Staff
Reviews 269 Soundoffs 140 News Articles 34 Band Edits + Tags 58 Album Edits 44
Album Ratings 3575 Objectivity 69%
Last Active 12-23-22 6:13 pm Joined 04-27-15
Review Comments 22,006
| I HAVE TO RANK THE WHALES!!! (Gojira ranked: worst to best)
The title says it all, really. Enjoy! | 7 | | Gojira Fortitude
I'll have to keep giving this more listens and see if my opinion eventually changes, but Fortitude still stands as my least favorite Gojira album. It's not bad, but simply offers no surprises. Many of the riffs are lazily recycled from past albums, and while the material is at least more energetic than Magma, I don't find it nearly as well-written. With that said, there are still plenty of good songs to be found if you dig deep enough; highlights include the beautifully dark "Into the Storm", the intense drum workouts of "Grind", the infectious grooves of "Sphinx", and the understated melodicism of "The Trails". 3/5 | 6 | | Gojira Terra Incognita
As I've stated before, the only reason I have this one so low is because of how inconsistent and filler-y it is at times. However, it still serves as a great launching pad for the band's career. One thing that works well in its favor is that it - along with The Link - represents the most experimental period for Gojira. You'll find everything from straightforward death metal to progressive metal to metalcore to even a little bit of rap/nu metal here and there. And while not all of it hits a bullseye - and a little more focus could have helped the album overall - the level of experimentation has to be admired. 3.5/5 | 5 | | Gojira L'Enfant Sauvage
As much as I still enjoy this album, I do see it as a pretty sizeable step down from the band's previous three records up to that point. The songwriting is very consistent, but also suffers from being a lot more monochromatic as a result; the riffs had already begun to be dumbed down at this point, and more epic 7+-minute tracks were replaced with much more average-length numbers. Still, there are a lot of good songs here; "Explosia", "Liquid Fire", "Planned Obsolescence", "Mouth of Kala", "The Gift of Guilt", and "Born in Winter" are all songs I still return to quite a bit. The other songs are just kinda "ok". 3.8/5 | 4 | | Gojira Magma
And now we reach possibly the most contentious pick of the list. I understand that this is where many Gojira fans starting swearing off the band, but I still have a lot of affection for it to this day. It's the softest album they've put out, but also possibly the most emotional; the Duplantiers were dealing with the grief of their mother's death, so a more subdued and somber atmosphere is perfectly understandable. There are still bangers on here like "Silvera" and "The Cell", but I find that my favorite songs are the most atmospheric and moody ones, such as the title track, "The Shooting Star", and "Low Lands". The latter track still ranks as one of my all-time favorite Gojira songs to this day. 4/5 | 3 | | Gojira The Link
The Link is what I consider Terra Incognita fully realized. It takes the experimental ideas and aggressive riffing of that album and consolidates it into a more cohesive and well-organized package. The highlights here are too many to count: the tribal drumming of the atmospheric opening title track, the crazy twin tremolo riffs found in "Wisdom Comes", the amazing closing breakdown of "Remembrance", the crazy tempo shifts of "Inward Movement"... there's so much good stuff to dig into here. And it was the last time that Gojira would be this adventurous, as they'd move toward new conceptual and musical heights with their next two records. 4.3/5 | 2 | | Gojira From Mars to Sirius
What can I really say here? It's one of the most acclaimed modern metal albums, constantly being praised by fans and critics alike as one of the band's best if not THE best. "Flying Whales" has become Gojira's signature tune, packing a ridiculous amount of mood, tempo, and volume shifts within one single 7 1/2-minute track while making whales the unofficial flagship mascot for the group. Meanwhile, songs like "Heaviest Matter of the Universe", "In the Wilderness", and "From the Sky" demonstrate just how heavy the band's music could be; rarely has standard-D tuning ever sounded so brutal. On top of all this, I just love the environmental concept and how the band link it to mortality itself... something they'd perfect on the next album. 4.7/5 | 1 | | Gojira The Way of All Flesh
Almost 13 years after my first listen, I still consider this the band's peak. It's basically what would happen if they took the From Mars to Sirius sound and made it darker and even more expansive. Joe Duplantier has made it no secret that the record is about his views on death and the afterlife, a concept that's brilliantly executed on cuts like multi-part epic "The Art of Dying" and the intensely emotional title track. The band themselves are on-point here as well, with the album featuring some of the strongest playing in their career. The infectious tapping licks on "Oroborus", the chemistry between Randy Blythe and Joe on the vicious "Adoration for None", the crazy tempo and rhythm shifts of "Toxic Garbage Island", Mario's ridiculous 45/16-time drumming on the main riff of "The Art of Dying", the instantly catchy chugs and melodies of "Vacuity", and so much more. The perfect Gojira album, as far as I'm concerned. 5/5 | |
Koris
05.07.21 | Feel free to judge and roast accordingly | Flugmorph
05.07.21 | pogU | StickFeit
05.07.21 | You're more positive about Fortitude than I expected tbh | Koris
05.07.21 | I mean, I did give it a 3 when I reviewed it... | Flugmorph
05.07.21 | great write-ups fam | Koris
05.07.21 | Thanks man! I appreciate it :] | dedex
05.07.21 | good man. great write-ups indeed
I used to have Way of All Flesh at the top, but these days I think it's gotta be From Mars to Sirius | DaveT0738
05.07.21 | Nice mini reviews on each one, i also got the nu metal vibes from Terra on my first couple of listens but somehow i can't manage to find that sound anymore, and as i said before, top 3 it's spot on m/ | DungeonBoy
05.07.21 | have never been able to get into anything i've heard from these guys, but love me some metal, where's a good place to start? | Snake.
05.07.21 | rank the whales? you don't really believe that do you? | DaveT0738
05.07.21 | > where's a good place to start?
From Mars To Sirius if you wanna jump immediately into the more spicy stuff, or Terra Incognita (debut) if you are genuinely curious about the band in general | DungeonBoy
05.07.21 | thanks dude! I'll give Mars to Sirius a spin, always heard a lot of praise for that one | DaveT0738
05.07.21 | And it's well deserved, it's trully amazing | Flugmorph
05.07.21 | quoting ainsley again i see | Koris
05.07.21 | Thanks m8s
"lol'd when i saw the title"
Yeah, I figured it would be better than using a generic title, lol | Muzz79
05.08.21 | DT my rankings are:
1. From Mars to Sirius
2. L'Enfaunt Sauvage
3. The Way of All Flesh
4. Magma
5. Terra Incognita
6. The Link
7. Fortitude | Muzz79
05.08.21 | Their first two are great but little bit techy/shugg. Greatest ‘jira for mine is the long flowing guitar lines w double bass underneath. From the Sky like | Koris
05.08.21 | Good list! I'm glad I'm not the only one who would rank Magma that high, lol | Emim
05.08.21 | I would have rather seen you actually rank different types of whales | Trundle
05.08.21 | lol, good list name | Koris
05.08.21 | Thank you Trundle :] | Koris
05.09.21 | "I would have rather seen you actually rank different types of whales"
That might be my followup :) | FurtherDown
05.10.21 | I've been revisiting Magma quite a lot and when compared to Fortitude its strengths are really highlighted. As you write, The Shooting Star and Low Lands are especially tasty cuts. Flesh/Sirius is the golden duo though, correct ranking. | Shemson
05.10.21 | This was a title I heard in my head exactly how you intended it to be heard
Top two are easily the best for me, with Sirius just edging it because The Heaviest Matter In The Universe is so good | DaveT0738
05.11.21 | Flesh/Sirius is the golden duo [2] | Thor
05.12.21 | From Mars to Sirius
The Way of All Flesh
L'Enfant Sauvage
The Link
Fortitude
Magma
Terra Incognita | Egarran
05.12.21 | *Psst*
(You have the power to heal yourself)
1. Humpbacks | bigguytoo9
05.14.21 | New album is Garbage all around. | conesmoke
05.14.21 | Haven't checked anything from the duplantiers since fmts. Maybe it's time | Koris
05.14.21 | Check out WOAF, you won't be disappointed | conesmoke
05.14.21 | Oh I own that one as digital cd. I checked it out first. I preferred fmts at the time. I'm thinking I'll go backwards and check the link | conesmoke
05.14.21 | Digipak cd... Fkn autocorrect | DaveT0738
05.14.21 | Yes, check The Link cuz it rips almost as much as FMTS and TWOAF | NorthernSkylark
05.14.21 | White whales > | Egarran
05.14.21 | Yeah it's hard to disagree with the biggest creature what ever done been on Earth | DType
01.28.22 | Lol the title got me good, and top 3 is exactly the same as mine m/ | Koris
01.28.22 | heh, thank you ;] And really, none of this list has changed for me. I do have Fortitude at a 3.5 now, but that's really about it |
|