TVC15: Most Overrated LP Conceived Round 1 [VOTING NOW CLOSED]

ArsMoriendi 04.02.16	You should set the precedent that someone should only vote if they've heard both albums paired.
Cimnele 04.02.16	2 3 5 7 10 11 13 16 17 19 21 24 25 27 30 32 33 36 38 40 42 43 46 47 49 51 53 55 57 60 62 64
Asdfp277 04.02.16	by far, 5
wwf 04.02.16	I agree with 90% of these
Avagantamos 04.02.16	high violet pinkerton loveless the beatles white blood cells is this it reign in blood painkiller ten nevermind appetite for destruction (my least favorite out of all of these probs) sgt pepper ashes against the grain whatever people say kid a tdagarim master of puppets rust in peace what's the story back in black dookie frances the mute joyce manor weezer tp pimp a butterfly altars of madness the eartth is not a cold dead place bwp vs dsotm is too tough, I like em both
MrSirLordGentleman 04.02.16	Painkiller
FrozenVain 04.02.16	Never understood why discussions likes these are interesting. There are albums that I kinda find overrated but I am also fine with the fact that I might just not get it.
Ryus 04.02.16	white blood cells ashes against the grain whatever people say i am... devil and god fear of a blank planet back in black dookie frances the mute night at the opera sunbather the earth is not a cold dead place
Snowdog808 04.02.16	17, 21, 24, and 43. I would most likely vote against 39 if I would have heard 40.
Snowdog808 04.02.16	Just as a disclaimer, I enjoyed Ten, but not nearly to the same extent as None So Vile.
wwf 04.02.16	if I had to choose one I'd say #5 for sure
TheGreatQ 04.02.16	Joy Division Weezer Joanna Newsom The Beatles Neutral Milk Hotel The Strokes Godspeed You! Black Emperor The Smiths Cryptopsy Swans Nick Drake The Beatles Converge The Clash R.E.M. Radiohead Iggy Pop Metallica Mr. Bungle Kanye West AC/DC Pink Floyd Elliott Smith David Bowie Green Day The Mars Volta Joyce Manor Weezer Kendrick Lamar M83 Deafheaven Deathspell Omega
Ryus 04.02.16	ten sucks dick compared to none so vile it's not even that good in general
AlexKzillion 04.02.16	"You should set the precedent that someone should only vote if they've heard both albums paired." It's kind of different for this tournament though. For example, if there is an album you already have rated a 4.5 or 5 paired against something you have never heard of, it's completely logical to say the album you haven't heard is more overrated because there is no way you can find an album you rated a 4.5 or 5 overrated since you gave that particular album a rating that deems it not overrated in your mind. Edit: That being said, if someone doesn't think either album is overrated in a pair they probably shouldn't vote for either album in that pair.
ArsMoriendi 04.02.16	Just voting for Pinkerton and Loveless for now, from the songs I've heard Newsom's pretty cool
JohnnyoftheWell 04.02.16	Pinkerton Loveless The Downward Spiral Reign in Blood Nevermind Appetite for Destruction Jane Doe The Devil and God Master of Puppets Rust in Peace Blackwater Park Dookie Frances the Mute Weezer To Pimp a Butterfly The Earth Is Not A Cold Dead Place
Greem 04.02.16	9, 11, 13, 27, 28, 33, 39, 50 ,58
chemicalmarriage 04.02.16	I hate successful musicians almost as much as I hate music
DustyTill 04.02.16	3, 27, 28, 30, 33, 39, 49, 56
hesperus 04.02.16	High Violet White Blood Cells Is This It Nevermind Appetite for Destruction Sgt Pepper Jenny Death Fear of a Blank Planet California Back in Black Dookie The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place
Friday13th 04.02.16	1, 3, 6, 7, 10, 11, 14, 15, 17, 19, 22, 24, 26, 27, 30, 32, 33, 36, 37, 39, 41, 43, 46, 48, 49, 51, 54, 56, 58, 59, 62, 64
Snake. 04.02.16	Cool album, but rate it as the 10th best album of all time? Really? Guys, it's just Hip-hop! There's no way it can be better than Dark Side Of The Moon or Close to the Edge.
adr 04.02.16	17,20,27,34,40,42,54
Avagantamos 04.02.16	what are you talking about, snake?
Snake. 04.02.16	dusty's soundoff for TPAB
JeetJeet 04.02.16	46 and 3
FearThyEvil 04.02.16	This might be one of the first overrated lists where I didn't see a tool album on it. As for my pick, 20 by a mile
smaugman 04.02.16	all who vote for 43 are smelly pigs
ArsMoriendi 04.02.16	"This might be one of the first overrated lists where I didn't see a tool album on it. As for my pick, 20 by a mile" It's because the Tool fanboyism has died down :D
DoofusWainwright 04.02.16	Unknown Pleasures (it's good but HV is better so sorry JD) Pinkerton The Seer White Pony (again it's v good but overrated esp on sput) Jane Doe (feels good, she ain't bad but overrated like crazy on sput) Arctic Monkey long album title Paranoid Death Grips whichever album The Devil and God (Iggy lucked out with the draw here, no wonder the smile) Fear of a Blank Planet California (album is a little annoying yes it is) Morning Glory Marquee Moon (good but overrated...much like marquees in general) Dookie Frances Moot Night at Opera with Freddy Wheezer sweater band Hurry up we're dreaming (winner right here end of comp) Earth cold dead you got it
AngryJohnny 04.02.16	Pinkerton Arctic Monkeys Devil and God Dookie
JamieTwort 04.02.16	Painkiller Fear of a Blank Planet Blackwater Park The Mantle
Jasdevi087 04.02.16	Pinkerton Ys Painkiller Ten The Seer Jenny Death I guess Master of Puppets Rust in Peace My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy Blackwater Park Either/Or Weezer
ShadowRemains 04.02.16	for at least half of these, yeah no
altertide0 04.02.16	so just to be sure we're voting for the more overrated one yes? Ys Animals as Leaders Reign in Blood Nevermind Appetite for Destruction Sgt. Murmur Master of Puppets (fight me) Rust in Peace (easiest one ever no idea what Bungle are doing here) Dark Side
smaugman 04.02.16	dark side of the moon both beatles master of puppets dookie
macman76 04.02.16	what would it take for an album to be properly rated?
trve 04.02.16	unknown pleasures pinkerton white the cheesles album aeroplane downward spiral reign in blood painkiller nevermind colorful the cheesles album ashes against the grain powarz dat b master of puppets california american football dark side hunky dory cookie as the roots undo both are fucking shit but the mantle doolittle altars of madness EitS
ChoccyPhilly 04.02.16	2 4 5 7 10 12 14 15 20 21 23 26 28 29 33 35 38 40 41 44 46 48 the rest arent too bad
Shuyin 04.02.16	In the Aeroplane Over the Sea The Seer Appetite for Destruction Jane Doe My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy Sunbather
eaglefan1998 04.02.16	Unknown pleasures white blood cells appetite for destruction painkiller none so vile paranoid weezer
eaglefan1998 04.02.16	and seriously, Either/Or is pretty much the best thing ever
hikingmetalpunk 04.02.16	1 3 6 7 9 14 17 21 24 26 30 32 33 36 38 39 43 46 48 53 56 58 60 62
UnderTheNorthernScar 04.02.16	Painkiller doesn't hope to measure up to sad wings and never will.
onionbubs 04.02.16	4 26 green day isnt really overrated here. just sayin. i typically see more shit towards them here than i do praise.
DoofusWainwright 04.02.16	Onion everything on the list is rated above a 4 so yes Green Day can be considered overrated
DoofusWainwright 04.02.16	LPFTW - that Bungle album is, like a lot of Patton stuff, technically decent but a bit clever clever soulless genre hopping wanky so for sure it can be considered overrated on this site
onionbubs 04.02.16	im surprised dookie is above a 4. i really am
ArsMoriendi 04.02.16	Dookie has exactly a 4. And yeah Mr. Bungle > Faith No More
porcupinetheater 04.02.16	Okay Computer Loveless Animals as Leaders White Blood Cells Is This It Reign In Blood Painkiller Nevermind Appetite for Destruction Sgt. Pepper Whatever People Say That I Am... Murmur Kid A Master of Puppets Rust in Peace My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy Back in Black Dark Side The Lonesome Crowded West Dookie Frances the Mute A Night at the Opera Weezer (Blue album) TPAB Hurry Up We're Dreaming Sunbather Anyone who votes Either/Or or Pink Moon doesn't have emotions
YetAnotherBrick 04.02.16	okay, shit like 9, 11, 17, 27, etc... i get why that's here. but 2, 5, and 6? and 37 and 63? like why are people going after artists like that i don't get it. "overrated" = "i don't like it" apparently
furyroad97 04.03.16	1v2: High Violet 3v4: OK Computer (both of these two kick ass, though) 5v6: Ys 7v8: Animals As Leaders 9v10: White Blood Cells 11v12: Is This It 13v14: Skinny Fists (no one's gonna make me go against Reign In Blood) 15v16: The Queen Is Dead 17v18: None So Vile 19v20: Nevermind 21v22: Pink Moon 23v24: White Pony 25v26: Jane Doe 27v28: Whatever People Say I Am... 29v30: Murmur 31v32: Jenny Death 33v34: The Devil And God Are Raging Inside Me 35v36: Fear Of A Blank Planet 37v38: California 39v40: My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy 41v42: American Football 43v44: Blackwater Park 45v46: Marquee Moon 47v48: Can't believe I'm gonna say it, but Hunky Dory. Classic, but he's got albums on either side of it that are better in my books. 49v50: Rage Against The Machine 51v52: Frances The Mute 53v54: A Night At The Opera (I'm more of a fan of Queen II) 55v56: The Mantle 57v58: This is gonna wreck me, but I'm gonna have to go with To Pimp A Butterfly 59v60: Hurry Up, We're Dreaming (Great album, but Dead Cities is still better in my opinion) 61v62: Altars Of Madness (Morbid Angel's got more credit with me on their next couple albums) 63v64: The Earth Is Not A Cold Dead Place
CaimanJesus 04.03.16	Nirvana Green Day
Zig 04.03.16	Let's do this: The Beatles In the Aeroplane Over the Sea PainKiller Ten The Seer Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band Whatever People Say I Am, That's What... London Calling (What's the Story) Morning Glory? Back in Black Dookie IMO, Beatles are the most overrated band ever existed.
Sevengill 04.03.16	Loveless Skinny Fists The Seer Appetite Paranoid Master of Puppets Weezer Cold Dead Place
Supercoolguy64 04.03.16	my vote goes to pinkerton
ryu 04.03.16	The Downward Spiral Rust in Peace Guilty Pleasures
bowlofsoup 04.03.16	Appetite for destruction gets my vote for that pairing.
Friday13th 04.03.16	"Anyone who votes Either/Or or Pink Moon doesn't have emotions" Voted for both, thank you. While we're at the hyperboles, anyone who thinks those are better than XO and Five Leaves Left is a hipster who thinks average singing and boring acoustic guitar playing is the pinnacle of music.
Frippertronics 04.03.16	2/4/5/9/11/15/20/21/23/41/56
worthlessscab 04.03.16	1, 3, 5, 8, 9, 11, 14, 16, 18, 19, 23, 25, 27, 29, 31, 33, 36, 37, 40, 41, 44, 46, 47, 49, 51, 55, 58, 60, 62, 63
ChoccyPhilly 04.03.16	1 vote for Paracletus, lol
AlexKzillion 04.03.16	Pinkerton The Beatles Painkiller Sgt. Peppers Kid A Fear of a Blank Planet California (What's the Story) Morning Glory Blackwater Park Dookie Doolittle Sunbather
torts 04.03.16	explosions has 10 votes but rage has 3 and downward spiral has 4??? god seriously fuck this site
NordicMindset 04.03.16	Unknown Pleasures Pinkerton Ys The Beatles White Blood Cells Is This It? Reign in Blood Painkiller None So Vile Nevermind Appetite for Destruction Sgt. Peppers Jane Doe Whatever People blah blah blah Murmur Jenny Death Lust for Life Master of Puppets Rust in Peace My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy Back in Black Blackwater Park Marquee Moon Hunky Dory Dookie As the Roots Undo A Night at the Opera The Mantle To Pimp a Butterfly Hurry Up, We're Dreaming Altars of Madness Paracletus
torts 04.03.16	calling jane doe overrated is basically confirming you deserve to be bludgeoned to death
Mystletainn 04.03.16	psychopath confirmed
brandontaylor 04.03.16	unknown pleasures white blood cells is this it i nominated death grips but im voting for kid a lol lonesome crowded west a night at the opera
ZippaThaRippa 04.03.16	As the Roots Undo Back in Black Blackwater Park In the Aeroplane Over the Sea Kid A (jesus) Ashes Against the Grain
trve 04.03.16	didnt add my vote on 8
Riviere 04.03.16	Either/Or, To Pimp A Butterfly
dbizzles 04.03.16	Fuck.... 10 or 2. Going with Neutral Milk Hotel. Sorry.
Slex 04.03.16	Guns n Roses fucking sucks
dbizzles 04.03.16	[2]
Muppelope 04.03.16	Pinkerton Aeroplane Painkiller Ten Appetite for Destruction Sgt. Pepper's Ashes Against the Grain Murmur Rust in Peace Back In Black Dark Side of the Moon Dookie Frances the Mute
Rice303 04.03.16	7,24,48,56
DoofusWainwright 04.03.16	The fact Swans look like they're going to drop out the comp at round 1 puts up a red flag to me saying maybe this tourney won't work lol Hopefully my boy 60 goes all the way
altertide0 04.03.16	The Seer is overrated for sure but it doesn't stand a chance against Nevermind. Very few records do.
Ryus 04.03.16	anyone who votes for american football over back in black makes me sad
JamieTwort 04.03.16	How the hell is Fear of a Blank Planet "losing"? lol
Ryus 04.03.16	that wasn't me. that was ryu (confusing i know). and nah unfortunately back in black is boring as hell
Ryus 04.03.16	and word @jamie
torts 04.03.16	"Also Back in Black is one kf the most badass rock n roll albums conceived I'vr never once heard or seen any mention of it being overrated in anyway until I put up this tourney" badass rock n roll holy fucking log off
claygurnz 04.03.16	Vote for 4 and you die
Artuma 04.03.16	white pony lol back in black frances (although it isn't that overrated imo) hurry up don't bother voting for the other pairings
torts 04.03.16	rock n roll is defined as garbage, plain and simple
claygurnz 04.03.16	Put me down for 11 21 and 41
JamieTwort 04.03.16	Shut up torts.
AmericanFlagAsh 04.03.16	Overrated is still such a stupid word and concept but ok
torts 04.03.16	its not ignorance, its the simple observation that all the bands classified as "rock n roll" are bland, uninspired, and have done absolutely nothing to help the music industry or the culture of music as a whole.
Keyblade 04.03.16	wait are ppl seriously saying that weezer are more overrated than ok computer?
Ryus 04.03.16	word pinkerton>ok computer tbh and people fellate ok computer to no end
Keyblade 04.03.16	im actually shocked it's 18 to 4 wtf lol
torts 04.03.16	ok computer is miles ahead of pinkerton.
torts 04.03.16	yes, I am Front Bottom Brothers I rest my case
Artuma 04.03.16	the front bottoms should certainly be here agreed
Friday13th 04.03.16	What are they, at best a Violent Femmes knock off? They don't even qualify cause no one cares.
claygurnz 04.03.16	Who are these brothers you speak of?
Zig 04.03.16	@LPFTW: I'm aware of the impact Beatles had on popular music scene and they have some good stuff indeed; I mean, it's just something that I'm not fond of, yet I'd heard all their LP's.
adr 04.03.16	"wait are ppl seriously saying that weezer are more overrated than ok computer?" lmaoo, weezer are objectively more overrated
Friday13th 04.03.16	The Beatles are an easy target since being anything but the greatest of all time would make them overrated in the strict sense. I think they're slightly overrated while still in my top 20 bands of all time. People like to suppose they started everything which is false.
adr 04.03.16	the voting is not on pairs how all of you still didn't get that lmao this thread
zakalwe 04.03.16	TDAG!
ChoccyPhilly 04.03.16	'No rhyme or reason to the pairing' suggests pairing to me
sonictheplumber 04.03.16	1
Friday13th 04.03.16	He has counted pairs, said pairs, and made it round 1. I think you missed something, adr.
adr 04.03.16	welp i fucked, my votes are still correct anyway lol
onionbubs 04.03.16	dookie's the easiest target here coz most users dont like green day makes sense why its winning
LotusFlower 04.03.16	64 is the only right answer remove those other votes
RadicalEd 04.03.16	Joy Division - Unknown Pleasures Weezer - Pinkerton Joanna Newsom - YS The Beatles - The Beatles White Stripes - White Blood Cells The Strokes - Is this It Slayer - Reign in Blood The Smiths - The Queen is Dead cryptopsy - None so Vile Nirvana - Nevermind Guns'n'Roses - Every Album The Beatles - Sgt. Peppers Converge - Jane Doe Arctic Monkey - Whatever People Say R.E.M. - Murmur Radiohead - Kid A Brand New - Devil and God Porcupine Tree - Fear of Blank Planet Megadeth - Rust in Peace Oasis - What's the Story AC/DC - Every Album Opeth - Blackwater Elliot Smith - Either/Or Modest Mouse - Lonesome Crowded West Green Day - Every Album Queen - Night at the Opera Weezer - Weezer Kendrick - To pimp a butterfly Deafheaven - Sunbather Explosions in the Sky - Every Album
Keyblade 04.03.16	" lmaoo, weezer are objectively more overrated " are u dumb, okc is considered to be the greatest album in all corners of the internet and beyond. weezer is held in nowhere near as much esteem
Keyblade 04.03.16	7k ratings and 4.6 avg. highest rated alb on rym with 32k votes. like, it's not even close
Friday13th 04.03.16	Keyblade, clearly "overrated" depends on what you think it should be rated. OK computer is overrated because it shouldn't be considered the best; whereas Weezer is overrated because it shouldn't be talked about at all haha
Keyblade 04.03.16	yea man, that's subjective and i actually kinda agree with that haha. but dude said weezer is objectively more overrated which is clearly not even true
Friday13th 04.03.16	true, everyone is in a hyperbole kind of mood
zakalwe 04.03.16	Pinkerton is still an outsider album. It's maybe over praised within its niche. The big daddies are what you're looking at here. Darkside, OKC, Unknown Pleasures, London Calling. The albums that are continually revered as the cream of the crop no matter what. Everybody's heard of 'em or seen something of them and for which anyone giving a first listen to is going to expect way too much of.
Friday13th 04.03.16	True, some of these album arts are primarily seen on memes and t-shirts now
ArsMoriendi 04.03.16	Wait what was the album that invented nu-metal?
adr 04.03.16	yea and 4.4 where the 5's are the most ratings by far for a Weezer album isn't overrated right lol, OKC atleast kinda of deserve it's classic status and rating and it's much better so yeah.
ArsMoriendi 04.03.16	Oh... fair enough that's pretty easy to argue even though I kind of disagree.
AlexKzillion 04.03.16	The first fully fledged nu-metal album is probably Korn-S/T.
ArsMoriendi 04.03.16	Yeah that's what I've always heard^
onionbubs 04.03.16	yeah rage more set the stages of what was to come. ive heard people say faith no more was a big influence too
ArsMoriendi 04.03.16	Faith No More, Rage Against the Machine, Tool, and even bands like Helmet and Nine Inch Nails are all cited as huge influences on nu-metal.
Friday13th 04.03.16	RATM is nu-metal there's really no difference in style between them and Korn
DoofusWainwright 04.03.16	if Swans were still in I'd say a perfect start - still, not bad M83 for the win