CK
02.04.15 | Wanna know your opinions |
Kman418
02.04.15 | its still astounding to me this is even up 4 debate
like mhtrtc is great and all but geo basically redefined the concept of art so like |
StallionMang
02.04.15 | Used to think Music was the better album, but recently I've been thinkin otherwise |
StallionMang
02.04.15 | Both stone-cold classics obv |
Artuma
02.04.15 | geogaddi |
zakalwe
02.04.15 | Geo is worst BoC |
deathschool
02.04.15 | Gotta check Geo |
chinesewhispers
02.04.15 | Geo forsure |
Rev
02.04.15 | geo used to be my fav but music grew on me like no other |
Relinquished
02.04.15 | lol I made this list before just to shut down the neverending battle
geo |
zakalwe
02.04.15 | Geo is an overlong meandering extension of what music.... had already laid down. Still good though. |
Ricochet
02.04.15 | shut up zak |
zakalwe
02.04.15 | Apologies dude I keep forgetting I have to bow down to you divs and not actually give me reasons for preference, just keep schtum and do some inane drivel like.
mhtrtc > |
Avagantamos
02.04.15 | geo |
AliW1993
02.04.15 | Music Has the Right to Children for me. Kind of because what zak said, but in slightly less blunt terms. |
Hyperion1001
02.04.15 | i like them both the same for different reasons but geo is obviously the more accomplished of the two and a masterpiece |
Ricochet
02.04.15 | sry for hurting your feelings zak :'( |
Ricochet
02.04.15 | were all friends on this site:):):):):):):)/(/(/):);:kr:kr |
zakalwe
02.04.15 | It's ok dude just give me sometime to get over it, I'll have stopped grinding my teeth by the time BoC release a new album. |
Kman418
02.04.15 | how is geo an extension of what music laid down those are by far their most stylistically different albums |
zakalwe
02.04.15 | Stylistically they both seem like the soundtrack to a 70s educational film about the ocean that the teacher had on video in me school days.
Geo goes on for longer and the 'tracking' needs to be messed about with a bit.
Dig them 80s video references dudes. |
JamieTwort
02.04.15 | Geo is best. |
Avagantamos
02.04.15 | geo is like 1 minute longer, and that's if you don't include happy cycling and magic window/from one source |
Relinquished
02.04.15 | zak's arguments are weak |
zakalwe
02.04.15 | Figuratively geo seems to go on until me headphones have become obsolete tec. |
Relinquished
02.04.15 | there we go |
YoYoMancuso
02.04.15 | Geo >>> Music
Music has Aquarius which is their best song but Geo is more consistent |
Hyperion1001
02.04.15 | "Figuratively geo seems to go on until me headphones have become obsolete tec."
wow tbh thats a great way to describe it
i always feel like ive been phased out by a new model when im done listening to geo |
demigod!
02.04.15 | personally i kinda enjoy music more but both are perfect so... yeah. music for me |
Ryus
02.04.15 | both are fives but i gotta say music |
MeatSalad
02.04.15 | Always liked geo more |
MeatSalad
02.04.15 | Also yeah Aquarius [3] |
CK
02.04.15 | To me, Music... sounds like a collection of musical ideas that were compiled and mixed to make an album, which sounds absolutely amazing, while Geogaddi is more consistent and professional in a sense and builds off of some of Music's better ideas. I just can't decide which I enjoy more |
TheBarber
02.04.15 | 2 is sex so definitly 2 |
Cygnatti
02.04.15 | both are like 2.5s so itsa tough choice for sure |
Graveyard
02.04.15 | music has a stronger set of songs like pete standing alone and roygbiv, but geo is more consistent |
TheBarber
02.04.15 | seriously though mhtrtc feels more playful, intimate and personal (maybe too much at times imo) whereas Geogaddi has some sort of fiery secret immensity within it that def appeals to me more |
Avagantamos
02.05.15 | sunshine recorder, julie and candy, and 1969 are their best 3 songs imo |
TychoBrahe
02.05.15 | Geogaddi ain't no fucking sophomore slump, that's for sure. Could switch spots given time but as it stands I got MHTRTC at #1. |
Relinquished
02.05.15 | it doesn't count as their sophomore, only as a major release LP |
TychoBrahe
02.05.15 | "it doesn't count as their sophomore, only as a major release LP"
Define sophomore effort as you wish, LPs are what we're comparing here. |
Keyblade
02.05.15 | mhtrtc cuz its my favorite album. geo just never resonated with me as much on a personal level, but it's still a masterpiece
also, when is TH gonna be considered for one of these discussions |
CK
02.05.15 | Never |
YetAnotherBrick
02.05.15 | they're both incredible, but i dig Geo's overall atmosphere a bit more |
CK
02.05.15 | Yeah, Geo definitely has this dark, wtf-is-going-on atmosphere, especially on a track like Gyroscope.
Most people are going with Geo |
TheBarber
02.05.15 | MHTRTC is a personnal record, Geo is a sensorial planet record, TCH is a friends around night record,
TH is an empty bleak record; imo |
Graveyard
02.06.15 | geo constantly moves and shifts everytime I listen to it and music is like that long lost photograph
of your childhood |
Graveyard
02.06.15 | the album covers perfectly describe what the records are pertaining to |
Ricochet
02.06.15 | Geogaddi touches the bleak places inside, MHTRTC touches the most beautiful places IMO IMO IMO |
TheBarber
02.06.15 | aww shit I'm feelin' it!
|
Ricochet
02.06.15 | did you drop acid ? |
TheBarber
02.06.15 | no, drugs fuck up dreams |
Relinquished
02.06.15 | that's a good thing sometimes |
Ricochet
02.06.15 | wow "drugs fuck up dreams"... im stumped |
Ichangedmynametojeff
02.07.15 | Haven't heard Music, but I've heard that Geogaddi is the darker one, and i like the dark parts of Geogaddi the most.
So yeah, I'm going with Geogaddi by default by my opinion has no weight here. |
WeepingBanana
02.07.15 | mhtrtc is way fucking better you guys are idiots |
TheBarber
02.07.15 | "that's a good thing sometimes"
true |