AnotherBrick
04.22.09 | 1. hell no
2. possibly |
Athom
04.22.09 | you could at least try |
Knott-
04.22.09 | 2 is really rated? Really? It annoys the hell out of me. |
NOTINTHEFACE
04.22.09 | 1, yes. It's far from Pink Floyd's best. 2, not on this site. Maybe amongst the kids at the mall, but I've found that most of those even hate that album. |
ninjuice
04.22.09 | I agree with redsky and Notintheface. |
Lunarfall
04.22.09 | 1. Definitely overrated. WYWH and Animals are leagues better.
2. I actually find this quite underrated in the critics scene. |
ShineOn75
04.22.09 | Dark Side may not be Pink Floyd's best, but it's not overrated |
fireaboveicebelow
04.22.09 | hey143, wish you were here is the most overrated pink floyd record by far |
BallsToTheWall
04.22.09 | Whoa, Maldoror bringing out a large bag of nonsense and falseness all in one out of the kitchen pail. That is if your name really is Maldoror. |
YouAreMySilence
04.22.09 | Put some effort in your lists if you want your opinuin to be valid. |
kintups
04.22.09 | @ YouAreMySilence: Most people complain that I use too much effort in my lists. I'm trying something different. Oh, by the way. Make sure to properly spell your sentences if you want your opinion to be valid. |
Lunarfall
04.22.09 | WYWH deserves all the credit it gets, unlike DSOTM. |
fireaboveicebelow
04.22.09 | The dark side gets credit? aside from tshirts I don't see it anywhere lol |
stoopkid
04.22.09 | 1. Wrong.
2. Nobody cares anymore. |
PuddleSwimmer
04.22.09 | Any band that makes good songs + time = 'an overrated band' |
Skishua71
04.22.09 | DSotM was revolutionary, and changed the face of progressive/space music and deserves its credit. WYWH and animals are underrated DSotM is not overrated. |
Thor
04.22.09 | 1. Not insanely overrated, but it's like the band's 4th best album.
2. Didn't know this was even considered overrated lol |
The Computer
04.23.09 | Any album that has The Great Gig In The Sky and Brain Damage is not overrated. |
Douchebag
04.23.09 | 2 is my favourite album of all time. And I guarantee I am the only person on this site who holds that opinion lol. |
feav233
04.23.09 | Pink Floyd, really? It's not their best album, but it's not insanely overrated
Yea, 2 is a terrible album |
kintups
04.23.09 | @ feav233: Really really. |
marksellsuswallets
04.23.09 | edgy |
myhigherpie
04.23.09 | ... yeah pretty much |
burnafterbreeding
04.23.09 | Kintups, you lost me at giving This Darkened Heart a 4/5. |
kintups
04.23.09 | @ burnafterbreeding: I just got into the band, so I'll probably change my mind later. |
burnafterbreeding
04.23.09 | Hahahahahaha, just listen to that CD one more time and I'm sure you'll recognize the magnitude of its crapocity. |
kintups
04.23.09 | Just did! I changed it to 3! |
burnafterbreeding
04.23.09 | Hahahhahahahaha kintups = my new favorite member. |
kitsch
04.23.09 | lol |
kintups
04.23.09 | @ burnafterbreeding: Huzzah! |
BlackMarketReview
04.25.09 | so true on #2 |
kintups
04.26.09 | That rhymes! |
Vehemence
09.25.09 | Dark Side is NOT overrated imo. Green Day's American Idiot, on the other hand is garbage (again, imo) |
qwe3
09.25.09 | 1 is like their 4th best
2 is alright |
HankHillsAcidTrip
09.25.09 | Out of all the albums you could've chosen, you chose those? Green Day is gay, but they were just kind of a fad. Pink Floyd is alright, but I'm not crazy about that album. |
Fxxkit13
09.25.09 | If anything number 2 is their most criticized, not overrated.
|
qwe3
09.25.09 | nah it's reaaaally overrated, just not on sputnik |
Inveigh
09.25.09 | 1. may be slightly overrated (not on this site though) because I hear people say all the time that it's Floyd's best. Which it is not. It's not even in their top 2 and maybe not even top 3 for me. WYWH and Animals own it.
2. I don't know whether it's overrated or not, but it is one of the worst things to happen to music in a LONG time. There is nothing worse than a shitty album that gets praise from a bunch of high schoolers for being political. Even if it's politics are vague and misguided and the songs suck. I hate Green Day. Pop-punk posers. |