macman76
User

Soundoffs 4
Album Ratings 142
Objectivity 62%

Last Active 09-25-20 9:08 pm
Joined 11-12-11

Review Comments 2,122

 Lists
06.14.18 World Cup 2018 04.16.18 Model Talk
04.09.18 Who wants to be a model?* 03.11.18 Most m/'s
02.28.18 Stat Tank 02.27.17 Blog Needs a Name
02.10.17 2016: To Be Sputnik Is to Be Nowhere 12.10.16 Sputnik: A Genre History
12.06.16 The Polls Did Alright12.04.16 Paired Genres
11.27.16 Album Rankings If Only Trve Fans Counte11.23.16 The Top 250 Users: The App
10.30.16 The Top 250 Users10.28.16 The Sputnik Years: The App
10.18.16 The Sputnik Years: The Uncharted10.17.16 2015: We Sputnik?
10.17.16 2014: Sputnik, Like NoPlace Is There10.16.16 2013: Sputnik Will Find Me
More »

Are you a Troll………. Rater?

Same dataset as before (7281 album ratings from all contrib/staff/emeritus reviewed albums scraped circa March 20th), new question: do you rate like a troll? I used the data to give each user a score for 3 types of rating trolling: (1) Contrarian troll, (2) Inliner Troll, and (3) Variance troll. Contrarian troll likes to give low ratings for highly rated albums and vice versa. Inliner troll gives a rating that closely matches the average rating. Variance troll gives every album the same rating (low variance) or gives every album and extreme ratings like 1s or 5s (high variance). I narrowed it down to users with 40 or more ratings (12,516 users) and calculated the (1) correlation of the users ratings to the average rating of the albums they rated, (2) the average number of rating per album rated by user, (3) the number of ratings by the user, (4) the number of ratings per day by the user, and (5) the standard deviation of their ratings. All values were transformed into rank values and a weighted average of the ranks determined you troll rating. For Contrarian Troll, a weight of 20 was given to the correlation, .5 for the average number of ratings per album, 2 for number of ratings, and 1 for ratings per day (weights were determined by a process that can best be described by the shrug emoji and Rachel Ray’s philosophy to measuring ingredients). Same weights were applied to Inliner troll, except the ranks were flipped for the correlation. For Variance Troll, standard deviations were z scaled and the z scales were absolute valued and rank transformed so that a high standard deviation and low standard deviation could be equated. Same weights were applied as the Contrarian and Inliner Troll, except correlation was not included and the transformed standard deviation ranks were given a weight of 20.
1Method Man
Tical


Conceptually, your troll rating increases mostly by your correlation or standard deviation (correlation for the Inliner and Contrarian Troll, standard deviation for Variance Troll) and somewhat by how many ratings the albums you rate have, how many ratings you have, and how many you do per day. Troll rating are presented as percentiles. Top 5s for each troll are presented as well as their other ranks and their values used for calculation. Request yourself, other users, whatever and I’ll post their scores. If you request a user, give their whole username and not that if the user has less than 40 of the albums in this dataset rated, I don’t have values for them.
2Contrarian
Polemic


Contrarians:
User: ISortaHateRadiohead
Cor: -0.04
Standard Dev: 0.03
Rating per Album: 370.79
Count of Ratings: 358
Ratings per Day: 17.9
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
100 % 6.31 % 100 %
3Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: ethos
Cor: 0
Standard Dev: 0.47
Rating per Album: 828.51
Count of Ratings: 330
Ratings per Day: 3
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
99.98 % 6.17 % 97.43 %
4Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: DanielNunes93
Cor: 0.1
Standard Dev: 0.87
Rating per Album: 1105.41
Count of Ratings: 483
Ratings per Day: 0.76
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
99.98 % 7.02 % 49.17 %
5Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: MsPinky
Cor: 0.1
Standard Dev: 0.73
Rating per Album: 1230.38
Count of Ratings: 178
Ratings per Day: 89
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
99.97 % 6.91 % 18.79 %
6Metallica
Master of Puppets


Inliners:
User: Totes
Cor: 0.93
Standard Dev: 0.46
Rating per Album: 1704.23
Count of Ratings: 205
Ratings per Day: 205
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
5.96 % 100 % 99.15 %
7Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: The3013thVermicide
Cor: 0.92
Standard Dev: 1.06
Rating per Album: 1690.19
Count of Ratings: 231
Ratings per Day: 115.5
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
6.65 % 99.99 % 90.72 %
8Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: AdAstra
Cor: 0.92
Standard Dev: 0.69
Rating per Album: 1931.58
Count of Ratings: 251
Ratings per Day: 4.74
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
6.26 % 99.98 % 37.75 %
9Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: TheLast7thVermicide
Cor: 0.92
Standard Dev: 1.16
Rating per Album: 1233.65
Count of Ratings: 649
Ratings per Day: 27.04
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
6.36 % 99.98 % 98.83 %
10Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: Millstone
Cor: 0.9
Standard Dev: 1.03
Rating per Album: 1662.33
Count of Ratings: 422
Ratings per Day: 12.41
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
7.53 % 99.97 % 87.51 %
11Metallica
Master of Puppets


Variancers (or something):
User: ISortaHateRadiohead
Cor: -0.04
Standard Dev: 0.03
Rating per Album: 370.79
Count of Ratings: 358
Ratings per Day: 17.9
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
100 % 6.31 % 100 %
12Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: SpookySkeletman
Cor: 0.63
Standard Dev: 1.34
Rating per Album: 1026.6
Count of Ratings: 343
Ratings per Day: 171.5
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
59.7 % 52.11 % 99.99 %
13Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: BHAR
Cor: 0.84
Standard Dev: 1.32
Rating per Album: 1473.64
Count of Ratings: 277
Ratings per Day: 4.69
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
13.85 % 96.4 % 99.98 %
14Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: destinysManchild
Cor: 0.35
Standard Dev: 0.25
Rating per Album: 1390.93
Count of Ratings: 117
Ratings per Day: 117
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
96.27 % 12.71 % 99.98 %
15Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: slimnosaj89
Cor: 0.66
Standard Dev: 1.43
Rating per Album: 1729.7
Count of Ratings: 124
Ratings per Day: 24.8
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
49.21 % 59.18 % 99.97 %
16Metallica
Master of Puppets


By Requests:
User: theacademy
Cor: 0.26
Standard Dev: 1.49
Rating per Album: 953.56
Count of Ratings: 488
Ratings per Day: 0.22
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
99.34 % 8.2 % 99.94 %
17Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: macman76
Cor: 0.81
Standard Dev: 0.77
Rating per Album: 2800.98
Count of Ratings: 46
Ratings per Day: 0.03
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
6.52 % 82.31 % 1.66 %
18Metallica
Master of Puppets


User: LordePots
Cor: 0.41
Standard Dev: 0.9
Rating per Album: 595.25
Count of Ratings: 1118
Ratings per Day: 1.43
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
93.58 % 18.24 % 55.45 %
19First Blood
First Blood


User: LPFTW
Cor: 0.49
Standard Dev: 1.19
Rating per Album: 1294.6
Count of Ratings: 534
Ratings per Day: 0.48
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
84.76 % 26.4 % 98.83 %
207 Seconds
Committed For Life


User: ArsMoriendi
Cor: 0.58
Standard Dev: 1.09
Rating per Album: 1673.43
Count of Ratings: 122
Ratings per Day: 0.13
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
64.07 % 38.69 % 88.03 %
21Third Eye Blind
Third Eye Blind


User: Titan
Cor: 0.63
Standard Dev: 0.74
Rating per Album: 1294.91
Count of Ratings: 479
Ratings per Day: 0.38
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
58.56 % 51.08 % 12.66 %
22High on Fire
De Vermis Mysteriis


User: Angelboros
Cor: 0.91
Standard Dev: 1.16
Rating per Album: 871.47
Count of Ratings: 548
Ratings per Day: 0.96
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
5.24 % 99.71 % 97.77 %
23Mr. Bungle
Disco Volante


User: discovolante
Cor: 0.62
Standard Dev: 0.91
Rating per Album: 913.72
Count of Ratings: 460
Ratings per Day: 0.27
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
59.87 % 47.85 % 58.47 %
24Nas
Illmatic


User: Nazzadan
Cor: 0.84
Standard Dev: 0.61
Rating per Album: 1189.77
Count of Ratings: 236
Ratings per Day: 1.58
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
11.53 % 96.33 % 67.1 %
25Shania Twain
Shania Twain


User: DoofusWainwright
Cor: 0.56
Standard Dev: 0.96
Rating per Album: 918.86
Count of Ratings: 639
Ratings per Day: 1.83
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
72.66 % 38.15 % 71.35 %
26Hardcore Superstar
Hardcore Superstar


User: Calc
Cor: 0.54
Standard Dev: 0.6
Rating per Album: 859.99
Count of Ratings: 395
Ratings per Day: 0.29
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
74.29 % 33.58 % 67.7 %
27Asia 2001
Strange World


User: hal1ax
Cor: 0.57
Standard Dev: 0.54
Rating per Album: 593.01
Count of Ratings: 354
Ratings per Day: 1
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
70.31 % 38.74 % 84.87 %
28Medicated
Ways to Make You Fall


User: torts
Cor: 0.44
Standard Dev: 1.04
Rating per Album: 1118.28
Count of Ratings: 202
Ratings per Day: 1.2
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
89.31 % 19.83 % 85.84 %
29Spoonion
Spoonion 1


User: onionbubs
Cor: 0.88
Standard Dev: 0.96
Rating per Album: 1639.42
Count of Ratings: 197
Ratings per Day: 1.7
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
7.35 % 99.3 % 71.73 %
30Jessica Drake
Jessica Drake


User: JigglyPDiddy
Cor: 0.89
Standard Dev: 0.79
Rating per Album: 1027.48
Count of Ratings: 611
Ratings per Day: 5.05
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
7.23 % 99.58 % 17.71 %
31Girls of the Internet
Masking


User: Sinternet
Cor: 0.82
Standard Dev: 1
Rating per Album: 621.34
Count of Ratings: 1064
Ratings per Day: 4.57
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
15.76 % 94.25 % 81.45 %
32Jackson Browne
Jackson Browne


User: Jacquibim
Cor: 0.55
Standard Dev: 0.7
Rating per Album: 914.99
Count of Ratings: 601
Ratings per Day: 0.52
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
74.5 % 35.05 % 29.21 %
33RandomWalk
Declaration


User: Asdfp277
Cor: 0.56
Standard Dev: 0.84
Rating per Album: 660.3
Count of Ratings: 260
Ratings per Day: 0.22
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
70.06 % 35.58 % 35.82 %
34Kolovrat
Forged Boots Rock


User: Ovrot
Cor: 0.83
Standard Dev: 0.82
Rating per Album: 1350.53
Count of Ratings: 101
Ratings per Day: 0.05
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
7.57 % 88.55 % 23.91 %
35American Princes
Less and Less


User: pbateman
Cor: 0.75
Standard Dev: 1.22
Rating per Album: 1665.08
Count of Ratings: 201
Ratings per Day: 0.08
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
27.08 % 77.08 % 97.67 %
36Alicia Keys
Girl on Fire


User: Keyblade
Cor: 0.48
Standard Dev: 0.47
Rating per Album: 967.7
Count of Ratings: 175
Ratings per Day: 0.1
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
81.37 % 20.87 % 93.38 %
37Iced Earth
Something Wicked This Way Comes


User: Pangea
Cor: 0.65
Standard Dev: 0.74
Rating per Album: 1061.24
Count of Ratings: 142
Ratings per Day: 0.25
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
50.81 % 52.02 % 10.34 %
38Prince
Batman


User: EasterInTheBatcave
Cor: 0.69
Standard Dev: 1.06
Rating per Album: 1217.53
Count of Ratings: 336
Ratings per Day: 4.54
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
44.94 % 65.9 % 89.55 %
39Radiohead
The King of Limbs


User: theBoneyKing
Cor: 0.76
Standard Dev: 0.82
Rating per Album: 1002.65
Count of Ratings: 156
Ratings per Day: 0.47
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
25.13 % 79.15 % 25.72 %
40Computer Magic
Davos


User: Kompys2000
Cor: 0.39
Standard Dev: 1.05
Rating per Album: 1969.12
Count of Ratings: 26
Ratings per Day: 0.28
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
83.41 % 9.94 % 76.88 %
41Vintersemestre
Jääverisaatana


User: emester
Cor: 0.69
Standard Dev: 0.82
Rating per Album: 731.39
Count of Ratings: 355
Ratings per Day: 0.42
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
42.84 % 64.66 % 27.66 %
42Michael Jordan Touchdown Pass
Cash, Money, Etc.


User: brainmelter23
Cor: 0.62
Standard Dev: 0.75
Rating per Album: 721.84
Count of Ratings: 218
Ratings per Day: 0.2
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
56.43 % 47.69 % 6.06 %
43Thank You
Golden Worry


User: wham49
Cor: 0.59
Standard Dev: 0.63
Rating per Album: 1528.19
Count of Ratings: 106
Ratings per Day: 0.33
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
64.2 % 39.29 % 56.24 %
44The Avocado Tapes
AT019 - Cinchel


User: Avagantamos
Cor: 0.62
Standard Dev: 0.86
Rating per Album: 1180.36
Count of Ratings: 352
Ratings per Day: 0.51
ConTroll InlTroll VarTroll
60.67 % 48.59 % 44.15 %
Show/Add Comments (88)

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy