MyNameIsPencil
10.25.15 | why 6 so low :[ |
ZippaThaRippa
10.25.15 | You really thought that Descension is their worst album? How come? |
joshuahuntkc
10.25.15 | this is so messed up, like outrageously messed up. 4 is way to high (good album, love all their albums but forreal thats like 2nd or third to last) 6 is easily interchangeble with silent earth for 1st and 2nd ad 1 is not 1 it might be 4 but def. not 1. also decension is underated overall, i dont get the hate |
jmnewcomer18
10.25.15 | Whaaattt? 8 is top 5. Gravitys Union is top 5 Coheed
1
2
8
3
7
6
4
5 |
ZippaThaRippa
10.25.15 | yeah but Gravity's Union doesn't make the whole album. |
jmnewcomer18
10.25.15 | Never said it does, but combined with essentially every other track other than Away We Go it does! |
Rowan5215
10.25.15 | Except like half of Descension is pure shite that outweights Gravity's Union
|
jmnewcomer18
10.25.15 | Except like you are wrong |
PunkMoon
10.25.15 | Claudio is almost 40. |
jmnewcomer18
10.25.15 | Holy shitcakes is he really |
PunkMoon
10.25.15 | Soon he'll be irrelevant. |
TheCrowing27
10.25.15 | MyNameIsPencil for me there isn't a huge drop off in quality through their discography but I find the second half of 6 to be inferior to the first half, where especially 1-3, are a lot more consistent to me |
TheCrowing27
10.25.15 | ZippaThaRippa it's kinda the same thing with 8 as it is for 6. I find the first half awesome, but after Gravity's Union, it really drops off in quality. |
Rowan5215
10.25.15 | Yeah after Gravity's Union that album goes down in flames tbh |
ZippaThaRippa
10.25.15 | Now I can see where you are coming from with 8 but 6 never drops off in quality. Junesong Provision and Neverender are among the best CoCa songs ever written. |
TheCrowing27
10.25.15 | I'm not saying I don't like the songs. For me, it just seems like the first half is definitely stronger than the second. It's probably because I find Devil in Jersey City the best song on the album, so i feel like it never reaches that quality again. It's the same for with No World For Tomorrow after the title track, which isn't good since it's the first "full song" |
PunkMoon
10.25.15 | Everything Evil is the best song they ever wrote. |
PunkMoon
10.25.15 | It's the Platonic ideal of Coheed songs. |
TheCrowing27
10.25.15 | Everything Evil is definitely in my top 10, so I can't disagree with you PunkMoon that it is the platonic ideal of Coheed songs |
TheCrowing27
10.25.15 | even though i have no idea what that means |
Kronzo
10.25.15 | 1 > 2 > 6 > 3 > 8 > 4 = 5 > 7
Best first three albums for a group ever tbh |
elephantREVOLUTION
10.25.15 | second stage is always 1 |
PunkMoon
10.25.15 | Well that's hyperbolic. Velvet Underground? Wire? |
Slex
10.25.15 | anyone who has 6 that low needs to be slapped |
Slex
10.25.15 | good list otherwise tho, I agree with number 1, and then 2 and 6 are interchangeable for me |
Ocean of Noise
10.25.15 | 6 is 1 by far |
Ocean of Noise
10.25.15 | "Best first three albums for a group ever tbh"
not while Black Sabbath exists! |
