlagAsh
08.14.14 | Might as well rename the list "albums i don't like as much as most of you" [3]
Maybe if you actually gave credible explanations on why they are "overrated"
But it just sounds like you don't like them |
MyNameIsPencil
08.14.14 | You can't have a wrong opinion
while I don't agree with 1,2, or 5. I will agree with 3 and ESPECIALLY 4
|
JSJC
08.15.14 |
Finally someone agrees with me on doolittle.I agree that the lyrics suck and the vocals are fucking shit.
|
NorthernSkylark
08.15.14 | vocals are the shit, agreed |
MO
08.15.14 | nice I agree with all these |
Keyblade
08.15.14 | Ugh @ 1 |
bach
08.15.14 | no. 1 brand new fan pannkakesangen chimes in with a hot opinion about loveless |
Mongi123
08.15.14 | That description for Kid A is ridiculous. The praise is not context at all for many people, including myself. And since when does an album being minimal a flaw like come. |
adr
08.15.14 | agree with 1, 3 and 4 -_- |
guitarded_chuck
08.15.14 | op has dookie 5d
complains about power chords |
Keyblade
08.15.14 | Fuckin lol |
ashcrash9
08.15.14 | 3 is overrated. U2's done way better. |
pannkakesangen
08.15.14 | Guitarded_chuck: Yeah I 5d dookie 'cause for nostalgia and the album is actually fun to listen to
Mongi123: What I ment with minimal is that it lacks instrumental depth |
BMDrummer
08.15.14 | "instrumental depth"
what the fuck is this? |
HarryBoBerry
08.15.14 | I've tried so hard to get into Pinkerton, but it still bores me to death. Definitely agreed on that. |
guitarded_chuck
08.15.14 | i like pinkerton a lot but i've never agreed with it being better than blue |
HarryBoBerry
08.15.14 | I do like Pink Triangle, it makes me laugh. Dude thought he was gonna marry a lesbian. |